Search This Blog

Monday, August 13, 2012

Water and wine, trans tasman comparisons of disclosure of ministerial expenses

Another area of expenditure deeply buried here in the various accounts of Federal and state government agencies or ministers' offices and rarely sees the light of day. Nothing publicly that I'm aware of like New Zealand where credit card transactions for ministers and staff are published in a single quarterly publication on-line, together with supporting documentation for purchases.

Ministers McCully and Carr
NZ blogger No Right Turn finds the prospect of disclosure seems to impact behaviour... with the occassional exception. So might we, if we tried it, even if our Foreign Minister Bob Carr, a teetotaller, simply watches what he spends on mineral water:
"I've spent the last hour or so going through the credit card statements, and I'm impressed. The picture that emerges is one of Ministers spending money reasonably and appropriately. There's a few amusing bits - Steven Joyce's lonely snickers bar habit (is he not satisfied?) - but very little really outrageous. Compare this with the pattern of a few years ago when these releases started, and it seems that Ministerial abuse of expenses has decreased significantly. Which both shows the value of such proactive releases, and builds trust in government. The exception, of course, continues to be (Foreign Minister) Murray McCully. He seems incapable of checking into a hotel room without several substantial charges marked "beverage" appearing on the bill (note: this is not drinks with dinner, it is drinks alone). Now, he may have a $50 a night coffee habit. But it reads like he's spending a lot of time in hotel bars drinking our money. Then of course there's the big dinner habit - this time round, an NZ$1200 dinner for 7 in Bali, including NZ$600 for four bottles of wine (and its Australian wine, at that). He hasn't beaten his NZ$233 record for a single bottle, but the average price of those is still well beyond what is reasonable, even given his role.
Proactive release of expenses relies on Ministers having a sense of shame to improve behaviour. But McCully doesn't. He's an uncorrectable recidivist, and its time we dispensed with his services."

Trust us, we're parliamentarians

Federal parliamentarians have learnt or are in the process of learning to live with the scrutiny that comes with public access to information about the use of entitlements, with speaker Peter Slipper the most notable example. But their state parliamentary colleagues are a different matter. Generally they receive or spend money or have money spent on their behalf under opaque arrangements that show no sign of 21st century standards of accountability and transparency.  The administration of all our parliaments should be subject to the same standards as any other government agency. That is, subject to freedom of information law, but these days with information about use of entitlements published in a timely fashion on the internet.

Jebulon
Victoria, Queensland and NSW provide examples of current impenetrable practices. Payments to parliamentarians in these jurisdictions are made by parliamentary departments, unlike Canberra where most but not all are the responsibility of an executive government agency subject to the FOI act, the Department of Finance and Deregulation (and the act for the present at least applies to the parliamentary departments).

In Victoria the administrative departments of the parliament established under the Parliamentary Administration Act would appear not to be agencies subject to the FOI act. In Queensland "the parliamentary service established by the Parliamentary Service Act 1988" is specifically listed among entities not subject to the RTI act (Schedule 2). In NSW the legislative basis for the NSW departments of assembly, council and parliamentary services is obscure but they don't appear to be agencies or public authorities. In 2009 the then presiding officers rejected suggestions in an ombudsman's report that the parliament should be covered by the new FOI act. The GIPA act  lists the Legislative Council, the Legislative Assembly, the office of a member of the council or assembly or the President or Speaker as bodies that are not public authorities or public offices for the purposes of  the act.)

This is the picture as best I can make out. Those newshounds at Fairfax and News publications in Melbourne, Brisbane and Sydney and other watchdogs could do us a service and push this along. Very high or high ratings for honesty and ethics for Federal and state members of parliament in the Roy Morgan Survey of Professionals May 2012: a tie at 10%. Just ahead of the last three of 30 categories, real estate agents, advertising people and used car salesmen.

Thursday, August 09, 2012

FOI peek at minder's diary on hold in Victoria

Not the Kapel diary
The Victorian Government is off to the Court of Appeal seeking to overturn a VCAT ruling by Judge Pamela Jenkins that parts of the Premier's former chief of staff Michael Kapel's diary are subject to the Freedom of information Act. The Herald Sun:
Government spokesman Paul Price last night said: "The Government has appealed VCAT's decision on a question of legal principle arising from what it considers to be the proper statutory construction of the relevant provisions of the Act."
As welcome as the decision was, can't say I'm surprised. See my post here.

