Search This Blog

Monday, July 09, 2012

Information commissioners by name, and nature


The Office of Information Commissioner Queensland has recently revamped the website, drawing attention to:
  • A user-centric layout with three primary content sections: Online services, Information for, and Information about
  • Dedicated pages for information rights practitioners, public sector employees, community members, media and students/researcher
  • Improved site searching options
  • Access to annotated legislation to provide critical or explanatory notes relevant to information rights
  • Quick links for popular resources and new decisions
  • Automated email form to submit a question to OIC
  • A friendly design for mobile device users.
"To improve our service, we have collated and organised in one online location, our research tools and information resources, case law and decisions from Queensland and other jurisdictions."

Sure to be useful for those who dig in these ditches.

As are the recently published 16 pages of FAQs and Answers from the Office of Australian Information Commissioner. Aimed primarily at those involved in dealing with Freedom of Information in government agencies, they won't come as a surprise to most. Pointing out that text messages and social media such as instant messaging (IM) that support the business of an agency fall within the definition of ‘document’ might give rise to a collective groan across Canberra. 

That FAQ and A and some others caught the eye:

Sunday, July 08, 2012

Treasurer Wells a long way from time in the stocks

Majorly
President Obama's resort to executive privilege in support of the refusal by Attorney General Holder to release documents to a congressional committee, a first for his administration, didn't protect Holder from a subsequent contempt motion. Closer to home, we have our own argument over parliament's powers to order production of documents.

Victorian Treasurer Kim Wells refused last year to comply with a Legislative Council motion requiring the tabling of a review report by consultants Deloitte of Myki, the controversial public transport smart card system. The Treasurer responded by advising that the report was prepared for consideration by a cabinet committee, that the council did not have power to require its production, and that the government had decided not to provide it.

Nothing happened in parliament thereafter but the matter is now in court. Greens MLC Greg Barber initiated action in the Supreme Court in March seeking a declaration that the council has power to order production of documents prepared outside cabinet and considered by cabinet. Not surprisingly all sorts of issues arise before the court gets to that point.

In a submission lodged last week the Solicitor General seeks an order that the proceeding be dismissed or stayed, or judgment be given for the Defendant on the grounds that the claim has no real prospect of success or is an abuse of process, based on legal principles concerning the order sought, the nature of privilege in Victoria, and the separation of powers. In essence:
  • there is no justiciable dispute to which determination of the existence of parliamentary privilege is a necessary incident;
  • the Legislative Council has not yet considered whether to assert any power to compel production, and the Court should not intrude into the workings of parliament unless compelled to do so;
  • the relief sought is merely hypothetical or advisory  and should not be entertained in the abstract and apart from a justiciable controversy.
The case is listed for 14 August. The Solicitor General has also given notice that the proceeding involves a matter arising under the Constitution. As s 78B of the Judiciary Act requires notification to the Attorneys-General of the Commonwealth and the States, some  may choose to join in.

So It will also take quite a while, if ever, to get to the underlying issue of access to the report prepared by consultants which the government claims was prepared for consideration by cabinet or a cabinet committee. If it was a freedom of information issue, which it isn't, the relevant exemption (s 28) turns on whether the report was prepared by or for the Minister or by an agency for the purpose of submission for consideration by the Cabinet.

NSW is the only Australian parliament that has a system for dealing with disputes concerning parliamentary orders requiring production of documents. An independent arbiter determines whether a claim for privilege has merit.  Some in federal parliament were keen to address the issue at one point but passed the opportunity in February 2010. 

In 2007 Victoria had a system of sorts (Sessional Order 21-Submission by Legislative Council: Inquiry into Independent Arbitration of Public Interest pdf) but apparently the current parliament has never got around to addressing what to do in circumstances where a minister says no, according to Mr Barber's Affidavit.

The general issue of parliament v the executive over access to documents will get an airing at a forum at the Castan Centre for Human Rights Law, Monash University on 9 August featuring Mr Barber and Clerk of the Senate Dr Rosemary Laing.

