Search This Blog

Monday, May 14, 2012

Allan Kessing on display


By Yiyang Liu-with permission.
Allan Kessing has plenty to be disappointed about, but not this outstanding piece. He and the artist Yiyang Liu are philosophical that it didn't make it into the Archibald Prize this year or even the Salon des Refuses. Currently on display at Sydney's Tap Gallery, next step is a crack at the Moran Portraiture Prize.

Of course Kessing has plenty of experience with raw deals-charged and convicted under a draconian law that in this form should have been erased from the statute book years ago; disclosures after the event of information that should have been made available to his lawyer during the trial and appeal, and if made available would have materially affected the way the case was handled; years of maintaining his innocence of the offence as charged, but an admission after his conviction that he did pass on information to the office of a then opposition parliamentarian, now a government minister, about a report on the parlous state of security at Sydney Airport that had languished in his boss' in-tray for two years ; continued silence from some who know the full story of the disclosure to journalists at The Australian that led to his conviction, and incidentally, to urgent attention to the security issues identified, to the tune of $200 million; and with some reluctance, to apply for a pardon in 2009 and to have the issues raised publicly by Senator Xenophon in 2010 and listed in the incoming brief for the attorney general that year as a "Hot Topic", to be left wondering as it disappeared from sight ever since.

Kessing told me some time ago he is past caring, "happy" to smell the wattle instead. The rest of us need to do both.

Nothing can right the wrongs, but it would help if Attorney General Roxon called for the file, and asked questions about the Kessing case. Here is a reminder what the ALP was saying about the importance of whistleblower protection and Kessing-in 2007! Come to think of it Special Minister of State Gray who appears to be struggling on the corporate memory front should be interested in that as well.

A win in the Moran for Yiyang Liu who accurately portrays Kessing as a proud, courageous man would be icing on a bittersweet pardon cake.

 Best wishes.



Australian Information Commissioner accused of lacking "teeth and ticker"

The 2012 Report on Press Freedom in Australia released by the Media Entertainment and Arts Alliance, Kicking at the Cornerstone of Democracy (see the full report here pdf), includes four articles on Freedom of Information. One unattributed (p 22) and one by academic Johan Lidberg (p 29) make reasonable points about shortcomings in the law and the system. Another by Christian Kerr of The Australian (p 20) provides a couple of FOI war stories. Then there is an article by Michael McKinnon, FOI Editor at the Seven Network (p 26) that makes some valid critical comments about the state of play but over-reaches in a couple of respects.


Michael McKinnon
McKinnon, a Walkley award winner in 2009 for leadership in this field, (and a winner for investigative journalism as well) has a great record as a vigorous applicant, has blazed many FOI paths, and is an exceedingly able advocate in his own cases in the tribunal and courts. He knows his FOI oats, so his observations about the state of the game deserve attention. However...

The heading, "An Unwelcome Freedom Rider" (probably not McKinnon's doing), is one of those ambiguous sub-editor smarty jobs, but in the context of what follows comes across as a personal shot about lack of ticker:
Freedom of information requests are all too often subject to unwarranted delays, bureaucratic wrangling and nit-picking refusals, writes Michael McKinnon The reformed FoI Act announced three years ago was to have its own watchdog, the Commonwealth information commissioner. But Seven Network’s FOI editor Michael McKinnon has found the watchdog lacks both the ticker and the teeth for the job
The watchdog could do with more teeth for sure in the form of powers to lay down the law and pull some out there on board, or in line. But the lack of "ticker" charge is unwarranted.


As to the article itself, the Commissioner Professor McMillan doesn't need me to defend his administration, or his views, but the following is a summary of what McKinnon had to say, with a few counter-points of my own.

(I notice Professor McMillan responded to recent commentary about the charges review by Perrin Brown of Monash University on The Conversation,. He is welcome to respond to this, as is Michael McKinnon.)

Friday, May 11, 2012

History of commitment to whistleblower protection airbrushed?

Special Minister of State Gary Gray made the following reference to public sector whistleblower protection in his second reading speech in March in introducing the Public Service Amendment Bill 2012:
Whistleblower reports
The act currently provides protection for whistleblowers in the APS. The regulations provide the framework under which whistleblower reports are handled.The bill makes two small amendments to the scheme. It provides a specific regulation-making power and allows for matters to be excluded from inquiry, including those that relate to an employee's own employment. Such complaints are better directed to the existing review of action scheme.
There has been no further debate.

The minister can buy an argument with the first proposition.

What is proposed are changes to processes associated with a whistleblower who reports a breach of the APS Code of Conduct. There are more than two proposed changes but the minister's reference to "small changes" was well chosen. "Comprehensive" or "far-reaching" would not have come to mind- see below for relevant extracts from the Explanatory Memorandum.

