Search This Blog

Thursday, February 04, 2010

Senate Committee digs deep

The  Senate Scrutiny of Bills Committee found a couple of micro details in the Freedom of Information Reform Bills worthy of Government reconsideration- may the Finance and Public Administration Committee that meets tomorrow show similar diligence. If you have the time and interest you will be able to pick up a live broadcast here from 9 am.
The line up is as follows. 
9.00�9.45 am Commonwealth Ombudsman
Professor John McMillan AO
9.45�10.30 am The Right to Know Coalition
Mr Michael McKinnon
10.30�10.45 am Break
10.45�12.00 am Department of Prime Minister and Cabinet
Ms Joan Sheedy, Assistant Secretary, Privacy & FOI Policy Branch
Ms Maia Ablett, Senior Advisor, Privacy & FOI Policy Branch
12.00�12.45 pm Law Council of Australia
Mr Mark Robinson, Committee Member
Ms Téa Paris, Policy Lawyer

FOI: Cat on ladder with a key

It will take a long time for the Opposition to live down its record on the transparency front while in government, but it doesn't mean criticisms aren't worth noting. And some metaphors aren't bad either. Here's the Liberal Member for Paterson, and Shadow Minister for Defence Science and Personnel Bob Baldwin in the House yesterday during debate on Appropriations Bills:
"It is now beyond any doubt that this Labor government has no ability to deliver on any of its intentions, promises or policies. For example, the intent of Operation Sunlight was to increase transparency of budgetary estimates and improve the readability of budget papers, yet this latest appropriation bill still smacks of Labor’s light touch in regard to transparency. An increase in transparency could be described in layman’s terms as being like installing a large glass window in a brick wall, thereby allowing the outside world to peer through and see what is on the other side. However, transparency according to the gospel of Prime Minister Rudd and his Labor disciples would be more akin to installing a small cat flap in the highest corner of the wall which can only be as accessed with a ladder and opened with a key. Now, the only key that regularly opens this cat flap is wielded by the freedom of information laws, and even then the Rudd Labor government does its level best to hinder those attempting to gain access to what should be classified as public information. That is hardly what I would describe as transparency in government."
The contentious issue is how big that glass window really needs to be. Baldwin went on to point out that the Bill included an additional $690 million worth of extra funding for the Department of Defence but no actual breakdown.
"In fact, this bill states that there is $528 million earmarked for ‘the protection and advancement of Australia’s national interests through the provision of military capability and the promotion of security and stability’. A further $108 million is to be used for ‘the advancement of Australia’s strategic interests through the conduct of military operations and other tasks directed by government’. It is plain to see that the level and amount of information substantiating the appropriation of over half a billion dollars of taxpayers’ money is, I am afraid to say, more than just a little light-on; it is downright shameful and a deliberate act of obfuscation."
Back in May last year I wondered if anyone with the skills and experience in such things had done an assessment of the Government's delivery of the promise of Operation Sunlight. Didn't see or hear a word, so still wondering?

Thanks to Open Australia for the Hansard link

Major parties prefer status quo on Senate powers

The titles of these two posts
Senate powers to access documents one of the issues for 2010, in the last few weeks indicate what I was expecting to come out of the Senate Finance and Public Administration References Committee's inquiry into Independent Arbitration of Public Interest Immunity Claims.

But the Committee's Report tabled on Tuesday saw Government and Opposition Members fold the tent on the exercise, recommending against the proposed resolution, leaving Independent Senator Xenophon and The Greens Senator Ludlam to fly the flag, in a dissenting report, for some sort of process that might scrutinise the validity of Executive government claims that documents cannot be provided because the public interest dictates otherwise.

The majority however decided it was all too hard ( see Chapter 2) for the details,  raising as it did, the prospect of curly questions about the powers of parliament versus the executive being decided by the courts

 In tabling the Report, Liberal Senator Cory Bernardi who chaired the inquiry explained that the majority view was "that the process of an opposition seeking to obtain documents from a government and a government claiming public interest immunity grounds for failing to release the documents is part of the combative cut and thrust of the parliamentary process, and indeed to allow an independent party to assess the validity or veracity of the claims of government may indeed ultimately compromise the operation of the executive."