Wednesday, July 04, 2012

Blanket FOI exclusion for federal courts complaint handling

Vmenkov
Blanket exclusions from freedom of information laws for some government agencies and blanket exemptions for information or documents of a certain kind held by agencies covered by the law constitute a hole in our accountability and transparency frameworks. Such provisions have the effect of putting beyond usual access rights, all information held by an agency or all information that relates to a particular aspect of operations for 20 to 30 years until  records (might not will) emerge from archives. The case for such exclusions or exemptions regardless of other considerations needs to be strong and compelling

Legislation debated in the House of Representatives last week, the Courts Legislation Amendment (Judicial Complaints) Bill 2012, would provide a statutory basis for the relevant heads of court jurisdiction to deal with complaints about judicial officers and also to provide immunity from suit for those involved in the complaints handling process. It would also provide broad exclusions from FOI for documents that relate to the complaints handling processes within the Federal Court of Australia, the Family Court of Australia and the Federal Magistrates Court. Beyond a matter of fact mention in the Attorney General's second reading speech in March, and another by one of the seven speakers (Craig Kelly) on 28 June, no one thought the need to justify or query the amendment. 

The Explanatory Memorandum explains the machinery provisions [218-225] but the only justification offered is in the Statement of Compatability with Human Rights which suggests a major objective is to protect the "privacy and reputation" of those who handle a complaint:
25. The consideration and handling of complaints about judicial officers may give rise to sensitive or personal reports or other documents about a judicial officer or another person. These documents require a degree of confidentiality to avoid improper interference in the complaints handling process and the possibility of the damage to the reputation of a judge and the operation of the court before the investigation has been completed. The potential to disclose sensitive information concerning a judge’s performance of their judicial duties may undermine judicial independence and impact on future performance and discharge of the judicial function itself.
26. In excluding these documents from the FOI Act, the Bill advances human rights by protecting the privacy and reputation of those involved in internal handling of complaints about judicial officers within the courts.
Maybe, but that's all there is?

The existing s 5 limits application of the FOI act to documents held by the courts that relate to matters of an administrative nature. Presumably the advice is that existing exemptions aren't sufficient to protect whatever must be protected in the management and investigation of complaints. Belt and braces protection of this kind hasn't surfaced as an issue elsewhere. Why the courts need complete and all encompassing protection for complaint handling functions not available to other commonwealth agencies who get by with the standard exemptions when dealing with similar matters might be an interesting discussion.


There are weightier issues in contention as the bill and the companion piece, the Judicial Misbehaviour and Incapacity (Parliamentary Commissions) Bill await final passage in the House and go to the Senate where the Senate Legal and Constitutional Affairs Committee is to report by 13 July. 

But someone might ask about the FOI aspect. And get a compelling or not so compelling answer.

Monday, July 02, 2012

Sunshine in shaded parts of Parliament House

While we await further news from Attorney General Roxon about that "anomaly" that the parliamentary departments turn out to be subject to the Freedom of information Act, up pops a report from a parliamentary committee that has been quietly looking over the last 12 months at strange goings on in the Department of Parliamentary Services. All prompted by Senator Faulkner's questions about what happened to the billiard tables. 

The Interim Report of the Senate Finance and Public Administration regarding the  Performance of the Department of Parliamentary Services commences:
The Senate referred the inquiry into the performance of the Department of Parliamentary Services (DPS) to the committee in June 2011. The committee received both public and confidential submissions which raised significant issues particularly in relation to the employment culture of DPS, the issue of bullying and harassment within DPS, management of heritage values and, of course, the sale of the billiard tables from the Staff Recreation Room.
Hmm, transparency, disinfectant, all that. The committee continues to dig.

Reminder from September 2010.

"What the Australian people told us, and they told us this in no uncertain terms on that day and on the days that have followed, is this: that we will be held more accountable than ever before, and more than any government in modern memory. We will be held to higher standards of transparency and reform, and it's in that spirit that I approach the task of forming a government......To quote Rob Oakeshott, sunshine is the best disinfectant, and we've agreed to far-reaching reforms that make me as Prime Minister and our government and how it functions more accountable to the Australian people. So, let's draw back the curtains and let the sun shine in; let our parliament be more open than it ever was before."

