Search This Blog

Tuesday, March 02, 2010

Black holes at the heart of FOI

Australian Freedom of Information aficionados, familiar with the definitional issues argued up hill and down dale and the absolute nature of the cabinet document exemption in our laws, may know that the UK doesn't have such a specific provision in the FOI Act, although just about everything of this nature is caught by a policy document exemption that at least requires consideration of the public interest. The Government has been moving in the direction of adding a cabinet document exemption to the law but has now backed off.

As Maurice Frankel of the Campaign for Freedom of Information writes in The Independent
The exemption would have carved out a black hole at the heart of the FOI Act. The chances of obtaining cabinet or cabinet committee minutes are already slim. A ministerial veto has twice been used to block their release. But the proposed exemption would also have applied to papers circulated to any cabinet committee.
Ministers wanting to keep their secrets safe could flash them in front of a cabinet committee, instantly prohibiting public access for 20 years. A new top layer of secrecy beyond the Act's reach would have been created.
The old "trolley technique" wouldn't seem to be available anywhere here these days, but I'm afraid we've got our share of black holes. Arguments for making the cabinet document and other absolute exemptions subject to a public interest test have fallen on deaf ears everywhere to date. So have things like following the UK example of extending FOI to the Parliament- everywhere except Tasmania, that is.

Monday, March 01, 2010

FOI= rights+sound economics+........

Nicholas Gruen writing in Government News isn't the first economist to postulate Freedom of Information reform as not just a "rights" issue, but an important matter of micro-economic reform - Stiglitz is just one example. I liked Gruen's couple of instances of well, lateral thinking - post codes that received fiscal stimulus cheques for family payments when, and publication of firms' workers compensation premiums - about disclosures that would advance community interests, the former assisting assessment of the impact of the stimulus, the latter as a measure of workplace safety. Are public servants generally starting to think this way?

Spin and excessive secrecy not a good combination.

Richard Ackland in Secrecy is a denial of our rights in the Sydney Morning Herald on Friday and Hamish McDonald in War spinners on the defensive in the same paper on Saturday wrote on different aspects of the same issue: secrecy in the name of intelligence, national security, foreign relations and defence. Both think the balance we have struck is wrong and compare the situation here in a couple of telling respects with the US and UK. This is a diificult area of course, but it's not a good look for a government under the gun on a range of issues, that made much of its intentions to govern differently from the last lot.

Information Commissioner speaks on the challenges

Here is Information Commissioner Designate John McMillan on ABC Radio AM discussing his role and some of the challenges. The interviewer seems to be hopeful of better access to Cabinet documents in the FOI Reform/Commissioner world but there is only a slither of change to that exemption, and historians will like the fact we're moving from 30 to 20 years for open access under Archives legislation. Public awareness and leadership are up there as  priorities. In my view stronger powers- for example, to require an agency to comply with directions regarding pro-active publication - would aid the Commissioner in the culture change task-but that's another story.
"One of the roles of this new commission will be to take a central leadership in the development of a pro-disclosure culture in government. And we'll do that through familiar ways; through training, through publication of manuals and guidelines, through getting agencies to develop best practice in web publication, but also reaching out a lot more to the community, to journalists and to members of parliament to provide them with essential information about making document and information requests to government."

Friday, February 26, 2010

McMillan an outstanding choice for Information Commissioner

The Commonwealth Ombudsman Professor John McMillan has been appointed Information Commissioner Designate. This is an outstanding choice and evidences the Government's seriousness of intent in this field. McMillan will bring stature, knowledge, expertise and experience to the position and will be on the job getting things moving from 8 March, before legislation creating the position passes Parliament. The process to find a permanent appointee to the equivalent position in NSW, created by legislation passed eight months ago must be getting close to finalisation, having started last September. Let's hope the state government follows the Commonwealth lead with an appointment of someone with similar standing, respect and credentials as McMillan.

The following are extracts from a tribute in the Canberra Times on 26 January this year after McMillan was awarded an AO in the Australia Day Honours.