Of course major inadequacies in the Public Service Act protections, including the absence of any protection for public disclosures, were the reasons why much time and energy was spent since 2008 examining comprehensive whistleblower protection legislation

Minister Gray's four sentences air-brush the following history:
  • ALP commitment to act on whistleblower protection prior to 2007 election. (They also talked then about justice for Allan Kessing, but that's another incomplete story.)
  • House of Representatives Standing Committee on Legal and Constitutional Affairs (Dreyfus) asked to examine models in 2008 and reported in 2009.
  • Government responded to the recommendations in March 2010 in a reasonably positive manner and went a bit further than the committee in some respects, including on public disclosures. Then attorney general McClelland said at the time “The Government supports a pro-disclosure culture in the Australian public sector, underpinned by enhanced whistleblower protection mechanisms, as part of its commitment to integrity in Australian governance. Whistleblower protection is about ensuring that there are appropriate processes in place, and protections offered, to facilitate the disclosure of wrongdoing, misconduct and corruption. The Government is committed to providing best-practice legislation to achieve this end. The Government will develop legislation reflecting this Government response for introduction during this year.(ie 2010). A further announcement about the legislation will be made in due course.”
  • The Gillard agreement in September 2010 with Andrew Wilkie to enable formation of her government included a commitment that parliament would pass the law by July 2011.
  •  The Australian Public Service Commission State of the Service Report 2010-2011 released in November 2011: "The government is finalising the Public Interest Disclosure Bill. The legislation is intended to set up a scheme that provides for the investigation of unacceptable conduct in the Australian Government sector and extend the protections available to people reporting wrongdoing. The legislation is expected to be introduced to parliament in 2011."
In March 2012 "two small amendments" proposed to the existing scheme, and nothing since.

What gives???
  
Explanatory Memorandum  

Thursday, May 10, 2012

Surprise, as parliament within FOI scope all along

Well it turns out I have been off the money for years, bemoaning the fact that the Department of the Senate, the Department of the House of Representatives and the Department of Parliamentary Services, the three agencies that service the parliament and parliamentarians, are outside the scope of the Freedom of Information Act. And arguing that they should be brought within scope as recommended by the Australian Law Reform Commission in 1995.

The departments have never been listed in any annual report on the operation of the act. No-one ever suggested I was off-target.

Bill Hoffman of the Sunshine Coast daily as recently as March was being rebuffed in attempts to get hold of documents concerning Peter Slipper's time as deputy speaker, the Sergeant at Arms as head of the House department telling him that  details of expenditure for services provided to individual members would not be released. 

But out of the blue, revised Guidelines today by the Office of the Australian Information Commissioner include this paragraph for the first time (Part 2-Scope)
2.5 Three of the Commonwealth Parliamentary departments (the Department of the House of Representatives, the Department of the Senate and the Department of Parliamentary Services) are subject to the FOI Act because they were established by, or in accordance with, s 54 of the Parliamentary Service Act 1999 and they have not been exempted. The fourth Commonwealth Parliamentary department, the Parliamentary Budget Office, is exempted because it is expressly deemed not to be a prescribed authority (s 7(1) and Division 1 of Part I of Schedule 2.)
No explanation, but perhaps the penny was dropping as legislation for the establishment of the Parliamentary Budget Office developed to insistent cries that it be specifically exempt from FOI. Of course legislation to this effect was necessary because a parliamentary department otherwise was a prescribed authority, a body corporate established for a public purpose by, or in accordance with the provisions of an enactment, and subject to the FOI act unless otherwise exempt.

As mentioned in previous posts these departments pay in addition to entitlements paid by the Department of Finance and Administration, salaries and electorate allowances of parliamentarians, additional salaries of parliamentary office holders, superannuation entitlements, resettlement allowance payments, and for services and facilities to support parliamentarians in Parliament House including the cost of office accommodation, computing and other equipment, telephones, newspapers and stationery. 

Of particular current interest is what documents held by the departments might reveal about payments to or on behalf of office holders such as the speaker, including perhaps travel, entertainment and other services when on business connected to that office.

And what other hitherto tightly held documents about expenditure for and on behalf of all other members and senators might reveal.

The FOI applicant queue starts here. 

If parliamentary leaders or Special Minister of State Gary Gray had been ahead of the game they might have headed all this off ages ago with moves toward pro-active disclosure along the lines advocated here rather than sitting on most Belcher committee recommendations for years. The Scottish model -on-line, comprehensive, searchable records of expenditure by parliamentarians still beckons.




Tuesday, May 08, 2012

More transparency for the private sector should be on the cards, not just for trade unions

In the light of what members of the HSU didn't know the Federal Government plans to force  trade unions to be more open:
The Government has announced that it will take action to enhance the accountability and transparency of registered organisations and to strengthen penalties, and improve Fair Work Australia’s investigation processes following the conclusion of the Fair Work Australia investigation into the National Office of the Health Services Union.
Good stuff, but a broader issue concerning the adequacy of transparency obligations of private sector bodies generally cries out for attention as well.