On bigger issues, still nothing about the commencement date for the act to create the office of Victorian FOI commissioner-the default date is 1 December-or at least in the public domain, news on who will fill it.

And of course diddly squat on broader reforms including bringing the 1983 act into line with good practice from the reform years of 2007-2010 in other jurisdictions.

One of those changes in NSW, on my reading, broadened the definition of minister's document from the standard "held by a minister that relates to the affairs of an agency", the issue heading to court in Victoria.  Significant chunks of a diary of the chief of staff would be covered by Schedule 4 Clause 11 of the NSW GIPA  act (emphasis added):
A reference in this Act to government information held by an agency is, when the agency is a Minister, a reference to government information held by the Minister in the course of the exercise of official functions in, or for any official purpose of, or for the official use of, the office of Minister of the Crown.

Wednesday, August 08, 2012

Some sovereign wealth funds need to invest in transparency

The Sovereign Wealth Fund Institute based in Las Vegas and its Linaburg-Maduell Transparency Index are new to me but worth a look now Opposition Leader Tony Abbott is suggesting the need to be wary of investment by foreign government controlled entities. None of the criteria listed below sound onerous and both the Australia Future Fund and the NZ Superannuation Fund score 10/10.

Three of five China funds, the State Administration of Foreign Exchange (4/10), China-Africa Development (CAD) Fund (4/10) and National Social Security Fund (5/10) struggle. But there are plenty worse.

On the foreign investment issue generally James Laurensecon a Senior Lecturer in Economics at The University of Queensland writing at The Conversation suggests Abbott needs to be a bit wary as well.
 
Point Principles of the Linaburg-Maduell Transparency Index
+1 Fund provides history including reason for creation, origins of wealth, and government ownership structure
+1 Fund provides up-to-date independently audited annual reports
+1 Fund provides ownership percentage of company holdings, and geographic locations of holdings
+1 Fund provides total portfolio market value, returns, and management compensation
+1 Fund provides guidelines in reference to ethical standards, investment policies, and enforcer of guidelines
+1 Fund provides clear strategies and objectives
+1 If applicable, the fund clearly identifies subsidiaries and contact information
+1 If applicable, the fund identifies external managers
+1 Fund manages its own web site
+1 Fund provides main office location address and contact information such as telephone and fax


Tuesday, August 07, 2012

Transparency in use of taxpayers' money still way short of what we should expect

Readers with a long memory might recall references here to Operation Sunlight an initiative of the Rudd government following years when points were raised by one time Democrats Senator Andrew Murray about the need to improve the openness and transparency of public sector budgetary and financial management. 

And the International Budgetary Partnership in 2010 that didn't even bother to rate our efforts at budget transparency.

Ross Gittins highlighted shortcomings in budget transparency a year ago.
 
So interesting to see the submission from Australian Information Commissioner John McMillan on the Commonwealth Financial Accountability Review (the Review) discussion paper Is Less More? Towards Better Commonwealth Performance particularly concerning  ‘Enhancing transparency and accountability' and ‘Improving performance'. 

All directed to making Australian Government financial information more available and more useful to the public. 

There are a number of important suggestions in the submission. One that commands attention is that the Review consider developing a list of financial information that should be published by agencies under the FOI Information Publishing Scheme. I'd go further and legislate for publication of many of these expenditures:
  • Educational expenses and study leave paid to staff
  • Expenditure on executive coaching, leadership training and media training
  • Paid parental leave
  • Employee expenses as a proportion of the agency budget
  • Expenditure on hospitality and entertainment
  • The value of consultancies awarded by the agency
  • Discretionary grants made by the agency
  • Expenditure on legal services
  • Expenditure on corporate cars
  • Expenditure on taxis
  • Expenditure on advertising
  • Expenditure on media monitoring
  • Expenditure on media subscriptions
  • Expenditure on staff travel
  • Measures taken to absorb the efficiency dividend
  • Staff numbers employed in ongoing, non-ongoing and contract positions, and at SES level
  • Expenditure on entitlements of current and former parliamentarians.
I'd add also all payments made and costs incurred by minsters and ministerial staff.