"Lawman praised for his integrity"
Commonwealth Ombudsman John McMillan accepts that sometimes his role could more accurately be described as a professional thorn in the Government's side.
As the nation's watchdog responsible for overseeing all government agencies, Professor McMillan is the final word on unworkable policy, bureaucratic ineptitude, and administrative bungles which plague an estimated 45,000 frustrated Australians who make official complaints to his office each year.
His constant stream of reports and investigations are highly critical, fiercely independent and often difficult reading for ministers involved.
Most recently, he has condemned the Rudd Government for its unwillingness to process Freedom of Information requests despite its mantra of open accountability...
He describes the Commonwealth Ombudsman's office as providing invaluable "bottom-up" analysis of the health of federal administration.
"The Government often does its own top-down analysis, but to look at individual complaints often shows how the systems works from the bottom up"...
Professor McMillan was first appointed in 2003 for a five-year term under the Howard government and was reappointed for another five-year term by the Rudd Government.
Chosen for his background in public-interest advocacy, Professor McMillan's experience ranges from being a founding member of the Australian Institute of Administrative Law and the Freedom of Information Campaign Committee, to being convener of the Braddon Resident's Action Group and helping save Northbourne Oval.
He was also the Commonwealth Ombudsman's principal investigation officer in 1979 with an academic background which includes being a professor of law and alumni chairman in administrative law at the Australian National University during the 1990s, as well as a member of the board of the faculties and deputy dean of students. He won the chancellor's medal for distinguished contribution to the ANU, 2004, as well as the vice-chancellor's award for excellence in teaching in 1995.

Thursday, February 25, 2010

Plenty more in FOI decision apart from the kitchen cabinet

The "kitchen cabinet" aspect of the decision by Deputy President Forgie of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal in Telstra wasn't the only element of the decision worth noting . Her examination of the law, precedents and findings concerning the cabinet document exemption (provided in the event she was wrong in concluding that the Special Ministers' group was not a cabinet committee), and the internal working document exemption and associated public interest test, provide something of a case book on these issues, worth filing away for future reference.

Health identifiers off to Senate Committee

The Senate yesterday referred the Government's Healthcare Identifiers Bill 2010  to the Community Affairs Legislation Committee for inquiry and report by 15 March 2010.
Reasons for referral/principal issues for consideration:
Privacy safeguards in the Bill
Operation of the Healthcare Identifier Service, including access to the Identifier
Relationship to national e-health agenda and electronic health records.

In introducing the bills Minister For Health Roxon referred to the strong emphasis on privacy considerations and to three Privacy Impact Statements. The Australian Privacy Foundation wasn't happy with the Exposure Draft. The Committee process will give the issue an, or another airing.

Tuesday, February 23, 2010

Archives to stay open..in a fashion

After posting a Boo, hiss last November over Government plans to close National Archives' offices in Darwin, Adelaide and Hobart, pleased to see an "archivists power" led movement resulted in a roll-over of sorts.  University of Sydney FOI staffer Anne Picot features in the 7.30 Report story on the win.

Parliament outside the transparency and accountability loop

David Hawker the federal Liberal MP for Wannon is a former speaker of the House of Representatives and in "Don't starve the watchdog" in The Australian yesterday made a good case for a properly resourced parliament, among other things. Two paragraphs mentioned below deserve comment. Both concern transparency and accountability of the parliamentary departments-House of Representatives, Senate and Parliamentary Services. Hawker is incorrect in claiming the administration of parliamentary entitlements for members and senators is entirely in the hands of the Department of Finance.  But a broader omission is any reference to the absence of accountability and transparency of the legislature as a branch of government allocated significant public funding. The three departments were appropriated $142 million in this year's budget. They should be subject to the Freedom of Information Act, like most of the executive branch, and in respect of matters of an administrative nature, the courts.

The Government to date has shown not a spark of interest in a 1995 recommendation of the Australian Law Reform Commission to this effect. Despite the matter being raised in a number of submissions, and by several witnesses at recent Senate Committee hearings on the FOI Reform legislation, one senator (The Greens Ludlam) asked one question of one witness on the topic. Maybe, like Hawker parliamentarians aren't fully aware of how the system works and the hole in our transparency and accountability framework. But an independent committee due to report next month may give the issue a kick along.

Hawker's two paragraphs -emphasis added- and information about the parliament and that independent committee follow.