As Johan Lidberg of Monash University concludes his piece on freedom of information in the 2012 MEAA Press Freedom report (pdf) (p 29):
However 2011 saw no movement at all in the most challenging areas of independent information access – corporate information. This is noteworthy as actions of big corporations arguably have as much influence (at times more) over our daily lives, as do governments. Access to corporate information remains the final frontier in the information access battle .
Elsewhere, almost on cue, George Monbiot writing in The Guardian yesterday tried to fire this up in the UK, reflecting on News International's previously tightly held secrets:
In this column I will make a proposal that sounds – at first – monstrous, but I hope to persuade you is both reasonable and necessary: that freedom of information laws should be extended to the private sector.....
The purpose of this monstrous proposal is not just to shine a light into the rattling cupboards of private companies, but to change the way in which they behave. A body that acts as if the world is watching presents less of a threat to the public interest than a body that knows it won't get caught. Would News International have acted as it did if its emails could have been revealed as a matter of course rather than a matter of chance? If it is true that "governments don't rule the world, Goldman Sachs rules the world", should we not be entitled to know what Goldman Sachs is up to? Is that not the only means we have of preventing its unelected power from becoming tyrannical?
It's not that monstrous. Readers might recall that a gutsy minister of our own raised the issue of FOI for the private sector in 2009.

In a post last June (and this earlier post in January 2011) I gave a rundown on Senator Faulkner's attempt to give the issue oxygen through an ALRC reference when he was Special Minister of State. The publicly announced cabinet decision to take that step came to nothing once Faulkner went to Defence that year. Then Attorney General McClelland showed no interest, and the public service in advising on ALRC references, said "move on."

No one in government or the opposition has said a public word on the topic since. 

Examination of transparency standards and how disclosure of information held by the private sector could enhance public knowledge and debate on issues of importance to the community should be on someone's agenda, given:
  • the power corporations exercise over the every day life of most of us,
  • the privatisation of functions previously in the hands of government but now carried out by the private sector,
  • the emergence of new private sector services that resemble public utilities in their scope and importance,
  • the adequacy/inadequacy of available information about private sector environmental impacts, or public health and community safety issues,
  • sectoral issues concerning, for example, disclosure by financial institutions that governments effectively guaranteed as a result of the GFC, and other corporates that might be in the "too big to fail "category.
 Any takers? Not holding my breath.

MEAA makes valuable contribution to press freedom discussion

The 2012 Report on Press Freedom in Australia by the Media Entertainment and Arts Alliance released last Friday provides a valuable summary of the state of play on a wide range of topics and is well worth a read. (See report here-pdf)

Kicking at the Cornerstone of Democracy devotes plenty of space to the Finkelstein and Convergence reviews and associated media ownership and diversity issues. But it also highlights that the high ideals and reforming zeal evident when Labor took office is hard to spot now in some key related areas. Two cases in point are the two years (and counting) silence on the ALRC Secrecy Laws and Open Government in Australia report with more than 60 recommendations for dealing with the crazy crowded secrecy quilt consisting of  506 secrecy provisions in 176 pieces of federal legislation, including 358 distinct criminal offences; and the oft promised still to be delivered protection for public service whistleblowers with the last in a long line of missed deadlines, June 30, 2011. 

The states have plenty to do as well particularly regarding an improved framework for court suppression orders.

The summary of submissions to a NSW statutory review of defamation law by Joseph Fernandez is the first coverage I have seen of this.

Several articles include some welcome balance on the privacy front and others cover Freedom of Information developments-I'll pick up on the latter in separate posts.

Friday, May 04, 2012

AAT pulls the shade on FOI access to Australian Honours guidelines

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Deputy President Hack in Kline and Official Secretary to the Governor General [2012] AATA 247 upheld the decision by Freedom of Information Commissioner Popple that documents sought concerning the operation of the Australian honours system were not subject to the Freedom of Information Act. 

For shades of Sir Humphrey, read on.

Ms Kline had sought access to documents concerning unsuccessful nominations by her of another person for an award in 2007 and 2009, and two other categories of documents: "Working manuals, policy guidelines and criteria related to the administration of awards within The Order of Australia", and "Documents relating to review processes i.e. right of appeal in cases of maladministration."

The issue before the Tribunal was whether the Office was required to deal with the application in the light of  s 6A: the act "does not apply to any request for access to a document of the Official Secretary to the Governor-General unless the document relates to matters of an administrative nature." If the application came within s 6A a separate question not raised in this case would arise concerning any relevant exemptions.

Deputy President Hack rejected what he described (without elaboration) as "sophisticated arguments" on the applicant's behalf, that the words relate to "matters of an administrative nature" should be interpreted broadly. He preferred to use his words, a "simple answer": any documents that relate to any substantive functions of the Governor-General including the award of honours are outside the scope of s 6A. :
 ".. documents generated in connection with the conferral of honours do not ordinarily relate to matters of an administrative nature...While it is possible to conceive of exceptions to this general proposition (correspondence with the supplier of medals and insignia, or with a caterer providing refreshments at the awards ceremony come to mind), the documents in question do not relate to this sort of matter. If the Act was intended to apply to documents generated in connection with a wider view of the Governor-General’s functions, it would have done so using clear words.
(Comment: An even simpler approach might be that "relates to matters of an administrative nature" means "relates to matters of management and administration" but we won't go there.)