As the Commmisioner concludes
Some of the items in that list may go beyond the scope of this Review. Some other items are currently published by at least some agencies, for example, in annual reports. However, it would enhance public accessibility and accountability of government spending if a common practice was adopted in all agencies. The IPS provides an excellent framework for developing that common practice; and the Review is well-placed to facilitate or support this development. 

NBN Co's FOI "good behaviour" report card coming soon?

The report by Stuart Morris QC on NBN Co's first year partially subject to the Freedom of Information Act was due to be completed by the end of June so may be tabled soon after Parliament resumes next week. What he makes of things should be interesting in the light of reports of excessive secrecy, and Malcolm Turnbull's comment that no other government agency had ‘‘so frequently frustrated reasonable requests."

Friday, August 03, 2012

Democracy-Can we be Optimistic?

I'm on a panel discussing this at the Northside Forum tomorrow with Professor Johnathon Keane of the University of Sydney and Matthew Thompson NSW Editor of The Conversation. Free, at  the Union Hotel Pacific Highway North Sydney 12-2pm if you have the time and interest. 

Should the size of the turnout determine the answer? 

(Update: 65 on a beautiful Saturday afternoon in Sydney with lots of competing attractions helps to confirm the topic is of interest.The discussion also confirmed, contrary to the ongoing campaign by Allan Jones, that democracy isn't dead, or at least that's what John Keane and I and most in the audience took away. Matthew Thompson, and I'm paraphrasing here suggested most people just want to enjoy life and democracy doesn't excite or warrant attention unless you live under a tyrant. Hmm..


In brief, my take was
  • our democracy has good bones but could do with a few large transplants and supplements, to mention just two, better rules and more disclosure regarding political donations and lobbying. Despite recent rumblings from some of our home-grown muti-millionaires we're nowhere near the situation in the US where the Citizen United decision seems to open the door to billionaires to do their best to buy the election.
  • democracy is no steady state and needs a lot of nurturing and close attention from an informed and engaged citizenry. Now that's an area where the people need to lift the game. We wouldn't rate too high on John Keane's "monitory democracy" scale.
  • no-one should think democracy automatically produces able, intelligent representatives and leaders. With occasional aberrations in fact, mediocre is the word that mostly comes to mind after running over those mentioned in Nick Bryant's recent article on the Global Mail. (As Bryant points out Andrew Leigh Member for Fraser in the ACT appears to be one of those exceptions. Read this recent speech for clear signs of intelligent, reasoned public thinking The Naked Truth? Media and Politics in the Digital Age.) 
 

Wednesday, August 01, 2012

Open Government Partnership plans throw up important ideas, even for by-standers

The Open Government Partnership-Australia and New Zealand do not belong-now has 57 members, with Finland the latest to sign on.(By the by, they are seeking nominations for an International Expert Panel, to oversee its Independent Reporting Mechanism so interesting to see if we have takers-country OGP membership is not a prerequisite.)

A membership requirement based on the idea that everyone has something to learn, and scope for improvement, is to lodge a national action plan

Global Integrity in Washington has just published this analysis of the plans submitted by 45 member countries. A lot of what they say is instructive even for those sitting on the sideline.

Open Data' and 'E-Government' are the most popular commitment categories across the Partnership. accounting for nearly a third of all open government planned activities. Prompting this comment by the author:
It is always encouraging to see countries strive to modernize the machinery of government, but the preponderance of information technology projects in national action plans deserves further consideration. The appetite for neat technological fixes to complex problems shouldn’t eclipse the need for politically difficult but fundamental reform. Eventually all technological solutions run into the limits imposed by the institutional, legal, political, and socio-cultural contexts in which they are embedded. Therefore, essential reforms should be encouraged from the outset to alleviate the unique structural constraints prevalent in particular country contexts. Doing that would expand the frontier of possibility so open data and related technologies can maximize their potential. (Read Tom Slee and David Eaves’ exchanges for an incisive analysis on the promise and limits of open data.) Case in point, there is no technological shortcut to greater judicial transparency in India. Ultimately even the most vibrant open data community and efficient judicial records management system will be undermined by the lack of legislation mandating asset disclosures across the judiciary.

