That's in essence what I told the Senate Finance and Public Administration Committee hearing on the Freedom Of Information Reform bills this morning, in my appearance by telephone. I used my opening remarks to welcome the legislation as a step in the direction of more open and accountable government. Many points made in the various submissions to the Committee had previously been raised in response to the Exposure Draft a year ago, with little reaction from the government and even less explanation, so it was a pity the opportunity for discussion and debate about best practice had been missed. With the Committee with a month to report, and an election somewhere down the track this year, it was now important that the legislation pass, with the broader, wider reforms perhaps left for another day. However while grabbing the half a loaf on offer, the Committee should be interested in a couple of additional slices.
This blog takes an interest in issues associated with Freedom of Information (FOI) and privacy legislation in Australia. Information contained on this site is general in nature and does not constitute legal advice. Follow Peter Timmins on Twitter: @foiguru Follow the open government cause through the Australian Open Government Partnership Network. www.opengovernment.org.au and @opengovau
Search This Blog
Monday, February 15, 2010
FOI Reform half a loaf, but needed soon, so grab a few extra slices
That's in essence what I told the Senate Finance and Public Administration Committee hearing on the Freedom Of Information Reform bills this morning, in my appearance by telephone. I used my opening remarks to welcome the legislation as a step in the direction of more open and accountable government. Many points made in the various submissions to the Committee had previously been raised in response to the Exposure Draft a year ago, with little reaction from the government and even less explanation, so it was a pity the opportunity for discussion and debate about best practice had been missed. With the Committee with a month to report, and an election somewhere down the track this year, it was now important that the legislation pass, with the broader, wider reforms perhaps left for another day. However while grabbing the half a loaf on offer, the Committee should be interested in a couple of additional slices.
Mrs Osland's Christmas yet to come-HIgh Court to decide again
Thanks to Harley Schumann at The Lamp Post, which keeps a close eye on the High Court, for alerting me that the Court on Friday granted another special leave application to Marjorie Osland in the long running battle over a Freedom of Information application for documents concerning her petition for mercy. Here's Harley:Secretary, Department of Justice v Osland (No 2) [2009] VSCA 69 Marjorie Osland is back in the High Court. She is still seeking documents under FOI legislation that relate to her petition for mercy. It must be like Christmas over at Open and Shut.
Christmas? Not quite, but I think it's a reference to comments I made at the time about observations by the Victorian Court of Appeal in a decision that overturned a decision of the then President of the Victorian Civil and Administrative Appeals Tribunal in exercising his public interest override powers, to grant access to documents containing legal advice . Like this for example, which to my mind was a significant reading-down of the discretion:
"(i)t is.. outside the scope of s50(4) for this Court to decide, as a matter of generality, whether there should be public scrutiny of legal advices received by a Minister in connection with the making of an executive decision. That is so whether the public interest is said to reside in greater transparency or in greater accountability… Whether ministerial accountability entails the production of legal advices relied on by ministers in making decisions, and if so in what circumstances, is a policy question which will fall to be considered, if and when it arises, by the executive or by the legislature."
I don't know the grounds for the application or what was said in granting it, but look forward with interest to reading the transcript and to the eventual hearing on the substance.
ABC Radio has just picked up the story.
Thanks again Harley.
ABC Radio has just picked up the story.
Thanks again Harley.
NSW information about Government Information
The Office of Information Commissioner NSW on Friday published four fact sheets for members of the public about the Government Information (Public Access) Act (not commenced), and an e-learning module that is pretty basic, but a useful resource for anyone who hasn't followed the development of the act, and for those public servants who need only the general gist of the new law. The materials don't address the nitty-gritty isues that agencies who face the task of applying the Act on a day to day basis require. Except this from the Fact Sheet What is the public interest test? was heartening, and prospective applicants might like to keep it handy:Under the Government Information (Public Access) Act 2009 (GIPA Act), all government agencies must disclose or release information unless there is an overriding public interest against disclosure....
The identification of one or even several public interest considerations against disclosure is not sufficient justification to refuse to provide information. Agencies will make their decision after balancing the relevant considerations for and against disclosure. In each case, agencies will consider a range of factors, including:
· the nature and context of the information
· in the case of an informal or formal request, any factors special to the applicant
· the relative weight of public interest considerations for and against disclosure.