In reaching his decision Deputy President Hack drew on the decision of Justice Gray in Bienstein v Family Court of Australia, a Federal Court case involving s 5 and the same FOI limitation as it applies to  documents held by the courts. The Deputy President saw similarities between the functions of the Governor General in making decisions on award nominees, and those of a judge exercising a judicial function. In both cases closed doors were necessary.
22. Choices have to be made between the nominees, and unsuccessful nominees may be upset when they are overlooked. Making those choices is akin to a judicial function that involves the exercise of delicate judgement. The Governor-General has the benefit of the advice of the Council of the Order when making her decisions; the Council is comprised of independent persons who bring a range of experiences and perspectives to bear on their work. That frank advice is essential to the process. While judges give reasons for their opinions, the decision in Bienstein confirms the courts are not expected to expose internal documents that might compromise the integrity of the process in the public mind, if only because they could be misunderstood or muddy the waters. That approach applies equally to documents held by the Official Secretary in relation to the system of honours.
23. The award of honours remains part of the Governor-General’s function, and – like a good deal of the work of the Governor-General – that process has occurred behind closed doors for good reason.
if Deputy President Hack is correct in taking a narrow view of s 6A, this analogy may be correct as far as it goes, putting beyond FOI reach documents held by the Office concerning individuals nominated for awards.

But the reasoning doesn't explain how this "closed doors" imperative is a relevant consideration when it comes to the manuals, guidelines and criteria for awards, and any documents held concerning review procedures. Why such documents need protection because disclosure would impact on "frank advice", "compromise the integrity of the process in the public mind" or "muddy the waters" remains a mystery. Au contraire, disclosure might have a positive rather than a negative impact.

I understand the applicant in this case has preliminary legal advice that there are grounds for appeal.

The broader public policy issue that deserves further consideration is why criteria and guidelines used in determining Australian Honours awards are not published or accessible. 

Arguably documents of this kind are the type that Parliament intended should be made publicly available by every government agency. "Operational information" (defined in s 8A to include rules, guidelines, practices and precedents relating to decisions and recommendations) must be published as part of each agency's Information Publication Scheme- unless exempt.(Government House has no published operational information.)

In line with this decision the Office of Official Secretary won't have to bother dealing with any application for documents for anything to do with the Governor General's substantive functions.

It raises the question how properly to categorise Honours manuals, guidelines and criteria and any similar documents held at Government House if they are not policy or related to matters of an administrative nature? Contributions by sir humphreys welcome.

That said it reminds of the exchange on the BBC's Yes Minister program as Sir Humphrey and the minister darted and weaved to avoid questions before a parliamentary committee- by distinguishing policy and administration.
Betty Oldham: Look, Sir Humphrey, whatever we ask the Minister, he says is an administrative question for you, and whatever we ask you, you say is a policy question for the Minister. How do you suggest we find out what is going on?
Sir Humphrey Appleby: Yes, yes, yes, I do see that there is a real dilemma here. In that, while it has been government policy to regard policy as a responsibility of Ministers and administration as a responsibility of Officials, the questions of administrative policy can cause confusion between the policy of administration and the administration of policy, especially when responsibility for the administration of the policy of administration conflicts, or overlaps with, responsibility for the policy of the administration of policy. 

Thursday, May 03, 2012

Privacy law reform on the agenda, again

Attorney General Roxon's Media Release yesterday about privacy law reform received a good run in the media but the detail will only be apparent when the legislation foreshadowed for the winter sittings is introduced. The Senate Finance and Public Administration Committee made 59 recommendations in its reports last year on the  Exposure Draft of the Australian Privacy Principles. and the Exposure Draft on Credit Reporting and there were plenty of other suggestions raised in consultations. The Attorney's release doesn't go into explanation of what has been accepted or rejected, simply listing these benefits to consumers:
  • clearer and tighter regulation of the use of personal information for direct marketing
  • extending privacy protections to unsolicited information
  • making it easier for consumers to access and correct information held about them
  • tightening the rules on sending personal information outside Australia
  • enhancing the powers of the Privacy Commissioner to improve the Commissioner’s ability to resolve complaints, conduct investigations and promote privacy compliance
The Government will also modernise credit reporting arrangements. Benefits for consumers include:
  • making a clear obligation on organisations to substantiate, or show their evidence to justify, disputed credit listings
  • making it easier for individuals to access and correct their credit reporting information
  • prohibiting the collection of credit reporting information about children
  • simplifying the complaints process by removing requirement to complain to the organisation first, complaints can be made directly to the Privacy Commissioner, and by introducing alternative dispute resolution to more efficiently deal with complaints."
In a separate release Australian Privacy Commissioner Timothy Pilgrim elaborated on what the proposed extension of his powers will allow:
  • Accept a written undertaking from an organisation that they will take or refrain from a specified action. This will be enforceable in the Federal Court or Federal Magistrates Court.
  • Make a determination following an investigation conducted on the Commissioner’s own initiative. Currently, the Act only allows a determination to be made when investigating a complaint from an individual about an act of practice.
  • Seek civil penalties in the case of serious or repeated interferences with privacy.
  • Conduct performance assessments of private sector organisations handling personal information. Currently the Commissioner can only conduct audits of government agencies and credit reporting agencies.
    I'm sure the Attorney General didn't mean to make it sound as if this is game set and match on privacy law reform:
    These changes.... will implement the Government’s response to the Australian Law Reform Commission’s report – For your information: Australian Privacy Law and Practice."
    The first stage response more like it.