'Citizen Engagement' (not one of Australia's strongpoints)  and 'Access to Information' were the other major categories of activities.

Observations about what's not in the plans also resonate:

 The missing link?
Private sector issues are conspicuously underrepresented in country action plans. Only 44 tags cover issues such as public private partnerships, regulations, private sector transparency, and corporate social responsibility initiatives, to name a few. For the OGP to truly become a broad-based multi-stakeholder initiative, commitments should address the openness of the private sector especially in crucial sectors such as extractives and financial services. Moreover, the Partnership must carve a meaningful role for private sector organizations. It would be a terrible waste of opportunity to ignore the resources and capabilities that the private sector can bring to the table especially considering their active participation in development projects at the behest of governments and international organizations. The yawning gap in awareness and enthusiasm among private sector companies for OGP will need to be addressed strategically by measures that go beyond merely engaging them as suppliers for the Networking Mechanism.
Legislate, don’t “innovate”
Another blind spot in action plans is the marginalization of commitments dealing with the legislative and judicial branches of government. Most commitments focus on government departments under the purview of the executive branch, privileging “innovative” solutions like e-government over the more fundamental and politically fraught legislative and judicial reforms, which are key if the OGP is to embody the grandest notions of open government. Worryingly few commitments are ambitious enough to tackle harder, “stretch” issues such as campaign finance, public asset disclosure, financial services sector transparency, etc., which require the passage of broader statutory reforms. As the Partnership develops, country governments will need to tackle crucial institutional challenges through legislation so the change in the culture of government sought by the OGP can firmly take hold.
There were other surprises as well: Despite the financial crisis giving way to a long tail of persistent recessions globally, not a single country directly commits to opening up financial institutions or services. Similarly, only 10 activities explicitly relate to extractive industries and natural resource issues. One would think that easy access to soft standards like the EITI—with the United States joining as a recent prominent signatory—would make these commitments more attractive for countries to include in their national action plans.

Tuesday, July 31, 2012

Now for the good news



Stephen Horne Managing Director of the NSW Internal Audit Bureau and a stalwart involved in many "better public sector management" organisations and initiatives over the years, finds mostly good news in discussing trends in transparency and accountability- Can I see clearly now? Public sector transparency and accountability

Monday, July 30, 2012

Privacy and press freedom to do what you like

I've just updated-retracted-my comment last Wednesday that you won't read about media invasions of privacy in The Australian as follows:
(Further Update: on 30 July prompting my strike-through in the heading to this post, Amanda Meade in the Media Section of The Australian wrote extensively about the family's complaints to the regulators and plans to take legal action against Seven, WIN and The Illawarra Mercury over their coverage of 13-year old Molly Lord's death. Avenues being explored included trespass, intentionally inflicting emotional harm, breach of confidence and breach of privacy. Space was also given to Molly's father to detail the invasion of privacy by reporters photographers and camera crew.

But will OZ Legal Affairs track down News Limited lawyer Jason Quill for a quote to remind as he has in the past, that there is no existing right to legal action for breach of privacy, and any move to create one by statute would strangle freedom of speech?)
Late addition: Media Watch tonight canvassed the issues as well.

Friday, July 27, 2012

Policy costings should be disclosed-if they're someone else's

Eraser Girl
Mathew Franklin in The Australian reported this week on the Treasury knockback (paywall) to an Opposition Freedom of Information application for documents concerning Greens policies submitted for costing, an arrangement agreed at the time of the formation of the Gillard government. Today Franklin gave the Greens a hammering for hypocrisy given their strong advocacy for open government as Senator Milne defended the Treasury decision to refuse access:
If such costings could be obtained under FOI, Senator Milne said, it would mean parties would be unable to "get a reliable costing to make a decision". The comment was neither logical nor consistent with the Greens long-claimed devotion to openness.
When Franklin rang on Wednesday to seek a comment on the Treasury FOI response I said refusal of access on cabinet document grounds seemed strange. How would the Greens costings end up in a document submitted or proposed to be submitted to cabinet, and prepared for that dominant purpose? So too the Treasury claim the documents were deliberative documents.