Senator Ludlam, in response said this meant the Senate had to wear Government claims when told ‘You can’t have that material and you just have to trust us as to why not.’
 "What Senator Bernardi did not mention was that every single witness who appeared before the committee on our one day of hearings, and every submission, was supportive of just such an instrument of the Senate and the executive agreeing that an independent arbitrator should be able to make the decisions as to whether—on sight of the documents or not—it is in the public interest for the material to be made public or not. Every witness was supportive—with the exception of officers from the Department of Prime Minister and Cabinet, who had no opinions at all about anything. We heard from some of the best minds in the country—people intimately involved at a Commonwealth level or at a state level in Victoria and New South Wales with the way this sort of instrument has been operating elsewhere—and every one of them was supportive. They went to the trouble of pointing out the flaws in the draft motion which the Greens and Senator Xenophon have acknowledged in our dissenting comments. But they went one step further, none of which was picked up in the majority report of the committee, which was to provide the solution and amendments to the motion to actually make the system work."
I think that noise in the background is recently retired Clerk of the Senate, Harry Evans grinding his teeth.

Thanks to Open Australia for the Hansard link.

Round in circles

The Crikey article by Margaret Simons referred to in her comment on the previous post, about the proposed  shift in onus in AAT reviews, including my comment on hers is here-if you get what I mean.

Wednesday, February 03, 2010

Senate Committee given food for thought on FOI Reform

There was a late rush to meet the deadline - the Senate Finance and Public Administration Committee has published 26 submissions received on the Freedom of Information Reform Bills. All welcome the reforms, with plenty of "buts", and many again reiterate points made but dismissed with no explanation during the Exposure Draft consultation phase last year. Not that they aren't still worthy of close consideration. However the odds are against it now as the Committee has scheduled a morning hearing on Friday in Canberra, with only two outsiders to make it to the table, the Right to Know Coalition and the Australian Law Council. The Ombudsman and the Department of Prime Minister and Cabinet are also scheduled to appear.

The thought strikes me that there was a great opportunity missed in all this to have some dialogue, rather than set pieces, between those in government and those outside to thrash out many of the  views and ideas in these submissions - the couple of hours in Canberra last May where virtually no-one turned up hardly counts. I don't think there was a serious attempt to go for gold on this one.

 My submission (19 on the list) expressed support for the framework proposed and welcomed many aspects of the legislation, but drew attention to
  •  the two year process to get to this point has been slow compared to other Australian reform initiatives, with limited public discussion and debate other than about amendment legislative drafting;
  • the selective and unexplained nature of the Government's approach to acting on "key" recommendations of  the 1995 Australian Law Reform Commission Report, choosing not to act on a number of important recommendations for example to extend the Act to the parliamentary departments, reduce the time limit on processing applications progressively to 14 days, requiring chief executives to ensure full and accurate records are kept. These issues feature in a number of other submissions, including that of the President of the ALRC, so hopefully at least some questions will be asked on Friday;
  •  the proposed abolition of application fees and retention of charges for processing may not be a efficient answer to removing the cost barriers touse of the Act at the least administrative cost, (again picked up by a couple of others);
  •  scope to improve the bills in a number of areas including by specifying additional types of information to be published on the web by agencies, or giving the Information Commissioner  powers to mandate what should be published; reframing the legislation as a right to information not right to documents act; extending the law to cover the administration of parliament; modifying several of the exemption provisions, including removing doubt about "frankness and candour" as a public interest consideration favouring non-disclosure of policy and related documents;  proscribing ministerial involvement in decision making on applications for agency documents and including offence provisions for improper interference with decisions along the lines of new Queensland, NSW and Tasmanian legislation; limiting agency rights to seek AAT review of an Information Commissioner decision on the basis it was wrong, and requiring the Commissioner to defend the decision when an agency takes that step; and widening the criteria for a cost order in favour of an applicant who is substantially successful in the Tribunal.  Again I'm not Robinson Crusoe on a number of these points.
If you've got this far please take a moment to give some feedback  in the survey on the sidebar-thanks. 

    Tuesday, February 02, 2010

    We're Four!

    Just seems like yesterday ....but it's 4 years tomorrow since we started here. 419 posts in our first year, then 334, 428 and 440 last year. We were pleased when we got to several hundred hits a week, but now are regularly around the thousand mark, plus unknown numbers of RSS subscribers, so thanks for your interest. Comments have increased but the topics warrant plenty of discussion so always glad to hear what you think.

    On the sidebar is a simple survey for some anonymous feedback over the next few days - take a moment if you will.  Cheers.