Agencies should refuse to disclose information only where, on balance, there is an overriding public interest against disclosure. Where considerations on balance favour disclosure, or are evenly balanced, the presumption in favour of disclosure stands, and information should be published or released.
As the Fact Sheet explains,there are 12 categories of information where there is always an overriding public interest against disclosure, but the guidance on the balancing test, where relevant, is positive stuff.
There isn't much in these materials that suggests the ongoing attention that is necessary to promote the cultural shift from the excessive secrecy the Ombudsman and former Premier Rees declared was at the root of the problem. No quotes from the Premier or the Attorney General, rallying ministers and the troops in readiness for a new era of open government, or urging citizens to take a closer interest in what government is up to. And the Fact Sheet The role of Right to Information Officers makes the job sound distinctly clerical, with no hint of involvement in, leadership of, or support for a concerted effort to champion the cause and win those hearts and minds of crusty types in the system who might be wedded to old ways. These are essential if the legislation is to achieve its purpose.
With the new legislation to commence "in the near future" and an Information Commissioner to take up duties "soon", another matter on which silence prevails is what the NSW Law Reform Commission has told the Government about a reference last June to examine how the new oversight regime should work. As the Acting Commissioner's Right to information in NSW guide last September recounted [2.4]:
In April 2006, the Government asked the NSW Law Reform Commission to review the State’s privacy laws, including whether a statutory cause of action should be introduced for invasion of privacy. In June 2009, the Attorney General expanded this reference to specifically include the relationship of right to information and privacy laws. The Commission will also report on how these laws should be administered, with specific attention to the relationship between the Privacy and Information Commissioners. Report on these issues is expected in late 2009.
The Law Reform Commission's Annual Report 2008-2009 [page 9] similarly states that this and another report on the reference were to be completed by the end of 2009.
At one minute to midnight (or so) no sign of the reports, at least in the public domain.
Sunday, February 14, 2010
Federal Information Commissioner lurking?
The Courier Mail was running ahead of itself with a reference to the federal Information Commissioner in this article at the end of January about violent incidents at public venues in Queensland. There isn't such a position, let alone an occupant at present, and Karen Curtis is the Federal Privacy Commissioner. Does the CM know something the rest of us don't?( a mistype more likely as implied by the commenter.)
Friday, February 12, 2010
Any connection between your bank data and US authorities?
Way back in 2006 questions were being raised here and elsewhere about access by US agencies to details of bank transactions outside the US, and the privacy implications, said to be a necessary element in the war on terror. So interesting to see the European Parliament has rejected an agreement for sharing bank data that allow US authorities to monitor Europeans' financial transaction data from SWIFT, the international banking transfer system.It's been going on for 9 months under interim arrangements. Lots of voices that the vote represents a major setback for international security, with a few such as the German Minister for Justice claiming it enhanced not only data-protection in Europe, but also democracy, and was therefore a victory for all EU citizens.
In October 2006 when the issue blew up here, the Federal Privacy Commissioner said she was considering having a closer look at Australian banks and access to data issues arising from their use of SWIFT, which all our banks use to facilitate international financial transactions. There is a reference to SWIFT in the Commissioner's Annual Report 2006-2007, but I couldn't quickly track it down. The Australian Privacy Foundation gave the Australian banks collectively their biggest danger to privacy award that year.
Focus on information not documents a NSW step in the right direction
One of the positive aspects of the NSW Government Information (Public Access ) Act (yet to commence) is that it moves into the modern world by providing a right of access to information. It's a significant move away from the Freedom of Information Act 1989 focus on "documents", evoking as that term does, images of piles of paper, manila folders, and large repositories to store them (not that all these aren't still important in the accountability context.)
The reality is that these days just about everything created or held by a government agency is rendered into a digital format with the bits and bytes stored electronically. Those within the system have sophisticated technology available to identify, retrieve and consolidate that information, as and when the need arises, for agency purposes. The new act will require an agency to use these resources to locate and provide requested information for applicants. And it limits charges to time necessarily spent in efficiently dealing with the request, so paper hunting or shuffling won't be necessary in many instances.
It also means the end of puzzling about what Section 23 of the Freedom of Information Act means. The section headed "Information stored in computer systems etc" requires a search of computer systems only when an agency doesn't hold a written document containing information of the kind requested.