FOI in the High Court: Osland case raises soundness of mercy refusal

In the long-running Freedom of Information case that revolves around the circumstances that give rise to the exercise of the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal's override discretion under Section 50(4) of the Freedom of Information Act to require disclosure of an otherwise exempt document where the public interest requires it, the central issue before the High Court will be the Victorian Court of Appeal's view of the proper application of the provision. However the case will also see issues raised relevant to the soundness of the Attorney General's decision to refuse Mrs Osland's petition for mercy.  The grounds for the High Court (Chief Justice French and Justice Keifel) granting special leave to Mrs Osland to appeal were something along these lines:

(a) The Court of Appeal did not perform the task required of it in accordance with the High Court's remittal in that it failed to determine that, in the circumstances of the present case, s 50(4) of the Freedom of Information Act 1982 (Vic) was enlivened as a result of material differences in the various legal advices the Attorney General received

(b) The Court of Appeal erred in concluding that, notwithstanding the content of the press release, there was nothing in the content of the legal advices  and nothing in the revealed differences and the extent between those advices, that attracted the operation of s.50(4) of the FOI Act.


(c) The Court of Appeal ought to have found that the Attorney General's press release announcing his decision was misleading, lacked candour or was otherwise materially inaccurate or incomplete and, as a consequence, s.50(4) was enlivened.

Former Federal Court judge Ron Merkel QC instructed by Nieva Connell of Hunt and Hunt appeared for Mrs Osland.The appeal is likely to be heard in April.

Perhaps it is easy to see from a government perspective why Commonwealth FOI Reform legislation leaves untouched the unique limitation on the Administrative Appeals Tribunal in the FOI area, compared to its powers in other areas of jurisdiction, to not extend to an override discretion. The Law Council of Australia's Mark Robinson argued the case for change at a recent Senate Committee hearing, asserting that full merits review of administrative decisions required that the external review body has all the powers of the original decision maker. Commonwealth FOI decision makers have always had a discretion to release a document found to be exempt. While Opposition Senator Brandis showed some interest, so far no-one in Canberra has been having any of this for the last 28 years.

Mrs Osland was convicted of the murder of her husband, after having endured years of domestic violence, but her son who committed the act was acquitted. She was sentenced to 14 years 6 months imprisonment with a non-parole period of 9 years 6 months and released on parole in July 2005.Mrs Osland initially won the right to access legal advice that formed the basis for the Attorney General's decision to refuse the mercy petition. Appeals have been running ever since.

Monday, February 22, 2010

AWB knew, should government have twigged?

The admission by AWB Limited, in settling a class action brought by a group of shareholders, that it knew money being paid to transport wheat  to Iraq was being illegally siphoned to Saddam Hussein's government all along, after battling through the Cole Royal Commission claiming innocence, is an appalling comment on the standards of honesty of those involved. And a reminder of the way Cole may have been put on a side track by the Howard Government, and a few other things besides.

Howard's kitchen cabinet not the real thing

While making it clear that government leaders are at liberty to establish whatever decision making processes they wish, a decision last week by Deputy President Forgie of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Telstra and Department of Broadband, Communications and The Digital Economy [2010] AATA 118) points up the problem that will arise from a Freedom of Information perspective in setting up a group of ministers and treating it as if it is a cabinet committee, even though it isn't. When push comes to shove, as in this case harking back to FOI applications in February and May 2007, documents provided to the group won't qualify as cabinet documents.