Sunday, July 01, 2012

FOI in South Australia not healthy

South Australia, one of our non-reform FOI states, gets a drubbing in this Sunday Mail editorial detailing a two and a half year battle to access documents on crimes reported on public hospital grounds in the preceding five years:
THE culture of secrecy, evasion, obfuscation and cover-up demonstrated by the Health Department, as reported today, is anathema to South Australia's proud tradition of being a free and open society whose democratic ideals include the public's right to know what is going on in our public hospitals. 
And more detail of the time and cost involved here.

Not sure when the assist from the Ombudsman occurred-no Health determination listed for quite a while. (Update-since posted. It's quite a saga, with the Ombudsman concluding that  much of the delay arose because the applicant could have done more to describe in less open-ended terms what was being sought (73), and that the Department had fallen short of what is expected under the FOI Act in relation to engaging with the applicant to clarify the scope of the application (74)).

SA needs a freedom of information act fitting for the 21st century. And the attitude to go with it.

Friday, June 29, 2012

Sun shines on parliamentarians' expenditure

Yan Zhang
In cold, wintry Canberra (not pictured) at least.

The Department of Finance and Deregulation has published reports of expenditure against entitlements it administers for parliamentarians and former parliamentarians, and overseas study travel reports, this batch for the period July to December 2011.

For those still looking for evidence that transparency can be a useful compliance tool, proof in the form of the associated list of certifications that expenditure was properly incurred, consistent with the rules.  Almost a full house with just a handful of exceptions including Minister Senator Conroy and Bob Katter MP.  When Finance commenced this publication practice in January the list of non-certfiers for the relevant period extended to 100 names, dropping quickly thereafter. (I'm still wondering why certification is voluntary.)

On the related issue of information on payments by the parliamentary departments (none pro-actively published to date) and the comment by Attorney General Roxon's spokesman that FOI coverage was an anomaly that needed fixing, not a word said or question raised in parliament in this session, and they've now packed up for the six week winter recess. A sign things should stay as they are?

Contrast sunny Canberra with the states-a dark subject I'm warming to, hopefully next week.


"Public interest" no simple matter

In the context of the Rinehart interest in Fairfax, Murdoch's troubled times and faint rumbles from Canberra, Richard Ackland in the SMH and elsewhere today muses on the imprecision of terms currently being bandied about such as "public interest" and ''fit and proper person'' tests for media ownership. In a broader context, those who ply the legal practitioner trade have passed the latter. And access to information folk are well acquainted with the former.
''The public interest'' is a phrase sprinkled through legislation with gay abandon. It sounds democratic and noble, but at the end of the rainbow it has to be interpreted by a judge, or a cluster of judges - a recipe for uncertainty, because the judges themselves are uncertain...In the government's issues paper on a cause of action for serious invasion of privacy, ''public interest'' appeared 57 times. In the Finkelstein report, it was 85 times, the same number of times it was mentioned in the Convergence Review (including 13 times on one page). No doubt it is a popular rubric because it artfully allows plenty of imprecision and circularity in its application....Really, a public interest test is fine, as long as no one tries to define it."
Definition starts with the notion of what action or decision best contributes to the good order and well being of the community as a whole, but that opens all sorts of trails and branches in search of factors relevant to the matter at hand.

Hence all that rubbery stuff, Richard, and the struggle with grey when black and white would be preferable- if only we could find it.

Of course in his trade some have worn the public interest badge proudly, apparently oblivious of what it means. Who will forget the Deputy Editor of Sydney's Daily Telegraph defending the publication of what at the time, the Telegraph insisted were photos of Pauline Hanson some 30 years previously:
the ‘public interest.’
When questioned about the precise public interest involved in old photos of compromising positions she said ‘That's for our readers to tell. That will be determined by the number of people that buy the paper’.  (Media Watch, 23 March, 2009). And of course they weren't of Hanson at all.

Freedom of information reforms in Australia in recent years have seen parliaments to varying degrees have something of a go at definition, or at least an attempt to spell out considerations that favour disclosure in the public interest (still leaving open other possibilities), those that favour non-disclosure, and some that are irrelevant in deciding whether to grant or refuse access. Within certain parameters still plenty of room for argument and lawyering, but something of an improvement on pre-reform days.

The Queensland Information Commissioner for example has reams of guidance but it's not for the faint-hearted. OAIC Guidelines include this non-definitive list of public interest factors favouring disclosure. And of course there is a statutory list of factors on the other side.