    A case for automatic and routine disclosure

    We can all make mistakes, but would former politicians be a bit more careful with their gold pass expenditure if they knew the details would be automatically and routinely published? Now when wrong claims come to light in response to a Freedom of Information application by the Herald Sun, the Treasurer criticises the misuse of the scheme, describes the behaviour of the former MPs who improperly used the pass as "completely reprehensible" and suggests the perk could go. Yet some people within the system have obviously known about it for yonks. FOI worked here but more  sunlight could help keep users  (and current members) on the straight and narrow.

    SA applies old rules about election comment to new media

    Amendments to the  South Australian Electoral Act that create an offence for publishing commentary on election issues on the internet as well as in a newspaper or magazine, or in a radio or television broadcast, without the name and address of a person who takes responsibility for the publication of the material, came into force on 6 January. The  Advertiser sees it as "Censoring free speech in the secret state", and with the state election next month, a move aimed at its own website, with bloggers, tweeters, other social networks, and even talk-back radio all probably affected.It suggests the legislation will require all contributors to give their real name and address.

    In the broader context:
    The legislation also further enforces South Australia's reputation as a place where secrecy flourishes. It is instructive that similar laws were also enacted in China last year, a country which has yet to embrace free speech. It is also instructive that the Federal Government examined the same issue after the 2007 election and decided to exclude blogs and online comment from any requirement to provide names and addresses. South Australia is a state that grants more suppression orders than any other, it is a state where it is acceptable to leave hundreds, if not thousands, of parliamentary questions unanswered for years at a time, where pursuing Freedom of Information requests is nothing short of a battle.

    Monday, February 01, 2010

    Opposition holds out on political donations

    I can't do better than Stephen Mayne in Crikey today on the annual release by the Australian Electoral Commission of donations to political parties. It's pretty much the same old ugly story, but a tick for Labor for voluntarily disclosing donations over $1000, while the the Opposition which is blocking the change in the Senate sticks to the letter of the law and anonymity for anything less than $10900. Generally on the disclosure front:
    Coalition opposition in the Senate means that not too much has changed on the campaign disclosure front. The figures are still released up to 19 months after the event, there are no consolidated balance sheets, no detailed breakdowns of spending and no restrictions on who can donate. Foreign dictators could pour millions into an Australian political party. Indeed, the Singapore Government gave $20,000 to both major federal parties through Optus, a business whose fortunes are particularly vulnerable to federal laws and regulations.

    Senate Committee's busy reading week

    The Senate Finance and Public Administration Committee has published only 6 submissions received in connection with the inquiry into the Freedom of Information reform bills, but my submission and three others I know of that made it by the deadline last Thursday are yet to appear. The Committee won't have much time to read on the subject, or to organise who it wants to hear from further, as a hearing has been scheduled for Friday 5 February in Canberra, after 3 days of full-on resumption of activities in the Senate. I'll post my submission when it goes up on the Committee website.

    No sign of imminent humbling for arrogance of power

    A couple of readers drew my attention to Humbling power's arrogance by Malcolm Knox in the Sydney Morning Herald on Saturday in which he draws on John Keane (The Life and Death Of Democracy) and ANU academic Dr Janine O'Flynn in suggesting "greater transparency is not necessarily an unalloyed good:
    "In public sector areas where the public's demand for hard data is greatest - schools' performances, hospital waiting times, timeliness of trains and buses - the risk is highest that the pressure to provide transparent information will interfere with the performance of basic functions. ''More accountability can mean less efficiency'' is how O'Flynn explains this tension. ''There has been a huge increase in reporting and performance focus which stretches organisations which are also expected to deliver an efficiency dividend.'' Within the health, education and transport bureaucracies in particular, she says, ''there is a real risk'' that the demands of providing transparent information can paralyse the very functions that are being measured. ''Every public sector organisation is trying to find this balance, between performing the actual functions and 'performing the performance'.''
    There is a point here, and it should be the subject of more discussion and debate.

    But it's been a familiar theme for years that efficiency is said to suffer as a result of public sector requirements for transparency and accountability ( and a whole range of integrity, equity and related processes.) This often then leads to a call to do away with some of the encumbrances that stop the public sector being as cost- efficient (ahem) as private sector organisations. Critics of Freedom of Information for example often cite cost ($30 million in total for the Federal Government last year). Measuring benefits-or the cost of not having such laws- is hard;  comparisons with the hundreds of millions spent on government information and PR activities usually don't rate a mention.