    As the government said way back in 2009 a whole raft of other ALRC recommendations were to be considered in stage two including exemptions generally and in particular removal of exemptions for small business and political parties and tightening up the media exemption; mandatory data-breach notification; a statutory cause of action for serious invasions of privacy (on which there has been a consultation of sorts); telecommunications privacy; decision making issues (such as authorised representatives and children’s privacy); and further national harmonisation. We aren't anywhere near done with a process that kicked off in 2006 with the reference to the ALRC.


    Tuesday, May 01, 2012

    Can the media make a good fist of self-regulation?

    The Finkelstein review report released in February didn't think so. It said the media had had the opportunity regarding print, had failed, and showed no sign of interest or capacity to address shortcomings. Separately it concluded that ACMA’s co-regulatory processes for television and broadcasting were cumbersome and slow. "The problems with both the external and self-regulatory mechanisms are inherent, and cannot be easily remedied by piecemeal measures." Hence a recommendation that a new statutory authority, the News Media Council, be established to set journalistic standards and handle complaints made by the public when those standards were breached.

     End of the world headlines that followed included:
    "Media fears for freedom as watchdog unleashed" in The Australian
    "Watchdog a 'threat to free press'" in The Australian
    "Put simply, mooted muzzle would not work" in The Australian
    "Bringing the media to heel" editorial in The Australian
    "Media union to fight government control" in the Herald Sun

    So this week, the Convergence Review in its final report stepped back from the Fink, suggesting the media be given another go, this time to achieve something even more complex than previously attempted, a self-regulatory scheme for all big news professional players regardless of platform (except the public broadcasters):
    The Review proposes that the government first test the effectiveness of a self-regulatory arrangement that operates across all platforms. Under this approach, content service enterprises would be required to join and adequately fund an independent self-regulatory industry body which would develop self-regulatory standards for news and commentary and adjudicate complaints. As stated, this body would be predominantly funded by industry with some government contribution. The news standards body would set clear goals to be achieved within a specified time frame. If, on review, this industry-led body was not effective, the government would have the last resort option of introducing some direct statutory measures.
    The Finkelstein stick has been transformed into the threat of a statutory regulator if they don't get it right this time. As Margaret Simons in Crikey (subscription) writes:
    The Convergence Review Report has effectively concluded that Ray Finkelstein got the diagnosis right but the prescription wrong when he recommended statutory regulation for news media.
    Perhaps the stick is worth waving but who would predict with any degree of confidence that a government three to five years hence would ever use it, regardless of how the proposed standards body performs? 

    Government money might be something of an incentive to media leaders to move along recommended lines. So too the prospect of legal privileges being linked to such arrangements, although stronger language than "could" might make the point more effectively:
    Membership of the news standards body could be a condition of retaining legal privileges currently provided for news and commentary in Commonwealth legislation. In particular, it seems reasonable that only those organisations that have committed to an industry self-regulatory scheme for upholding journalistic standards of fairness and accuracy should be entitled to the exemptions from the provisions of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 concerning misleading and deceptive statements and from the obligations of the Privacy Act 1988 that would otherwise apply to those organisations. However, there is not the same argument for applying this requirement to laws protecting journalists’ sources. These laws apply to information collected by individual journalists, who might be freelance journalists rather than employees of an organisation.
    The proposed communications regulator would have a role in the scheme including oversight of the adequacy of codes and capacity to act in the case of persistent or serious breaches. Chapter 4 of the Final Report has the details.

    Given media hostility to the Fink, the proposed scheme reeks of pragmatism and realpolitick, and  comes with a load of qualifications about the prospects for real improvement in media standards. But given the state of play in Canberra it's unimaginable that the tough Fink line was ever a goer regardless of how you see the merits.

    Media reaction to the report is, well a shade less alarm, although there is some of that, but in some instances, positive support. Chair of the Australian Press Council Professor Julian Disney welcomed the report, and wants prompt government action. The MEAA likes what it sees but thinks the recent strengthening of the Press Council with increased funding and commitment is already a big step in the right direction. Fairfax and some other players say yes, let's talk.

    No prize for guessing News Limited says no way. It is yet to agree there is a problem, let alone articulate a better way forward. Its leadership credentials have been somewhat diminished by developments elsewhere in any event but it is far and away the biggest funder of the Press Council.

    Comment from academe on The Conversation suggests it's all a far cry from what is really needed to lift standards.