Tuesday, June 26, 2012

Open Australia, great to see you're back

After six months terrific to have the fantastic hansard service back to assist in keeping up with federal parliament. In the interim, having to rely on parliament's own newish and expensive website without similar search capabilities was painful and inadequate, so hats off to the volunteers at Open Australia, particularly John Wells and Henare Degan for righting things once again.

SMH
One little gem uncovered in a "freedom of information" search was a question on notice in March from the shadow minister Senator David Johnston to the Minister representing the Minister for Defence that included:
"For the period 1 July to 31 December 2011... How many conclusive certificates were issued in relation to FOI requests."
I'm sure the public servants and the minister were tempted, but they dead-panned, simply answering in May:
"Conclusive certificates no longer exist. They were abolished under the Freedom of Information (Removal of Conclusive Certificates and Other Measures) Act 2009."
Passed by the Senate on 13 August 2009 to be precise.

Sunday, June 24, 2012

Pen and paper FOI applications make jaws drop

From the (Toronto) Globe and Mail
"Toby Mendel, president of the Centre for Law and Democracy, recently returned from Rabat where he spoke with officials devising an access law for Morocco. They asked him what the Canadian government had proposed in the area of access reform as part of the global Open Government Partnership initiative. Mendel told them Canada had suggested allowing access requesters to apply electronically, dispensing with the current cumbersome practice of a paper form and a $5 cheque. “Literally, I could see their jaws dropping,” Mendel said in an interview. “Because it was incomprehensible to them that a country like Canada would not already have electronic requesting possibility.”
Well at least Canada is a member of the OGP along with around 60 other countries. Australia continues to sit on the outside- Indonesia, the Philippines and Korea are the only torch-bearers from this region.

Of course if the issue of comparisons with Canada was raised, our government could point out that these days Federal agencies all seem to accept an email application.

But many state governments are still back in the stone age as we found from a quick look around last year.

South Australian Police still take the gold boulder- asking that you personally front up to a police station with your application. Narrowly ahead of those such as NSW Roads and Maritime providing the option of dropping your application into an office or dropping it in the mail. To be fair some NSW agencies such as Finance and Services  appear to have moved into the 1990s in the last year. But there are plenty of other agencies in NSW, SA and Western Australia still opening the stamped  envelopes each morning. And trusting you followed the guidance to pay the application fee-strictly cash, cheque or money order, thank you. (Memo: Once upon a time, long before there were Apps.......)

Victoria still failing to deliver

Add this Sunday Herald Sun Editorial "Premier needs to open doors on Freedom of Information" to the Victoria file marked "disappointing":
The Sunday Herald Sun urges Mr Baillieu to revert to the view he held in Opposition; that governments should be open and accountable.
I'm in Melbourne speaking at the Managing Patient Confidentiality and Information Governance Conference tomorrow so hope to catch up with a few of the locals.

(Update:further grist from the Hun.

But wait-Opposition joins in.

Still more.

Friday, June 22, 2012

Transparency and the food business

Last year a comment here about developments regarding transparency and food hygiene standards in Queensland and the ACT- both in the news again recently. I haven't kept track of developments across the board in this area in recent times. (Update: a reader draws attention to the SA Food Act Prosecutions Register- but publishing convictions in court is no big deal, as recent developments in Queensland show.)  There is a research project  for someone interested in looking into this at the national level, or on a comparative basis across state jurisdictions, to see what effect various degrees of transparency have on compliance with hygiene standards, and importantly, on outcomes in terms of public health.

Wednesday, June 20, 2012

Sydney Olympic deals still commercially significant

 Ah remember the days..revisited recently in a Government Information (Public Access) Act case in the NSW Administrative Decisions Tribunal concerning the relatively rare issue of access to cabinet information ten or more years old. The decision involved something not quite as rare, a win (mostly) for the Sydney Swans (8-3, midway through the season).

The conclusive presumption that there is an overriding public interest against disclosure of cabinet information ( GIPA Schedule 1 Clause 2) does not apply if (a)  public disclosure of the document has been approved by the Premier or Cabinet, or (b)  10 years have passed since the end of the calendar year in which the document came into existence.