Perhaps The Greens shouldn't have been surprised FOI came into play. Senator Milne in the Senate last November in debate on legislation to establish the Parliamentary Budget Office said:
One of the important reasons for the Parliamentary Budget Office is that those costings that you get done between elections remain confidential. If you have to put them to Treasury then they do not remain confidential, and you run the risk in that circumstance of the government anticipating what your election policies might be.
But as to hypocrisy..

Franklin quoted the FOI applicant, Liberal MP Jamie Briggs:
“I don't think that taxpayers should fund the costings of policies of a political party absent the public being able to see those costings,” and  “If the taxpayer is funding the costings of minor parties, they should be able to access the results.”
A far cry from last November when confidentiality for policy costings was the biggie for the Opposition.

For one, all sides agreed so the Parliamentary Service Amendment (Parliamentary Budget Officer) Act 2011 exempts the PBO entirely from the Freedom of Infiormation Act.

For two, Opposition speakers at the time were troubled at the prospect that their policy costings would be released during the caretaker period before an election. In fact front bench senators Mathias Cormann and Scott Ryan then sounded remarkably like Senator Milne now.

Thursday, July 26, 2012

UK committee stands with FOI, withstands blowback

Despite Tony Blair's preference to go down as a "nincompoop" rather than the courageous leader for introducing freedom of information in the UK, and all sorts of concerns from current and former ministers and senior public servants, the House of Commons Justice Committee concluded FOI has been worth the effort:
(Chairman Sir Alan) Beith said the legislation had enhanced Britain's democratic system and made public bodies more open, accountable and transparent: "It has been a success and we do not wish to diminish its intended scope or its effectiveness"..
The Committee's Conclusions and recommendations are here.

The Campaign for Freedom of Information which sensibly has stood guard and sought to protect the act and the principles that underpin it, rather than fade into the sunset thinking the job was done years ago, generally welcomed the report-with a sigh of relief I imagine.

Wednesday, July 25, 2012

Principles for journos dealing with the grief-stricken-stories you won't read (strike-through "in the OZ")

Admissions, sometimes forced, of journalists going over the top in pursuit of the story are common place in the UK  these days with some destined soon for an airing in the courts. But less so here, with assurances from media bosses that everything's rosy. Any attempt to rein in the hounds will see News boss Kim Williams for one off to the High Court.

Crikey yesterday published an account by an anonymous former commercial TV current affairs reporter suggesting the genre regard grieving families as fair game because of a lack of clear guidelines on privacy. And the public is to blame in any event because they love to watch people in distress:
The problem is that for the media it’s just another day at work. But families such as Molly Lord’s may only interface with the media like this once and only during tragic circumstances. What we think is normal and ethical, can often feel is shocking and insensitive. The trouble is, there is no accepted industry-wide standard about how to handle these things. So as is often the case when the rules are unclear, those willing to push the boundaries usually benefit, creating more pressure on those who want to act ethically. A lack of clear guidelines benefits the dodgy and the desperately ambitious in our profession. We also need to have a better discussion around the ethics of interviewing someone who you know is probably in a state of shock. We’ve all done it and nine times out of 10 people are much more likely to talk in this state  But is it ethical? Would they be as willing to share their story 24 hours from now? If the answer is “no” you probably shouldn’t be putting them to tape. And let’s not forget the audience also plays a part. If they didn’t watch, this stuff wouldn’t get to air. They do, and it does."
Sounds a bit like that deputy editor of the Daily Telegraph justifying publication a few years back of  photographs of an unknown red-headed woman wrongly identified as a politician, as in the public interest. The measure? The number of papers sold.

New Zealand Law Commission completes FOI review

The New Zealand Law Commission today released the final report, The Public’s Right to Know: Review of the Official Information Legislation, concluding its 2009 reference. The report evaluates the Official Information Act 1982 and the Local Government Official Information and Meetings Act 1987 in the light of 30 years experience and changing times.