    Martin Hirst of Deakin University:
    At best this suggested change amounts to a new set of dentures for the existing publisher’s poodle. It will be able to accept sanitised government funding in ways that will not upset the old-guard in the newspaper industry who see Armageddon in every attempt at regulation by government. There is no indication in this 170+ page report that there is any real problem or issue with media accountability and standards in Australia. This is a whitewash of the highest standard.

    There are some strong recommendations which deserve to be applauded, but the bottom line is, the recommendations of the Convergence Review will likely do little to solve the problems that prompted public concern in the United Kingdom and in Australia about news organisations their culture, ethics and practices..Unless forced, I doubt the new standards body will be able to agree to enforce a common media code aimed at promoting fairness, accuracy and transparency.

    Sunday, April 29, 2012

    Parliament sails above expected standards of transparency

    Amid all the hubbub about Speaker Slipper, sure not to die down anytime soon despite his decision to step aside for the moment, I've been wondering when the mainstream media would notice that reams of material about his (or any parliamentarians') expenditure of public money seems to be available from the Department of Finance and Deregulation, either in published form or in response to Freedom of Information applications, but nothing from the Parliament itself about payments made to or on his behalf.

    Parliament not Finance pays salaries and electorate allowances of parliamentarians, additional salaries of parliamentary office holders, superannuation entitlements, resettlement allowance payments, and services and facilities to support parliamentarians in Parliament House including the cost of office accommodation, computing and other equipment, telephones, newspapers and stationery. And perhaps travel for office holders such as the speaker when on business connected to that office, but who knows, this is murky territory.

    But hallelujah, this in an editorial in the Sydney Morning Herald on Saturday:
    The case also raises the issue of transparency. Parliament is not covered by freedom-of-information legislation. It should be. It is no breach of Westminster tradition: the British Parliament is covered by it, as was shown by the recent expenses scandal. Given that Parliament has a budget of $180 million to spend on its members, there is significant public interest in ensuring it is spent properly.
    I won't go back over years of pointing out that the Australian Law Reform Commission recommended this, ahem, 17 years ago. (Well I will actually.)

    Or that no government or parliamentary leader has given a response since. 

    Or that I've been ranting on for yonks about gaps in transparency for payments to parliamentarians most recently last week, further back last November or even further back, a year ago.

    Or that parliament has been fiddling but not acting to establish the position of parliamentary integrity commissioner?

    Has anyone asked minister for integrity issues/parliamentary entitlements, Special Minister of State Gray? 

    Or the presiding officers of parliament?

    Wait a minute, one of those is Speaker Slipper  who retains the position despite the fact he has stood aside from chairing parliamentary debate.

    Ah you've got to love 'em!

    Differences in FOI acts in protecting against harassment or intimidation

    Privacy Commissioner Pilgrim in  'I' and Australian National University [2012] AICmr 12  (the first published review decision in which he rather than Professor McMillan or Dr Popple exercised powers under the Freedom of Information Act) set aside a decision to refuse access to emails sent to climate change scientists at the ANU that had been the basis of earlier media reports that death threats had been made against them. (Update: Christian Kerr in The Australian on 3 May provided a racier account, the ANU has since decided against appealing the decison, and Chris Merritt  found scope for some point scoring against Fairfax.)
     
    Of interest is that the Commonwealth act contains no counterpart to provisions found in Queensland,Tasmanian and NSW acts that provide grounds for refusal where, with regard to matters of this kind, the likely effect of disclosure falls short of a reasonable expectation of harm to life and safety. Those state acts throw the risk or likelihood of harassment or intimidation into the harm mix.

    Access in this case had been refused by the University on the basis of Section 37(1)(c) of the FOI act, that disclosure would, or could reasonably be expected to endanger the life or physical safety of any person, and Section 47F, the conditional exemption for personal information. The latter claim failed because the applicant was not seeking information that would reveal the identity of the individuals sending or receiving the emails in question.

    Commissioner Pilgrim was satisfied that disclosure of the content of the documents could not be expected to endanger life or physical safety of any person. His decision was that edited copies (with information removed that would identify the individuals sending or receiving the emails) should be released to the applicant.

    Tuesday, April 24, 2012

    Privacy Awareness Week

    Privacy Awareness Week kicks off on 30 April at breakfast in Sydney with Privacy Commissioner Timothy Pilgrim leading a panel discussion about data breaches and privacy best practice. Australian Information Commissioner Professor John McMillan will also launch the OAIC's revised Guide to Handling Personal Information Security Breaches at the event. Initiatives such as this and other events scheduled for the week by the OAIC, and the Northern Terrritory, Queensland, NSW and Victorian regulators to raise awareness are to be applauded.

    Meanwhile consideration of the case for a legislated requirement for notification of a serious breach of data security presumably grinds on.

    Privacy law reform generally, identified by the federal government as long ago as 2006 as an issue, has moved at glacial pace since the government's announced response in October 2009 to the Australian Law Reform Commission report of a year earlier. First stage reform issues such as the proposed new form Australian Privacy Principles are still unfinished business.

    Monday, April 23, 2012

    Slipper saga reminds of lack of transparency concerning payments to parliamentarians

    7 News
    Plenty to read about House of Representatives Speaker Peter Slipper, some courtesy of documents obtained under Freedom of Information by News Limited publications from the Department of Finance and Deregulation, which manages most entitlement payments to members and senators.