After almost writing a book on what constitutes "the government" and related issues and considering the evidence, Deputy President concluded:
When I have regard to all of the matters to which I have referred,  I have concluded that the Senior Ministers’ group was not a committee of Cabinet. It was treated as a group that was analogous to a committee of that sort but its being treated in that way does not make it a committee of that sort. There is no evidence of Cabinet’s having decided that the Senior Ministers would be able to make decisions on certain matters that would be binding upon Cabinet itself, as in the case of the NSC, or that their decisions required Cabinet’s discussion and ratification, as in the case of decisions of the ERC. If the Senior Ministers were a committee of Cabinet, it would be expected that there would have been some formal decision about the status of their decisions. On the evidence I have, there is none. It would be expected that there would be some reference to the work of the Senior Ministers in material available to the public or at least to the legislative arm of government. An obvious place to reveal its existence would have been in PM&C’s Annual Reports. If not there, then it would be expected that information about its existence would have been available from the Cabinet Secretariat as directed by the Cabinet Handbook but it was not. There is no reference to be found. Unquestioningly, the former Prime Minister was within his rights to create the Senior Ministers’ group and to direct its tasks as he would. Having regard to the findings I have made, however, I am not satisfied on the evidence that I have that he established it as a Cabinet committee either on an ongoing or an ad hoc basis.[149]
The decision covers important ground regarding public interest considerations in the internal working document exemption, the subject of another post. The "kitchen cabinet" issues were as follows.

Slow-no?- progress in the Capital Territory.

Whatever happened to the ACT Assembly Committee inquiry into the Freedom of Information Act?

Impressive terms of reference were adopted in April last year, but apart from three published submissions including one from the Australian Press Council there is no visible sign of activity since, and no report date for the Committee. Given the ACT Act is basically the same as the Commonwealth Act, perhaps it's been shelved until those reforms are settled, but no-one seems to have said as much.

NSW guidance on GIPA Act

The NSW Office of Information Commissioner published more guidance material on Friday on the Government Information (Public Access) Act including two Knowledge Updates-  transition arrangements on repeal of the FOI act, and application of the public interest test, the latter pretty basic in terms of the sort of thing agencies are looking for. And a revised Business Plan that includes a reference to regulations already drafted that are set to commence with the GIPAA but no indication of what the regulations address.  There has been nothing further from the OIC on when the act will commence since "in the near future" started to appear this year.

Sunday, February 21, 2010

Senate Committee hearing on FOI Reform bill

The transcript of the Senate Committee hearing on Freedom of Information Reform legislation in Melbourne on 15 February has been published although not as of now up on the Committee page. All witnesses  highlighted areas that warrant further consideration, or raised questions about why other changes had not been included. There were some questions from committee members on areas of possible interest but I wouldn't be at all confident we struck much of a chord. Somewhat ominously NSW Labor Senator Cameron, who together with Victorian Labor Senator Ryan appeared to be the only member other than Chair Senator Polley from Tasmania. to stay throughout all the evidence at both hearings, asked every witness whether they supported the bill even if no changes were made. We all individually said yes. My guess is this fact will feature prominently in the report due on 16 March. Even though there is plenty of room for warranted improvements.

But I'm still open to surprises.

Friday, February 19, 2010

Advice documents mostly sacrosanct

A couple of weeks ago Minister for Climate Change Penny Wong was quick off the mark releasing what was described as a summary brief containing analysis by the Department of the just announced Opposition policy. However when the issue arose in Senate Estimates hearings of what other advice she had received, in addition to the two pages released, it emerged there was plenty more, but don't expect to see it until the Government is good and ready, or maybe in open access records in 20- 30 years.  Here is the thrust of the discussion( Finance and Public Administration 08/02/2010 F&PA 118):

Curiosity or legitimate public interest?

Roll on that foreshadowed culture change. In the meantime...

Stephen Kirchner of Institutional Economics and the Centre for Independent Studies writing in The Australian today, recounts efforts, including finally a successful Freedom of Information application, to obtain a copy of a speech last September by Executive Director of the Foreign Investment Review Board whose other hat is General Manager of the Trade and Foreign Investment Division in Treasury. What to make of attitudes to the free flow of information where a speech on an important topic the subject of wide debate isn't routinely posted on the web, and requires a formal application? And as characterised by rejection by Colmer of an application for waiver of the $30 application fee on public interest grounds:
"mere curiosity on the part of a person or a substantial section of the public will generally not constitute a public interest ground. I am not satisfied there is a public interest sufficient to warrant the waiver of the $30 application fee in this case"
Mere curiosity? More like a legitimate public interest in informed discussion and debate on a matter of major national significance.

Kirchner says the speech is still not available from the FIRB (how will they cope with the  disclosure log proposed in the FOI Reform Bill?) but he has posted a copy on his website, as he says, for the benefit of the many foreign investment professionals and journalists who also suffer from "mere curiosity".

