The 2012 Report on Press Freedom in Australia released by the Media
Entertainment and Arts Alliance, Kicking at the Cornerstone of Democracy (see the full report here pdf), includes four articles on Freedom of Information. One unattributed (p 22) and one by academic Johan Lidberg (p 29) make reasonable points about shortcomings in the law and the system. Another by Christian Kerr of The Australian (p 20) provides a couple of FOI war stories. Then there is an article by Michael McKinnon, FOI Editor at the Seven Network (p 26) that makes some valid critical comments about the state of play but over-reaches in a couple of respects.
McKinnon, a Walkley award winner in 2009 for leadership
in this field, (and a winner for investigative journalism as well) has a great
record as a vigorous applicant, has blazed many FOI paths, and is
an exceedingly able advocate in his own cases in the tribunal and
courts. He knows his FOI oats, so his observations about the state of
the game deserve attention. However...
The heading, "An Unwelcome Freedom Rider" (probably not McKinnon's doing), is one of those ambiguous sub-editor smarty jobs, but in the context of what follows comes across as a personal shot about lack of ticker:
As to the article itself, the Commissioner Professor McMillan doesn't need me to defend his administration, or his views, but the following is a summary of what McKinnon had to say, with a few counter-points of my own.
(I notice Professor McMillan responded to recent commentary about the charges review by Perrin Brown of Monash University on The Conversation,. He is welcome to respond to this, as is Michael McKinnon.)
![]() |
| Michael McKinnon |
The heading, "An Unwelcome Freedom Rider" (probably not McKinnon's doing), is one of those ambiguous sub-editor smarty jobs, but in the context of what follows comes across as a personal shot about lack of ticker:
Freedom of information requests are all too often subject to unwarranted delays, bureaucratic wrangling and nit-picking refusals, writes Michael McKinnon The reformed FoI Act announced three years ago was to have its own watchdog, the Commonwealth information commissioner. But Seven Network’s FOI editor Michael McKinnon has found the watchdog lacks both the ticker and the teeth for the jobThe watchdog could do with more teeth for sure in the form of powers to lay down the law and pull some out there on board, or in line. But the lack of "ticker" charge is unwarranted.
As to the article itself, the Commissioner Professor McMillan doesn't need me to defend his administration, or his views, but the following is a summary of what McKinnon had to say, with a few counter-points of my own.
(I notice Professor McMillan responded to recent commentary about the charges review by Perrin Brown of Monash University on The Conversation,. He is welcome to respond to this, as is Michael McKinnon.)