    But details of payments and related information concerning use of entitlements by Mr Slipper for which the parliament itself is responsible haven't featured so far. That sort of information about parliamentarians isn't available. See this post from last November about gaps in the system of accountability and transparency and recommendations for change, yet to be acted upon by parliament or the government, that have been floating around for years.

    Long before it became an issue attracting national attention, Bill Hoffman at the Sunshine Coast Daily was on the Peter Slipper expense case. In March he detailed his unsuccessful effort to access information about payments by the parliament while Mr Slipper was Deputy Speaker last year.

    Hoffman's article included this response from House of Representatives Serjeant-at-Arms Robyn McClelland which referred for the first time to future consideration of a public reporting regime for such payments, On past form don't expect to hear much from parliamentarians about the subject, or prompt action on much-needed improvements to the system:
    Dear Mr Hoffman,
    I refer to previous emails. The department has considered your request.
    We have not previously had a request to our knowledge for % (sic) release of details of expenditure for services provided to individual members. Such details have not been released previously and we do not propose to make the details that you have requested available to you at this time. We will consider a public reporting regime involving publication of expenditure details. Any development of a reporting regime will involve considering the information available, developing a consistent approach across the parliamentary departments, and consultation with members. We will write to inform you if the information becomes publicly available.

    Friday, April 20, 2012

    NBN Co FOI performance review won't examine broader exclusion issues

    Attorney-General Nicola Roxon announced this week that what has ensued since June 2011 when NBN Co commenced operating under the Commonwealth Freedom of Information Act (albeit with coverage limited to documents that don't concern commercial activities) will be reviewed by a yet to be named eminent person. 

    The review stems from an agreement between the government and The Greens reached at the time the amendment was passed to bring NBN Co under FOI law a year ago. The Greens were wary that the government formulation of the NBN Co exemption, along the lines of long standing exemptions enjoyed by other GBEs and similar bodies, left too much room for avoiding disclosure, hence the agreed review of performance in return for their votes. At the time Malcolm Turnbull of the Opposition was convinced The Greens had been conned, and that the legislated formula provided too much hiding room for NBN Co. We'll see what has happened when the review report is tabled in parliament in June. I'm assuming, knowing all along that the review was to happen, that NBN Co has been reasonably well behaved.
      
    Broader issues
    The review notwithstanding, the justification for special exemptions afforded to a range of organisations and the inelegant form of words used in s7 and schedule 2 to achieve this will remain matters for another day. Along with the justification for exclusion of an unknown number of government owned corporations similar to NBN Co in structure, such as the National Electronic Health Transition Authority, that carry out important public functions with large allocations of public money.

    Similar issues, rarely explored in most instances, also exist at state level.(Tasmania may be an exception because of the broad definition of public authority in s 5.)

    Queensland Attorney General showed interest in scope issues in opposition
    In Queensland last year  the Supreme Court ruled Special Purpose Vehicles were not subject to the Right to information Act. Then Opposition Member for Kawana, Jarrod Bleijie introduced the Right to Information (Government-related Entities) Amendment Bill into Parliament in September, partly in response to the court decision. Mr Bleijie is now Attorney General, minister responsible for the RTI act.

    His 2011 bill, which lapsed when parliament was dissolved prior to the election in March, would extend the RTI act to cover "any corporation supported directly or indirectly by government funds or other assistance, or over which the state, a minister or a department is in a position to exercise control."

    The RTI act currently (s 16) provides for extension of the act by regulation to such entities, but Labor made no move in this direction. Mr Bleijie in opposition saw merit in legislating in a job lot for such bodies to be subject to the RTI act but it remains to be seen whether the view from behind a ministerial desk takes on a different hue-as so often is the case. 



    Thursday, April 19, 2012

    Official: Victorian FOI fails to deliver

    The report by the Victorian Auditor General on the extent to which the 11 Victorian public sector (VPS) departments and Victoria Police meet the requirements of the Freedom of Information Act 1982 won't surprise those who work in or have experience in dealing with the system.

     Media reports today grab on to "scathing" and "damning" to describe the report's findings but the report best speaks for itself:
    Since FOI legislation was introduced 30 years ago, Victoria has gone from being at the forefront of FOI law and administration to one of the least progressive jurisdictions in Australia. Over time, apathy and resistance to scrutiny have adversely affected the operation of the Act, restricting the amount of information being released. As a result, agencies are not meeting the object of the Act, which is ‘to extend as far as possible the right of the community to access information’. The public’s right to timely, comprehensive and accurate information is consequently being frustrated. The VPS’s systemic failure to support this right is a failure to deliver Parliament’s intent. The prevailing culture and lack of transparent processes allow principal officer —secretaries and chief executive officers of agencies—to avoid fulfilling their responsibilities. Principal officers are not being held to account for their agency’s underperformance and non-compliance. Agencies are routinely disregarding the 45- day statutory time limit for processing requests and the five-day ministerial noting period, and there are serious flaws in record keeping practices and FOI searches in the Department of Human Services and Victoria Police. The Department of Justice has not satisfactorily fulfilled its role as lead agency for FOI. More effective leadership is required to promote an appropriate culture, improve transparency of government information and adequately inform Parliament and the community about FOI.
    The Ombudsman has reached similar conclusions in various reports over the years to no avail, as the Auditor General notes citing this example:
    None of the 12 audited agencies implemented all of the recommendations made by the Victorian Ombudsman in 2006. This is indicative of a poor, resistant culture and low level of priority placed on FOI, which DOJ has not managed to address effectively.
    The report does not reflect on the role ministers have played in all this- ministerial conduct being  beyond the auditor's reach-but ministers in governments of both persuasions set tone at the top and went along happily with nary a word of concern about a system now described as apathetic and resistant to scrutiny.