In a recent decision different interpretations of the provision by Administrative Decisions Tribunal members surfaced. The new act contains no equivalent, simply requiring a reasonable search for information using equipment available for retrieving information stored electronically, limited only by an out where a request would involve substantial and unreasonable diversion of resources. The agency can put all that it finds into a new record where this seems sensible. All a very good step forward in my opinion.
Further Senate Committee hearing on FOI Reform Monday
The Senate Finance and Public Administration Committee is back to the Freedom of Information Reform Bills on Monday with a hearing in Melbourne, and a broad range of witnesses speaking to their submissions including academics Johan Lidberg and Moira Patterson, yours truly, the Australian Law Reform Commission, Australian Press Council, Victorian Privacy Commissioner, Public Interest Advocacy Centre and Liberty Victoria. Details here but no broadcast by the look of it. All submissions suggest the reforms are good, but scope to do better.
Thursday, February 11, 2010
Yes Minister: political interference in Freedom of Information decisions
From The Canadian Press:
"Last summer, Sebastien Togneri (a top political aide to the Minister) issued a terse email to officials in the Public Works Department telling them to "unrelease" a report on the government's real-estate portfolio when he learned it was being sent uncensored to The Canadian Press. The news agency had asked for the 137-page document under the Access to Information Act, and had paid all photocopy fees. Togneri insisted that only 30 pages be released. The file contained sensitive information about the performance of the government's real estate portfolio, such as missed targets and high maintenance costs. A bureaucrat had to dash down to the Public Works mailroom to retrieve the sealed package. And for the next three months, public servants, Justice Department lawyers and consultants all agreed there was no legal basis to withhold any of the document. Despite that consensus, Togneri's view prevailed and the heavily pruned report was sent to The Canadian Press 82 days later than required by the law."
When this was revealed, according to The Canadian Press, the Minister didn't even thrash Togneri with a feather, commending him as "an employee who has exceptional parliamentary skills." Then, I expect to Togneri's delight, announcing "he won't be in charge of access-to-information files anymore." There has been plenty more in the news in Canada about this since, with claims it was an isolated incident and the Prime Minister's Office restating ministers staff should not interfere in such things.
The point in drawing attention to this Canadian story is that in three Australian state jurisdictions this sort of conduct could see the Tognieris of this world in serious hot water. New FOI laws in Queensland (commenced) NSW and Tasmania (yet to commence) include offence provisions for the first time. They're laws you hope never need to be used but their presence on the statute book would have to have a salutary effect. Togneris in Canberra however needn't be alarmed-there is nothing of this sort in the Commonwealth Freedom of Information Act, and no glimmer of interest in going down this path, as evidenced by the Government's FOI Reform Bill, now before Parliament.The states' move is an example of an emerging Australian standard ignored by the Commonwealth Government in its reforms.
Glad to hear here, anytime
The Age"The government wants to blog" is the headline to Finance Minister Lindsay Tanner's piece in the Sydney Morning Herald, today, something a bit different from other headlines of barbs exchanged with Barnaby Joyce et al. The Minister tells readers about the thrust of the Gov 2.0 Task Force Report received in December and some of what it advocates for greater government engagement with the community. There are acknowledgements of present failings:
"Dialogue with citizens tends to be one-to-one, not general. We broadcast a lot to passive audiences, but when it comes to more active engagement, we're still in the dark ages."
And the magnitude of the task ahead:
"More freely available information and deeper engagement between government and citizens will improve the quality of government regulation and services. It will also challenge public servants and politicians to move beyond traditional mindsets of secrecy, hierarchy and control. While that's great in theory, it won't be easy in practice."
Open invitation anytime here folks to participate in discussion of - open government etc. A Google search shows the Minister had a brief go at blogging himself two years ago.(Correction - thanks to a reader - Tanner writes a weekly blog, Razor's Edge on the National Times, where the Herald piece probably started.)
Last week IT Wire reported the Victorian Government is on the move in this area, embracing Creative Commons publishing, starting on a government wide information management framework and putting some money on the table for a competition to encourage developers to start using the state's available data sets.
Wednesday, February 10, 2010
FOI law protects confidential complainants
December and January saw quite a few Freedom of Information decisions around the country, and I'm behind in mentioning some of interest.