The report reinforces the main principles of the Act but makes 137 recommendations including measures to encourage more proactive publication, improving operational processes, bolstering the leadership role and functions of the ombudsmen and ahem, attention Attorney General Roxon who may be still intending to fix an "anomaly" here, that the parliamentary departments be covered by the OIA.

I'll leave commentary to the kiwis-the government has welcomed the report but that's all so far. (Update: See No Right Turn-"An appalling conclusion"- among other things, lamenting the absence from the debate of OIA users. Know the feeling.)

Some of the 137 recommendations that attract the eye this side of the ditch include:

Monday, July 23, 2012

Opinion not always the basis for a reasonable expectation

The phrase "could reasonably be expected" features in Australia's freedom of information laws in provisions available to justify a refusal of access. It describes the degree of confidence required in assessing the likelihood of potential harms to the public interest that could arise from disclosure. While the law is reasonably settled, recent decisions in the NSW Administrative Decisions Tribunal illustrate that opinion of an official won't necessarily constitute evidence sufficient to justify such a conclusion.

Friday, July 20, 2012

Australia, a cocky on the OGP tin

"Since its launch in September 2011, the Open Government Partnership (OGP) has become the most high profile international movement for greater government transparency in the world."
But Australia (and New Zealand and every country in Asia and the Pacific regions except Indonesia, Republic of Korea, Mongolia and the Philippines) isn't one of the 55 Participating States.  Some in the region won't meet the eligibility criteria, others won't want to fly this particular flag. In our case our reasons haven't been stated, publicly at least. When I raised this earlier in the year, a government spokesperson said we were still considering and consulting. What, and who, who knows?

A contact who follows these developments closely recently suggested that foreign policy considerations- not wanting to be part of a group embracing aspirations that China doesn't share-played a part in our lack of involvement. I'd be surprised. That consideration didn't hold back founding governments such as Brazil and South Africa who share interests with China, for example through BRICS. India did back out after initial enthusiasm, but China's views or sensitivities, if they exist on this question wouldn't have been a consideration. Apparently India's concern was scrutiny that would accompany government self-assessment, and possibly, reluctance politically to engage in a public consultation at home on transparency.

My guess is those considerations loom large in Canberra as well when the hard nosed question "what's in it for us" is asked. Far easier to avoid international nosey-parkers and leave to others leadership in the search for best practice, and international heavy lifting to encourage improved standards in this area.

The Centre for Law and Democracy is already drawing attention to deficiencies in the Action Plans lodged by many participants.

I'm pulling together at present some information about right to information in the South Pacific. It's not a great story in the only region where Australia and New Zealand loom large and are well placed to lead through words, resources and example. The Cook Islands is the only country with an FOI law, Tonga is on the move and there are occasional references to good intentions in a couple of other countries as well. 

But Australia and New Zealand could both benefit directly, and indirectly have influence, from mixing more with those involved in "the most high profile international movement for greater government transparency in the world."

Wednesday, July 18, 2012

Who ministers and minders talk to about what

Jack Waterford in The Canberra Times compares some aspects of transparency in the UK as practiced by the PM and other ministers concerning meetings with lobbyists, with our very own, echoing observations here about the quite word in the ear approach that slides under the radar in this part of the world. "Spot on, Jack"  I say in a comment just published.

In a related matter, an important decision in the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal last week saw Vice President Judge Jenkins take a broad approach to what constitutes an official document of a minister and within scope of the Victorian Freedom of Information Act.