Nevertheless, depending on content, context and the effect of disclosure, there is scope on other grounds to claim an overriding public interest against disclosure. 

Deputy President Higgins in Hall v Department of Premier and Cabinet [2012] NSWADT 46 decided some withheld parts of a 1999 cabinet minute prepared in the lead up to the 2000 Olympics should be released, affirmed the decision (with a confidentiality order attached to the reasons) to refuse access to other parts that had continuing commercial significance to the Swans and the Stadium Australia Management Limited (SAG), and referred other disputed parts of  the document back to Premier's for reconsideration. (The document as released is yet to appear on the department's disclosure log.)

Few points of law arose in the case. The order that some information withheld by the department should be disclosed resulted primarily from the failure to satisfy the tribunal that disclosure would have the adverse effects claimed. For information of this kind it was unnecessary to consider whether the public interest considerations against disclosure, on balance, outweigh the public interest considerations for disclosure. However with regard to some, Deputy President Higgins commented "there are a number of public interest considerations in favour of disclosure of the information in the disputed paragraphs. The stadium is an important public asset and disclosure of the disputed information (now 13 years old) could reasonably be expected to enhance Government accountability and ensure effective oversight of the expenditure of public funds" [52]. Other information of this kind "appears to be purely factual and uncontroversial" [72]

Tuesday, June 19, 2012

World conference snaffles... Dr Solomon

A comment from Andrew, just over the ditch, explaining what will be keeping Dr Solomon busy 12-16 November while some of us will be in Canberra (just kidding):
Overlapping with the AGS conference in Canberra is the World Conference of the International Ombudsman Institute, being held in Wellington. Dr Solomon will be speaking there, along with Prof. McMillan, Rick Snell and others. FOI sessions, as well as others relating to ombudsmanship and human rights. More details on the conference website:
http://www.confer.co.nz/wcioi/
Plenty of other top-liners there including Professor Alasdair Roberts, Jerome L. Rappaport Professor of Law and Public Policy at Suffolk University Law School, and Faculty Director of the Rappaport Center for Law and Public Service on "Freedom of Information: the current challenges and the future directions freedom of information might take", and  Bruce Barbour, New South Wales Ombudsman on "The effect of removal of FOI jurisdiction from an Ombudsman."

Monday, June 18, 2012

Australian conferences call, and not just David Solomon!

Managing Patient Confidentiality and Information Governance (IIR Conferences) -Melbourne 25-26 June, so hurry. I'm a speaker-as if that will get you across the line! For the record, David Solomon (see below) isn't.

Integrity in Administrative Decision Making  (Australian Institute of Administrative Law)-Adelaide 19-20 July. "An opportunity to consider the concept of the integrity branch, the institutions that constitute it and its health in 2012." Includes sessions on integrity issues featuring Queensland Integrity Commissioner, Dr David Solomon, Professor A.J Brown of Griffith University, and Australian Information Commissioner Professor John McMillan (on "Jurisdictional facts and the Malaysian solution (!)). Julie Kinross, Information Commissioner, Queensland will speak to “Get off the couch!” - The transmission of the public value of transparency through independent merits review, Queensland style".

Creating Open Government (New South Wales Information and Privacy Commission)-Sydney 20-22 August. Program yet to be posted. Early bird rates on offer. Follows the two Right to Know Day conferences in Brisbane in recent years and the Information Policy Conference in Canberra last year. Includes the Solomon (see above) Lecture inaugurated in Queensland in 2009, this year to be delivered by Dr Geoff Gallop, Professor and Director at Sydney University's Graduate School of Government and former Western Australian Premier.

International Council on Archives Congress-Brisbane 20-24 August. Savings for registration before 15 July. I'm exhausted just reading the program! "Rub shoulders ..with internationally acclaimed archivists, information managers, audiovisual and preservation specialists." Two of many offerings of interest are Professor McMillan (see above), Canadian Privacy Commissioner Jennifer Stoddard, and Director of the (US) Office of Government Information Services at the National Archives and Records Administration Miriam Nisbet, as keynote speakers on 23 August on "Public Rights to Information and to Privacy" to be chaired by.... Dr Solomon (see above); and Ann Steward of AGIMO chairing a panel session on "Open Government, right to information and recordkeeping: interdependencies and interconnections" that includes Julie Kinross (see above), Queensland State Archivist Janet Prowse, and Miriam Nisbet.