Public interest immunity to protect collective cabinet responsibility

In recent Senate Estimates hearings for the Department of Prime Minister and Cabinet, amid questioning of Minister Ludwig and officials about the Government's claim that no special deal had been offered those on board the Oceanic Viking, Liberal Senator Ronaldson made a concerted effort to get the names of those who attended a meeting of the Cabinet border protection committee where decisions on the matter were taken, in particular those from the Prime Minister's office.  The Minister refused, claiming public interest immunity and providing this statement of reasons (Finance and Public Administration 08/02/2010 at F&PA74).
"Disclosing the identity of ministers who attend cabinet meetings or cabinet committee meetings—I will deal with this issue first—would be contrary to the public interest because it would tend to undermine, as I indicated earlier, the collective responsibility of cabinet. It does that by inviting speculation about the collective basis of agreed outcomes, and this is consistent with the practice of successive governments. The relevant staff may attend meetings of the cabinet and its committees and working groups to provide advice when required depending on the subject matter under consideration, but they are not decision makers. Disclosing the name of ministerial staff who were present at particular cabinet meetings or cabinet committee meetings would also tend to undermine the collective responsibility of cabinet."
Senator Ronaldson responded that the names of members of  cabinet committees were public knowledge ( they are in the Cabinet Handbook, but remember this from earlier last year ?), called the Committee into a couple of closed meetings where it decided not to press the matter further, and finally said he may ask the Clerk to investigate. Given the fact that Labor and Liberal senators who sat on the committee have recently recommended against an independent arbiter proposal to deal with these sort of stand-offs, the issue won't run too far.

Revealing names of ministers in the room at a particular meeting would reveal also who was not there, so this must be what the Minister meant by the line invite "speculation about the collective basis of agreed outcomes." And the name of ministerial staff present could maybe suggest the subjects being discussed or angles being considered, or indicate whether that minister was or wasn't present. Still it seems something of a stretch to suggest disclosure "would..tend to undermine the collective responsibility of cabinet."

Thursday, February 18, 2010

Queensland first RTI review decision published

There is a long tail to the review of Freedom of Information decisions by the Queensland Information Commissioner, with half a dozen decisions (going back some time) published in the last month or so, on applications made under the FOI Act, the act replaced by the Right to Information Act in July. Transition arrangements mean anything on hand at that time, and the pursuit of available review rights are to be dealt with under the FOI Act.

But a decision made in October and only recently published (why so slow?) appears to be the first review of a decision under the RTI Act. The decision in the end is primarily about a refusal to neither confirm nor deny documents are held. The published summary of Tolone and the Department of Police (220006 9 October 2009) gives the gist of how the Police took a while to get on the right track in pressing the right exemption claim and the complex steps involved in following the RTI public interest decision-making formula, something the full text brings home more clearly. The formula as the Commissioner sets out is:
Section 49 of the RTI Act sets out the steps which must be taken when deciding whether disclosure of information would, on balance, be contrary to the public interest.  The requirements of section 49 of the RTI Act must be read in conjunction with the public interest factors listed in schedule 4 of the RTI Act.   Schedule 4 of the RTI Act sets out factors  irrelevant to deciding the public interest; favouring disclosure in the public interest (Part 2 Factors);  favouring nondisclosure in the public interest (Part 3 Factors); favouring nondisclosure in the public interest because of public interest harm in disclosure (Part 4 Factors.) In determining whether disclosure of information, would, on balance, be contrary to the public interest under section 47(3)(b) of the RTI Act, I must  identify any irrelevant factors that apply in relation to the information and disregard them; identify public interest factors favouring disclosure and nondisclosure that apply in relation to the information; balance the relevant factors favouring disclosure and nondisclosure; and decide whether disclosure of the information, on balance, would be contrary to the public interest.

Wednesday, February 17, 2010

FOI reform comparisons- the Commonwealth and NSW

In preparation for speaking to an audience in Sydney today about the Commonwealth and NSW Freedom of Information reforms, I put together information about the reform processes and some high order comparisons between the two laws based on the Commonwealth Reform bills, as introduced, passing the Parliament. My notes, if you are really interested.