Two NSW Administrative Decisions Tribunal cases illustrate that the identity of complainants or those who provide similar confidential information about an individual is well protected by exemptions in the NSW Freedom of Information Act. While the personal affairs ( Clause 6, Schedule 1) and confidential information (Clause 13(b)) exemptions are the usual provisions relied upon, there are others that are rolled out from time to time.
In Head v Commissioner of NSW Police [2010] NSWADT 27 Judicial Member Montgomery acknowledged the interest the applicant in seeking access to information in relation to complaints that were made against him as a serving NSW Police officer, and his concern about aspects of a resulting investigation. The applicant contended that the information, if disclosed, would enable him to defend himself from what he believed were false allegations. Judicial Member Montgomery said any discrepancies in the investigation were matters to be pursued through appropriate channels. The Tribunal should not attempt to cure defects that might exist in those processes. The Tribunal’s role was to determine the correct and preferable decision in regard to the status of documents under the Freedom of Information Act. He found the withheld parts of documents concerning complaints- names, addresses and personal information -was information concerning personal affairs, and that disclosure in the circumstances would be unreasonable (Clause 6) ; and that statements or names and addresses of third parties were provided in confidence in a personal capacity (including some from internal sources); disclosure might undermine the provision of such information in the future; and as it was unlikely that disclosing the contents of the statements and letters would enhance the Applicant's understanding of the investigation in any significant way , the public interest in maintaining the exemption outweighed the public interest in disclosing the contents of the documents. (Clause 13(b)).
In Starr v Sydney Water Corporation[2010] NSWADT 28 Judicial Member Montgomery found details of the Corporation's employees and contractors who complained about the applicant, a person in a longrunning dispute with the Corporation, alleging bullying and harassment, were exempt under the confidential information exemption (Clause 13(b)). . Somewhat surprisingly Judicial Member Montgomery [71-77] also found that the disputed documents were exempt under the business, commercial and financial affairs exemption (Clause 7(1)(c)) as they contained information about the Corporation's treatment of employees and contractors in the performance of their duties and its response to the matters raised by them about dealing with the applicant. It was unnecessary to consider other exemption claims for the documents (legal privilege (Clause 10) and operations of agencies (Clause 16)).
Not all complaints are made on the basis of confidentiality but those that are, or deserve such treatment are well protected.
Kirby set for privacy champion award
Speaking of honours, nice to see that former Australian High Court judge Michael Kirby AC is to receive the 2010 International Privacy Champion award from the Electronic Privacy Information Center (EPIC).The award recognises his work, at the time President of the Australian Law Reform Commission, to develop the OECD international privacy guidelines that have provided the basis for laws, agreements and frameworks around the world since 1980.
Orders of Australia beyond question?
During Estimates hearings of the Senate Finance and Public Administration Committee on Monday (08/02/2010), The Greens Senator Bob Brown raised with the Governor General's Official Secretary (F&PA 44-46), the issue of unsuccessful nominations for honours (446 of 738 nominees or 60% were successful this year) that led to discussion about the Council for the Order of Australia, how it operates, the fact that there is no review of decisions process, and no access to information about how decisions are made.In passing Senator Brown commented he "was aware that the council is exempt from freedom of information. That is another matter of concern." On a related matter, the Official Secretary said advice received was that as the Council is not an agency it is not accountable to the parliament, but took this question on notice.
The Official Secretary is the Secretary to the Council so there is an interesting question whether documents held relating to the Council's work are covered by the Freedom of Information Act, even if the Council itself is a separate body outside the scope of the Act. Section 6A provides:
Official Secretary to the Governor-General
(1) This Act does not apply to any request for access to a document of the Official Secretary to the Governor‑General unless the document relates to matters of an administrative nature.
(2) For the purposes of this Act, a document in the possession of a person employed under section 13 of the Governor‑General Act 1974 that is in his or her possession by reason of his or her employment under that section shall be taken to be in the possession of the Official Secretary to the Governor‑General.
I'm unaware whether this has been tested, but coincidentally Karen Kline (who I don't know) raised the issue in a submission (PDF 86KB) to the Committee in connection with its reference on the Freedom of Information Reform Bill. That may have been based on unsuccessful experience.The rub, as the law stands at present, is whether Council documents are in the Official Secretary's possession by reason of his employment as Official Secretary, and whether they relate to matters of an administrative nature.