Update-2nd National information Law Conference (Australian Government Solicitor)-Canberra 14-16 November. See here-scroll down, to pdf top right. Early bird rates to 30 June. "Privacy law, freedom of information and related topics, as relevant to all Australian jurisdictions. Digital privacy will be a particular focus, as will be the key issues and practicalities of freedom of information, and recent reforms in both areas at a Commonwealth level." A lot of territory to be covered over three days and plenty of big names-but not Dr Solomon. Richard Ackland of the SMH after dinner, Sean Parnell of The Australian and Geoff Thompson of ABC Investigative Unit (on a topic broached here in January) sure to add valuable "outsider" perspectives. I'm on, with Rick Snell, University of Tasmania and Justin Davidson of AGS, assessing "Australian information law: what kind of shape are we in?"

Friday, June 15, 2012

Australian Press Council goes for quality.

Professor Julian Disney's term at the Australian Press Council has been marked by efforts to try to get ahead of the council's critics, and clean up media self regulation to the extent possible before the case for government hopping further into the game becomes compelling. The Australian reports two moves in this direction. The appointment as public members of the council of the highly respected Andrew Podger (mentioned here a few times over the years including as one of our best when it comes to knowing how government works and should work) and Philippa Smith, a one time Commonwealth Ombudsman, and many other things beside. And a new executive Director, Linda Matthews, formerly Queensland Privacy Commissioner.

 Not sure when Mathews left the job in Queensland-nothing on the Information Commissioner's website and this may be old news but "Lemm Ex, Principal Privacy Officer, Office of the Information Commissioner is currently the Acting Privacy Commissioner."

The appointments were an important step in strengthening the Council, said chairman Julian Disney. "We are greatly looking forward to working with Andrew Podger and Philippa Smith and to the major contribution which Linda Matthews will make to the operations of the Council," he said.

Indeed.

Like to be a fly on the wall at Holt St when news filtered through that Mathews with a strong privacy protection background was to join the ranks on 9 July. And at APC meetings when privacy issues are on the agenda. New and differerent perspectives, anyone?

Victorian FOI commissioner will be busy in 2012-13

The Victorian Parliament passed legislation to establish the office in February. No appointment has been announced and there is nothing I can find in the public domain about where things stand. Except the start date for the legislation is no later than 1 December 2012.

There is a scrap or two in the  Budget papers. Nothing like last year when the plan received headline status with an announcement of $7.9 million to establish the office, although the fine print (Budget Paper 3 (Chapter 1 Election Commitments p 54) revealed this was spread over four years with $1million allocated in the first year, $2.3 million in 2012-2013, and $2.2 million in each of the next two years.

This year the only mention is at pages 179 and 181 of Budget Paper no 3, where "enhancing government transparency through the establishment on an independent Freedom of Information (FOI) Commissioner" is bundled together in two sets of disparate outputs of the Department of Justice. It's unclear what the money situation is as there is nothing specific about past or future expenditure on the office. The combined allocations come with a note: the "2012-13 Target has been reduced due to efficiencies reflecting government savings." 

But somewhere, someone must be gearing up to deliver.

At page 182, performance measures for the office are mixed in with those for others but in 2012-13 the office of the commissioner is to complete 100 complaints, undertake 20 training and education activities, achieve 100% compliance with statutory and other agreed time limits, and rate "high" on applicant satisfaction with review and complaint processes. What this note means for commencement of the scheme is unclear: "The 2012-13 Target takes into account the legislation’s default commencement date of 1 December 2012."

The Office of the Victorian Privacy Commissioner (page 183) was allocated $2.4 million ("reduced due to efficiencies reflecting government savings"), $2.6 million, $2.6 million and $2.5 million in each of the next four years. In 2012-13, performance targets for that office are 700 "compliance activities", 195 "Privacy Awareness activities", high rating in client feedback of satisfaction with complaint handling and training services provided, and 90% statutory or agreed timelines met-perhaps reflecting (in contrast to the FOI commissioner's 100% target) some realism that comes from a presence at the table when these things are settled.