    The public sector must manage functions in the way we expect such functions to be managed in a modern democratic society, and to achieve measurable public policy outcomes in the most efficient way possible.  Meaningful transparency in the conduct of those functions should help guard against simply "performing the performance."  There are pitfalls in performance measurement, and there needs to be some  limit on transparency in the interests of good government.  Generally we're a long way from the danger point.

    Tough and expensive going getting behind Climate Change

    Mike Steketee in The Weekend Australian  had a follow up piece on attempts by Richard Denniss of The Australia Institute to access under the Freedom of Information Act, documents held by the Department of Climate Change, this time those prepared to help inform Minister Penny Wong and her advisers of the details, merits, limitations and criticisms of the Emissions Trading System. Broad requests of this kind aren't the best way to frame an FOI application but you can understand why Denniss went this way, as a previous attempt had been interpreted narrowly so he  missed everything but inconsequential documents.

    You guessed it: the Department said it holds 210,507 relevant documents and told Denniss  the bill would be over $256,586.98:  $73,102.58 for search and retrieval for 4873.505 hours work, $141,383 for 7069.15 hours of decision making at $20 an hour and $42,101.40 for the possible release of 210,507 documents of an average two pages at 10c a copy. And it still reserved the right to knock him back entirely on grounds of substantial and unreasonable diversion of resources.

    What it points up is that applicants who want to get behind government decisions have the dice loaded against them.There are no tools available to assist an applicant before making an application to know what documents exist; applications drafted too narrowly may miss entirely; those drafted broadly to avoid this fate run into cost and delay hurdles. All this before anyone examines the documents to see what might be claimed exempt. In this case Steketee says the Department wouldn't help the applicant by telling him how charges could be reduced if he tweaked his application to cut out costly aspects that were unlikely to contain information of the kind he was really after.

    There is something wrong with a system where an attempt to find out what government's advisers think about a scheme to address what it says is the greatest challenge of our times will take 4800 hours to locate and extract documents, presumably using highly sophisticated technology, and 7000 hours to decide what can be released.

    The Rudd Government's culture change and new law promises may not deliver much improvement. Steketee says the department assured him that in dealing with the application "it has taken into account the provisions and the spirit of the new legislation, even though it is not yet in force and it is mindful of the obligations placed on it by the proposed reforms."

    Well, The Australia Institute as a non-profit will presumably automatically qualify for 5 of those 11942 hours of processing time free under the proposed new charges regime. John or Mary Citizen pursuing the same inquiry won't.

    Friday, January 29, 2010

    Education in the right place

    Terrific to see education on the front pages across the country, and the interest in our schools such that there were 1.5 million hits (this was way off- some reports suggest 4 million plus) on the My School website yesterday. Long may it continue, and lead towards a real "education revolution" through better informed communities, better and better targeted funding, and voice and action to improve the quality of teaching, things that should flow from breaking the hold of public servants, teachers and politicians over the details of what goes in our schools. More transparency should act as an incentive for all to lift their game. It's far from perfect, and opinions including expert those of experts differ on what should be measured and compared, but it's a start. Congratulations to Deputy Prime Minister Gillard for sticking to her guns on this one- her only mis-step throughout was to say the information should be used to badger teachers about performance, which wasn't quite the way to get the school year off to a good start.

    As to the NSW law banning publication in newspapers and magazines of anything other than the stats as they appear on the website-brickbats to the NSW Opposition and The Greens who foisted this upon us, and bouquets to the NSW print media for taking no notice despite the prospect of a $50,000 fine.

    Thursday, January 28, 2010

    Agencies not necessarily best at publishing what the public wants

    One aspect of the Federal Government's Freedom of Information Reform (Amendment) Bill that will get some attention in my submission today is the pro-active publication scheme. The Bill itself doesn't take things far beyond the current requirements (except for wider publication of some information released to an applicant in response to an application, and information about statutory appointments). While an agency must have regard to the objects of the Act (a plus) and any guidelines issued, the  Information Commissioner has no duty to issue any, or powers to require an agency to publish particular types of information. The Explanatory Memorandum explains this by saying agencies are the best judges of what information they hold that should be published.

    In my view more specificity is required, either in the Act, or by imposing on the Information Commissioner a duty to provide guidance (its a discretionary power at present) and to make some publication requirements mandatory. What happens when agencies are left to their own devices is the current situation that most regard as unsatisfactory. The recent initiative boosted along by the Gov 2.0 Task Force to encourage voluntary publication of data sets is also instructive. Have a look at the current catalogue  at data.australia.gov.au  the home of Australian government public information data sets and the  offerings so far. Some appear useful and of potential interest to particular groups, but how much is new, hasn't been published previously, or is relevant to a wider audience (exceptions for where to find a public toilet around the country or a barbie in the ACT) remains to be seen.