In The Herald and Weekly Times v Office of the Premier [2012] VCAT 967 Judge Jenkins ruled that the diary of Premier Baillieu's former chief of staff Michael Kapel was a document in the constructive possession of the premier and that many entries in a sample provided to the Tribunal related "to the affairs of an agency" even where they did not directly concern departmental business but were relevant to the Ministerial responsibilities of the Premier or any other Minister, as a Minister of the Crown. The range of entries which Judge Jenkins found would qualify for release (subject to any exemption claim) include:
  • (a) attendances involving a range of stakeholders, both with and without the Premier; and both with and without public servants;
  • (b) interaction with public servants, both with and without the Premier;
  • (c) attendances involving Parliamentary colleagues; the media, unions; community, business and ethnic parties and organisations;
  • (d) attendances involving foreign dignitaries, including politicians and diplomats;
  • (e) other entries which may record events, whether or not attended by the Chief of Staff; and
  • (f) entries in the nature of descriptions, observations or outcomes.
While welcoming this new potential extended torchlight on what ministerial advisers get up to, I expect lawyers will be pondering Judge Jenkins finding [at 75] that
"the expression ‘relates to the affairs of an agency’ does not connote direct involvement by an agency in the document per se, but rather whether the document records any act, matter or event which falls within the Minister’s responsibilities as a Minister of the Crown." 
Information of the kind outside scope where similar words appear in legislation, as in this decision by the Australian Information Commissioner, because it relates to party political activity can still be distinguished. But  it seems to me Judge Jenkins has nudged things forward a notch or two.

As Jack Waterford points out, however, you won't find in these parts anything like that published by 10 Downing Street at "Who ministers are meeting'":
 It lists the diary appointments of all British ministers, and of their senior minders, and of their department heads and senior executive officers. It also lists meetings with journalists, and their organisations. Mostly, it gives some clue about the nature of the discussions (David Cameron, October, met with Joe Lewis to discuss redevelopment of Tottenham Hotspur stadium, or, Lockheed Martin, to discuss Warrior upgrade program.) In some case, little lobbying is said to have occurred: Archbishop of Canterbury, general discussion or Bank of England, discussion of economic outlook.

Tribunals not courts, but if it looks like....

You may have been thinking I got to 2500 posts and dropped by the wayside. 
Or off the perch. Not quite.

I've been busy with other things including representing an applicant in a Government Information (Public Access) Act review in the NSW Administrative Decisions Tribunal. That  involved a few visits to John Maddison Tower in Goulburn St where the Tribunal has been located since moving south from long time digs in Elizabeth St in October last year. The former home was in an office block near Sydney's heavyweight legal precinct. The John Maddison Tower and the Downing Centre next door are court buildings in the next tier, with John Maddison home to the District Court including the civil registry and several floors of courtrooms, the Federal Magistrates Court and the Chief Industrial Magistrates Court. These days with the ADT, the Dust Diseases Tribunal, and the Medical Tribunal for company making it a mix of parts of both the executive and judicial branches of government.

Citizens jostling with barristers and solicitors passing through the security check as they enter on the ground floor, and who consult the day's tribunal listings in the foyer affixed to a notice board headed "District Court" may find this a somewhat intimidating, heavily legal environment.

Tuesday, July 10, 2012

Managing not misspending time

Just passed 2500 posts here since this odyssey began in February 2006. Youth aren't the only ones!

Lobbying 101 in Australia: a word please, privately of course

Sharona Coutts at the Global Mail (Rinehart's reach) illustrates what is wrong with our  approach to money and clout being used in the exercise of influence on government decision making- the lack of transparency about who is doing what, to whom, and why.

Registration of third party lobbyists and the requirement for parliamentarians to register interests are laughably light touch. 

Coutts found ministers and parliamentarians who enjoy Rinehart's largesse (not the only one in the game) made the point they are under no obligation to do anything more than comply with the limited legal obligation to declare (trips to India and around the country for instance) but as to who they meet and what they say, that's "private."
It's hard to describe how backwards Australia is in this respect. In the United States, lobbyists are required to lodge regular reports saying who they work for, with whom they've met, what they discussed, and how much they were paid. And all that information is freely available online....
Public officials who meet with these players have a moral duty to disclose the details of all those meetings, so the public can see the links between lobbying and decisions that are made. That duty should also be enshrined in state and federal laws, as it is in countries around the world that have shown they're serious about holding public officials accountable.
Read Who's lobbying in the UK for example, but don't expect to find anything there about the local scene.

In March when Federal parliamentarians took a look, they concluded our current system is just fine.

Now where's that ticket for the Rinehart express, and my Fairfax paper?

LOL.

I spoke to Coutts, and on a similar theme, to The Wire on 2SER.