Wednesday, June 13, 2012

Stuart Morris QC coming to grips with NBN and FOI

On 16 April Attorney General Nicola Roxon announced that an "eminent person" would undertake a statutory review of the application of Freedom of Information to NBN Co, the company responsible for implementing the National Broadband Network. The review is to be completed by 30 June 2012, and the report tabled in Parliament. Terms of reference were published but user experience in dealing with NBN Co didn't get a look in.The  NBN Co website makes no mention of the review.

On 20 May, I emailed the Attorney General's office asking if an appointment had been made, if so , who, and if not when could this be expected? No reply but having asked again this week, the name, Stuart Morris QC, former justice of the Supreme Court of Victoria and President of the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal, appeared yesterday on the Attorney General's Department website. 

His surprise early resignation as President of VCAT generated media interest in 2007, The Age describing him as "colourful and controversial." While his main game appears to be planning law, Mr Morris had his share of FOI cases in VCAT, and memorably, had his decision in the Osland case stand up to High Court scrutiny. 


NSW budget squeeze to tighten information??

The NSW treasurer's order of the day to agencies in the 2012-13 budget handed down yesterday was to live with an annual 1.2% "labour expense cap" over four years expected to lead to 10,000 job cuts, and to "rein in expenses" so await with interest to see what this does to resources across the public sector devoted to information access and privacy protection. Less spin, more information perhaps....


The Office of Information and Privacy Commission (Budget Paper No 3 Attorney General and Justice, page 2-28) will remain on tight rations: $5.406 million available for operating costs and $150k for capital expenditure in 2012-13 compared to the revised allocation of $5.503 million and $366k in 2011-12.

Service measures listed for the office are straight output numbers-undertake 350 reviews, investigate 100 complaints, handle 435 formal privacy matters - and in anticipation, expect 280k website hits. Outcomes don't rate a mention and there are no published quality or efficiency measures or indicators.

Hopefully Ross Gittins of the SMH will repeat his federal budget performance, testing the treasurer's claim that this government "has restored openness and transparency to the Budget." Plenty of sceptics out there on that one, pondering the treasurer's observation that leaving the detail of program cuts of over $1 billion to portfolio ministers and agencies is  "normal" practice.

Tuesday, June 12, 2012

Senator Xenophon's FOI message: fair roll of the dice!!

RicHard-59
GOVERNMENT  RESPONSE SLAMMED AS RUBBISH
"Independent Senator for SA Nick Xenophon has slammed the Government for its pathetic response to his Freedom of Information Request relating to the cost of converting poker machines to be maximum $1 bet capable.The Government charged Senator Xenophon $465 for 34 pages of documents, with huge slabs of potentially critical information blacked out. (The documents can be provided on request from Nick’s office – at no charge).“If this wasn’t such a serious issue it would be laughable. They might as well have just sent me 34 pieces of blank paper,” Nick said.Senator Xenophon sought access under the Freedom of Information Act to documents relating to the work done by the Department on the cost of implementing the $1 bet scheme with $120 an hour losses – as recommended by the Productivity Commission.Senator Xenophon made the request after the Government repeatedly claimed it would cost $1.5 billion to make poker machines $1 maximum bet ready.“The Australia Institute has already analysed the costs as being in the order of $200million over a number of years. Given problem gamblers lose $5 billion a year on pokies, that’s chicken feed. Instead the Government’s given me a load of chicken poo.”“It seems the Government has plucked the figure out its head.”“This is a serious matter of critical importance to public policy that affects the lives of hundreds of thousands of Australians who are deeply damaged by poker machine addiction.”Senator Xenophon will lodge an appeal under the public interest provisions of the FOI Act for the release of the blacked out information and other documents which the Department has refused to release.“What has the Government got to hide?” Nick asked. “And why will their watered down draft legislation only allow for machines to be mandatory pre-commitment ready, not $1 bet ready as well? It’s absolutely absurd.”
We here love to see reasons given as to why this sort of disclosure would be the end of the world as we know it, Senator.

Monday, June 11, 2012

Radio National, Tuesday morning

I'll be talking Freedom of Information with Natasha Mitchell on Life Matters, ABC Radio National- AM 576- tomorrow, Tuesday morning a little after 9 am. (Update-you can listen here.)