    Melanie Sloan in the Huffington Post (thanks to a reader for the lead) has just written about the results of President Obama's directive to Federal agencies in December to publish three"high value" data sets within 45 days, released last Friday. She similarly finds a mixed bag with many data sets obscure, old, or already publicly available:
    "So what accounts for the widely varying importance of the posted data sets? Undoubtedly it stems from the failure of the (Office of Government Data) to provide any definition or standards for what constitutes a high-value data set. As with other aspects of the administration's transparency initiatives, the OGD is long on aspirations and short on specific benchmarks to measure success. If the administration wants to move beyond rhetoric, however, it must do more than espouse agency transparency. It is time for the White House to get specific and tell agencies precisely what they need to do to become transparent and accountable."
    So should we. Back to the submission.

    Tuesday, January 26, 2010

    Happy Australia Day

    Congratulations to all Australia Day Award recipients. I didn't see anyone singled out specifically for contributions to open government, Freedom of Information or privacy protection - let me know if I missed any - but particular congratulations to the Ombudsman Professor John McMillan, Officer, Order of Australia:
    "For service to the law as the Commonwealth Ombudsman, particularly in the areas of immigration and law enforcement, through leadership roles in professional bodies and as an academic."
    Professor McMillan was a prominent advocate for FOI in Australia way back in the 70's and has been involved in and around this area of public law in various capacities ever since.

    Monday, January 25, 2010

    Memo Senate: Aussies back from beach soon

    www.neatorama.com

    "Reform Now" commented on a recent post about the few submissions posted so far on the Senate Finance and Public Administration website in connection with its examination of the Federal Government's Freedom of Information Reform (Amendment) Bill - five to date. Submissions close on 28 January, and I'm working on a submission to that deadline.

    The reasons for a handful of submissions so far are obvious- the debate during the earlier Government consultation phase, and now, has been framed in a way that it has all been about words in an act, something that effectively sidelines most john and mary citizen types (but two out of five already in are from citizens on a mission), meaning its largely in the hands of boffins. And December/January isn't a great time of year for even boffins to drag out the computer and get to work on dissecting a few hundred pages of legislation (or the associated Exposure Draft on Fees and Charges, on which submissions closed two weeks ago.)

    But fascinating to see Queensland Information Commissioner Julia Kinross in there already (PDF 259KB) arguing strongly a single issue- that Federal parliamentary departments should be covered by the FOI Act. She presents a good set of arguments for something I've been running with for years, so far to no avail.
    However, ahem, the Information Commissioner didn't mention Queensland hadn't taken this step in its 2009 reforms. Parliament there remains outside the Right to Information Act 2009. Tasmania, by my analysis of their Right to Information Act, to commence in July 2010, did take this step. I've yet to hear anyone from the Tasmanian Government,  the media, other commentators or even the Queensland Information Commissioner, mention this important Australian precedent.

    Friday, January 22, 2010

    Two different worlds, we hope...

    On top of a myriad of other problems comes this US Supreme Court decision (see Washington Post's rundown) that finds restrictions on corporate spending in electoral campaigns inconsistent with the First Amendment's protection of political speech. The decision comes after decades of effort to limit corporate influence, but does not address the restriction on direct contributions to candidates, and upholds disclosure requirements for groups that mount advertising campaigns for and against candidates. Just why corporations should enjoy rights originally framed for individuals is a question for another day


    The NSW Parliamentary Research Service has published this useful  Research Paper - Political Donations and Electoral Finance which summarises the state of play here including constitutional issues that have been raised about state based reform efforts.

    Minister reiterates open government commitment

    Special Minister of State Senator Joe Ludwig gives this positive assessment of Federal Government achievements and plans for open government in Fairfax publications today. There's room for qualifiers on some of what he says-a couple of the printed comments suggest pigs are flying - but in the spirit of a new year, and Australia Day, it's a welcome restatement for the record of the commitment to "restore trust and integrity in the use of Commonwealth Government information, promoting a pro-disclosure culture and protecting the public interest through genuine reform". The Minister didn't mention submissions to a Senate Committee on the Government's proposed reform legislation close on 28 January.