Tuesday, February 09, 2010
FOI review rights and who carries the can
The issue in the Federal Government's Freedom of Information Reform Bill that Australia's Right to Know ran strongly with last week and was picked up elsewhere by the media and in the Senate committee hearing on Friday, revolves around the right to seek merits review from the Administrative Appeals Tribunal, and who should carry the onus if the matter gets that far. While it is an important issue, it is hardly the most important, and suggestions in Crikey it would "fatally undermine the move to more open government" seem way over the top. In the year to 30 June 2009 there were 27560 applications under the FOI Act but only 139 applications for review by the Tribunal. With the new system providing, as the Explanatory Memorandum states, "a simple expedient and cost efficient system for external merits review" by the Information Commissioner, everyone will be hoping even fewer cases warrant AAT review, once the Bill becomes law. And there are plenty of issues apart from this one in the Bill that call out for another look.
I'm concerned also about a related matter- the potential delay tactics if an agency or Minister has a right to further merits review of an Information Commissioner decision.This post looks at whether there should be any such right of review, and at the onus issues.The best approach in my view would be for an agency only to have a right to seek review of a Commissioner decision on the basis of an error in law; and as preserving an applicant right would be a means of ensuring the Commissioner stays on the right path, and the cost of an AAT application ($682) will always sort the serious applicant with a genuine issue from the frivolous, in the event of such an application, the agency or Minister should, as now, carry the onus.
For brave hearts an explanation follows.
Privacy, the media and Terry's own goal
Michael Pelly in The Australian Legal Affairs on Friday took some comfort from England soccer (now former) captain John Terry's failure in court to stop publication of an affair with a team mate's ex, suggesting the decision of High Court Justice Tugendhat would have Australian media lawyers smiling. Pelly also predicted with confidence that Attorney General Mc Clelland won't be hurrying in this election year to do anything on the ALRC recommendation of a cause of action for breach of privacy, or for that matter act on a raft of other controversial issues on his desk - "Too many people to upset for too little gain."Pelly's probably right on that but a couple of comments about the article and the decision.
Pelly said the "...mere thought of (a move in the direction of a privacy cause of action) gave the media apoplexy" when it emerged from the ALRC.
More accurately the suggestion gave News Limited executives and outlets, particularly The Australian Legal Affairs Editor Chris Merritt, who at the time used the words "outrageous" and "alarming," apoplexy. From memory experienced and respected commentators Mark Day, writing in The Australian Media Affairs, Jack Waterford in the Canberra Times, Matthew Ricketson then with The Age, and Richard Ackland in the Sydney Morning Herald were some who showed no such sign, suggesting the media needed to look closely at the proposal. And Mark Scott Managing Director of the ABC suggested the media get its house in order on privacy and negotiate something sensible rather than leave the issue for development in the courts over time.
Monday, February 08, 2010
New FOI era in NSW still coming "in the near future"


You might say that publicly at least, all that reforming zeal about ending secrecy in NSW associated with former Premier Nathan Rees, may have gone out the door with him, as there has been no mention of this aspect of public administration from new Premier Keneally, other than an early comment she was keen to restore trust in government. Or from Attorney General Hatzistergos to whom Rees had assigned responsibility for the yet to commence Government Information (Public Access) Act.
Rees had proclaimed the legislation would turn the freedom of information regime on its head; constituted a fundamental freedom of information revolution; that the public's right to know must come first, and that "the public sector must embrace openness and transparency and governments must forever relinquish their habitual instinct to control information." "This is generational change and reform that is long overdue" he said.
Well yes, but virtual silence from those in charge in the Keneally Government is quite a contrast, as are the limited visible signs of progress towards the new era in the seven months since Parliament passed the legislation last June. The Rees Government took only four months to consider, consult, act upon and push legislation through parliament on an Ombudsman's report put on the table in February 2009.
If you read tea leaves, there are a couple of suggestions that things are moving at the Office of Information Commissioner. According to its website the inaugural Information Commissioner will now take up duties "soon" (previously November 2009) and the Office advised government agencies recently that the new Act is to commence "in the near future"(previously early in 2010).
All in the interests of informed public discussion and debate
Federal Minister Penny Wong had no problem last week releasing a copy of New Department of Climate Change analysis of the Opposition climate change policy, in a succinct two pages, and drawing attention in a media release to the fact the policy would increase emissions by 13%. Its probably not what he is after, but I wonder whether Dr Denniss of The Australia Institute mentioned here earlier in the week facing a bill for $256,000 for documents the Department prepared to help inform the Minister and her advisers of the details, merits, limitations and criticisms of the Emissions Trading System, is tempted to simply ask for the most recent similar assessment of the Government's plans?