    Senate powers to access documents one of the issues for 2010

    The  Senate Finance and Public Administration Committee will be sharpening the pencil this week and next with a report due on 2 February on a problem former Clerk of the Senate Harry Evans describes as one of the biggest facing legislatures around the world: what should be done when a minister, on claimed public interest immunity grounds, refuses to produce documents in response to an order, and the Senate only has a broad statement of reasons  for the claim?

    The Committee is considering a proposal to call on an independent arbiter to determine if the claims are justified. Since the resolution was referred last November, the Committee received 11 submissions and held a hearing in Sydney on 7 December.

    Here's Harry Evans in his first appearance before a senate committee in a private capacity, on the nature of the problem, and how the resolution might help:
    A large part of the problem is that Public Service departments have an instinctive reaction to withhold information from disclosure. If a committee or the Senate itself asks for something and there a vague idea that it is sensitive in some way or it is something that has not been published, the instinctive reaction of government departments is to say, ‘No, you can’t have it,’ and then to think up some plausible reasons why you cannot have it. Then it goes to the minister and the minister more or less feels obliged to support the department. Ministers are naturally reluctant to overrule their department and say: ‘No. I think this information should be disclosed’—although, good ministers should know how to do that. So you have the problem of these cases remaining unresolved.

    If this system were in place, I hope it would deal with the problem at the source back in the department, where departmental officers would say to themselves: ‘If we say they can’t have it, it has to go to the minister and the minister has to make a decision and then, if the Senate is not satisfied, it will go off to this arbitration and we will have to make a submission or produce the information to the arbitrator. That is a very time-consuming and troublesome process. Let’s think more carefully about whether we can really let them have it in the first place.’ I hope that would be the deterrent effect of this process being in place—right back at the source, officers of departments will think more carefully about whether there really are any persuasive and valid reasons for withholding information in the first place.
    The weight of evidence before the Committee suggests the need, if much is to be accomplished, to come up with something stronger than what was proposed - asking the Auditor General (in any claim of commercial in confidence) or an otherwise independent arbiter (in the case of other claims) for a report based on the Minister's stated reasons. The Government is unlikely to find some of the suggestions in submissions and evidence palatable.
     
    Professor Anne Twomey, who has researched and written about the NSW scheme, says the whole exercise will be a waste of time if the proposal goes ahead without a requirement to produce documents to the arbiter. She has other concerns about the proposed resolution, and urged the Committee to ensure the resolution contained clear rules about what qualified for a public interest immunity claim and what did not.

    Clerk of the NSW Legislative Council Lynn Lovelock can't see how the scheme can work without the documents being available to the arbiter. Auditor General Ian McPhee doesn't want a role in any of this, saying that asking him to arbitrate goes beyond traditional functions of his office. Commonwealth Ombudsman Professor John McMillan sees merit, and alignment of functions, in giving the arbiter's job to the proposed Information Commissioner.

    Thursday, January 21, 2010

    The hat you are wearing may have FOI implications.

    This report by Richard Baker in The Age about an unsuccessful Freedom of Information application to the Reserve Bank of Australia for a report on the legality of multimillion-dollar payments to foreign middlemen used to win currency printing contracts, appears to indicate the RBA is claiming that a  document held by an officer of an agency as director of a separate but related entity is not held by the agency , and not subject to FOI.

    According to The Age, the 2007 report by Freehills was for the Board of Note Printing Australia, a wholly owned RBA company. The company and a sister company Securency, jointly owned by the RBA and a British firm, are both chaired by Assistant RBA Governor Bob Rankin who apparently holds a a copy of the report in that capacity. According to The Age the RBA is refusing to release the Freehills report on the grounds that it is ''not a document of the agency'' and ''not within the RBA's purview to release''.

    The odds would appear to be against The Age on this one, but it's an interesting issue. 


    The term ‘document of an agency’ is defined by subsection 4(1) of the FOI Act to mean a document ‘in the possession of an agency’, whether it was created in the agency or received by the agency from another agency or a source outside the government. Possession is the critical factor.

    The RBA response is presumably based on the argument that there is no copy of the report in  RBA's records management system, and any copy held by Dr Rankin has not been received in his capacity as an officer of the RBA, but in his separate capacity as a director of the company. The Age of course might argue that he only holds a copy because he is an officer of the RBA which appointed him, as part of his duties, to be a director of the companies. Therefore it is held by him as an officer in the performance of his duties as an officer of the RBA.


    Good luck.