SA backflip on online political discussion
After posting here in defence of anonymity and pseudonimity, used reasonably, in online political discussion, I missed the ensuing fuss last week over the South Australian law to try to haul this in during the pre-election period, only to read in the Weekend Australian of the complete government backflip, under pressure, and some other colourful aspects of the public life of the minister responsible, Attorney General Michael Atkinson. David Penberthy on The Punch, while welcoming the move, makes the point that "the tone and quality of many (online)) comments is abysmal, and it’s a problem which stems in large part from anonymity." I can believe it, although Anonymous -apparently in many incarnations - is our best and best informed commenter here.
Sunday, February 07, 2010
Senate Committee to inquire further into FOI Reform
The Senate Finance and Public Administration Committee has another hearing on the Freedom of Information Reform Bills scheduled for Melbourne on 15 February, according to the list of upcoming hearings.
(Update: The Canberra Times in another piece on Saturday "Shame may beat public servants 'secretive ways' "( no link available-c'mon guys) also reported the Ombudsman Professor John McMillan:
(Further update: The transcript of the hearing is now available.)"..hoped changes to FoI law would encourage public servants to be more open with the public, but warned that overcoming the bureaucracy's secretive culture would be difficult. "The main enforcement mechanism that works is the public naming and shaming [of public servants who suppress documents]," he said. "My experience as Ombudsman shows me that this is a far more effective tool than any other determinative functions."
Friday, February 05, 2010
Senate Committee does FOI Reform before lunch
Following right along the Senate Finance and Public Administration Committee wrapped things up at 12.25 pm, but the widely experienced administrative lawyer Sydney barrister Mark Robinson, appearing for the Law Council of Australia, managed to raise additional issues for Committee attention including reformulation of exemptions so that a modified public interest test would apply to trade secrets and commercially valuable information, and to information claimed to be received on a confidential basis. The point he made that generated most interest ( a series of questions from Senator Brandis who was back for this session) was that the Bill should provide the Administrative Appeals Tribunal with the same powers in respect of FOI as it enjoys in all other areas of jurisdiction- to have the same authority as the original decision-maker, and in the case of FOI, to decide to grant access to an otherwise exempt document.
Then, in response to questions, Robinson gave his views on the reversal of onus issue that had dominated the earlier session: that such a provision would place an applicant who takes a matter to the AAT in an impossible position, and would undermine the objects of the act.
Committee Chair Senator Polley was sticking to time and started to finish the strictly 45 minutes reserved for the Law Council just as The Greens Senator Ludlam arrived with a batch of questions which might have been interesting. The only new issue he managed to raise during the 10 minute extension was the vexatious applicant provisions (the Information Commissioner can rule in limited circumstances) which Robinson thought necessary and reasonable.
Then, in response to questions, Robinson gave his views on the reversal of onus issue that had dominated the earlier session: that such a provision would place an applicant who takes a matter to the AAT in an impossible position, and would undermine the objects of the act.
While welcoming the legislative reforms, and in similar terms to Michael McKinnon in the previous session, urging prompt action on the bills, Robinson spoke for many of us when he said the amendments grafted slightly less turgid language on to an already turgid piece of legislation that was difficult even for lawyers to come to grips with, and a complete rewrite was required. His metaphor that we've kept the whole body and grafted half a transplant wasn't bad. He also made the point that the Government had not responded or explained why it had rejected points raised in the Council's submissions on the Exposure Draft last May. Welcome to the club on that one.
So that's game set and match until we see the Committee's report due 16 March.(Update: not quite- another hearing apparently was always the intention although not mentioned to date on the Committee website and is now scheduled for Melbourne on 15 February.) With the exception of the onus issue the Government got off very lightly without having to explain, defend or justify anything much at all, and with issues that surfaced just the tip of those raised in submissions.
It shoudn't go unremarked that not one question was raised, or the slightest interest shown when Michael McKinnon mentioned it, about the recommendation made 15 years ago by the Australian Law Reform Commission that the parliamentary departments that administer the Parliament, and spend over $300 million of public funds, including some payments to and on behalf of members and senators, should be brought within the scope of the act.
Lunch-no sausages.
Senate Committee speeding through FOI Reform Bills
I'm having one of those moments they say you experience when you see sausages or legislation in the making.
Things moved along so smartly at the Senate Finance and Public Administration Committee hearing on the Freedom of Information Reform Bills, this morning that proceedings adjourned for an hour at 10:30. They went way ahead of schedule when questioning of the first witness, Ombudsman Professor McMillan ran out of steam after 15 of the scheduled 45 minutes. Then the few members of the Committee who made it at 10:15 for a session with officers of the Department of Prime Minister and Cabinet only managed to keep things going for 8 minutes before questions dried up.
In between the point made by Michael McKinnon appearing for Australia's Right to Know about the reversal of the onus of proof in Administrative Appeals Tribunal processes (so the party seeking review would carry the onus, not always the agency that made the decision) dominated discussion in his 45 minutes, with Opposition Senator Brandis (not present otherwise) taking great delight in contrasting the Government's rhetoric about the magnitude of the proposed changes with what he described as a bizarre obstacle to disclosure that applicants who take a matter to the AAT might face.
This despite the fact that McKinnon had kicked off saying that after a meeting yesterday with Minister Ludwig the situation might not be as clear as he had argued in a submission,and in the light of the complexities explained, now needed to seek legal advice before making another submission on the subject. PM&C later explained the agency will continue to carry the onus in any Information Commissioner review, but based on precedent with other bodies such as the Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission it would not be appropriate for the Commissioner to defend the decision in the AAT, therefore if the matter went further the party who took it should carry the onus.
Things moved along so smartly at the Senate Finance and Public Administration Committee hearing on the Freedom of Information Reform Bills, this morning that proceedings adjourned for an hour at 10:30. They went way ahead of schedule when questioning of the first witness, Ombudsman Professor McMillan ran out of steam after 15 of the scheduled 45 minutes. Then the few members of the Committee who made it at 10:15 for a session with officers of the Department of Prime Minister and Cabinet only managed to keep things going for 8 minutes before questions dried up.
In between the point made by Michael McKinnon appearing for Australia's Right to Know about the reversal of the onus of proof in Administrative Appeals Tribunal processes (so the party seeking review would carry the onus, not always the agency that made the decision) dominated discussion in his 45 minutes, with Opposition Senator Brandis (not present otherwise) taking great delight in contrasting the Government's rhetoric about the magnitude of the proposed changes with what he described as a bizarre obstacle to disclosure that applicants who take a matter to the AAT might face.
This despite the fact that McKinnon had kicked off saying that after a meeting yesterday with Minister Ludwig the situation might not be as clear as he had argued in a submission,and in the light of the complexities explained, now needed to seek legal advice before making another submission on the subject. PM&C later explained the agency will continue to carry the onus in any Information Commissioner review, but based on precedent with other bodies such as the Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission it would not be appropriate for the Commissioner to defend the decision in the AAT, therefore if the matter went further the party who took it should carry the onus.
While there was some interest in the various sessions in the culture question and how change in that area was expected to come about, and in issues concerning overlap in functions of the Information Commissioner and the Ombudsman, there wasn't questioning at all on other points of weakness in the legislation mentioned in McKinnon's opening remarks- things like bringing the parliamentary departments and intelligence agencies within the scope of the act, applying a public interest test in all exemptions, proscribing frankness and candour as an argument to be used in arguing public interest considerations against disclosure. And certainly nothing to indicate that any of the many other points made in the 26 submissions had registered with Committee members, although Senator Ryan asked three witnesses what they thought about optional right of internal review.
There was some discussion with McKinnon about the Cabinet document exemption, with Senator Brandis seeking to label Kevin Rudd as the architect of the old Queensland practice of wheeling documents into the Cabinet room on a trolley, and wondering whether this was prohibited by the Commonwealth Bill. McKinnon thought there was nothing relevant to prevent it, although in fact, a document qualifies only if prepared for the dominant purpose of submission to Cabinet, so that sort of high jinks isn't on, we hope, and has never been suggested in Canberra under the current act. McKinnon said his scepticism about change in Queensland had been misplaced, as there had been a real turnaround ("I keep pinching myself wondering whether it will last), which he attributed primarily to the leadership of Premier Anna Bligh.
The Law Council of Australia is the next and last to appear. Early lunch anyone?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)