    Premier Baillieu gilds the lily in claiming (as reported in The Age) that government legislation to establish a freedom of information commissioner is the answer to the problem. That act doesn't encompass the more fundamental reform needed to mandate pro-active disclosure or changes to exemption provisions that would bring Victorian law closer to contemporary standards that properly balance confidentiality in the interests of good government and public rights to gain access to government information.

    A 45 day response time for requests which, according to the Auditor General, is routinely disregarded in any event, is a bad joke in this day and age. As is the formal practice of "ministerial noting" before an agency decision is notified to the applicant- a practice open to abuse and the cause of long delays in some cases documented in the report.

    The FOI commissioner model adopted in Victoria but yet to commence has significant weaknesses apparent well before it takes effect but which were simply shrugged off by the government during parliamentary debate.

    While these holes in the bucket remain as they are, as well as serious systemic flaws in record management practices identified by the Auditor General (documented in detail in this 2008 report  and raised also in this recent Ombudsman report Own motion investigation into the management and storage of ward records by the Department of Human Services (256KB) FOI  in Victoria will continue to fail to deliver fully on its promise

    Wednesday, April 18, 2012

    Australia shuns good company at OGP meeting in Brazil

    You are known by the company you keep. For this reason Australia sensibly looks for a seat at the right international tables. But for some reason we weren't in Brazilia yesterday in any official capacity at least, when over 1,000 representatives from 55 member governments  and 200 civil society organisations got together for the first annual high-level meeting of the Open Government Partnership (OGP), an initiative launched in September 2011 by President Obama and Brazilian President Rousseff. 

    The meeting was chaired by President Rousseff and U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton who spoke of the opportunity the OGP provided to
    "set a new global standard for good governance and to strengthen a global ethos of transparency and accountability... we intend to do all we can to help make the Open Government Partnership a leader in ensuring that the 21st century is an era of openness, transparency, accountability, freedom, democracy, and results for people everywhere."
    47 countries have joined the partnership in the last eight months. Apart from President Rousseff and Secretary Clinton, President Kikwete of Tanzania, Prime Minister Gilauri of Georgia, UK Cabinet Minister Frances Maude, and dozens of senior government leaders from around the world thought it important enough to attend the Brazil meeting. Libya was represented. The UK and US are co-chairs for the next 12 months.

    The Australian government talks the talk about the importance of open government but either has difficulties with the partnership concept not shared by those who have joined, or other more pressing priorities. Our reasons for not signing up are so far unexplained, although in response to my report that the word recently in Washington was we would not be joining, a spokesperson was quoted by itnews saying we continue to consider and consult- eight months on for heavens sake!

    Australian ministers who should have an interest including Attorney General Roxon (on Q&A and elsewhere) and Foreign Minister Carr (on his first visit to Europe) obviously had other pressing matters requiring their attention, but Trade Minister Emerson has been in Latin America for the past week for other reasons, and in Brazilia days ago, but apparently with no time for this sort of stuff, and had moved on to Colombia by the time the meeting began.

    More than a pity that we sit out international action on open government in the 21st century while the following participating countries give it a high priority and the cause a shot in the arm by being seen in this sort of good company. Australia and NZ could give the notably light Asia -Pacific region representation a lift:
    (* denotes Steering Committee member):

    Brazil* Colombia Italy Peru
    Indonesia* Costa Rica Jordan Romania
    Mexico* Croatia Kenya Russia
    Norway* Czech Republic Latvia Serbia
    Philippines* Denmark Liberia Slovak Republic
    South Africa* Dominican Republic Lithuania South Korea
    United Kingdom* El Salvador Macedonia Spain
    United States* Estonia Malta Sweden
    Albania Georgia Moldova Tanzania
    Armenia Ghana Mongolia Trinidad and Tobago
    Azerbaijan Greece Montenegro Turkey
    Bulgaria Guatemala Netherlands Ukraine
    Canada Honduras Panama Uruguay
    Chile Israel Paraguay

    Friday, April 13, 2012

    Overseas FOI travel bug

     I'm not the only Aussie with an FOI interest voyaging forth-according to this post by Alasdair Roberts he and Australian Information Commissioner John McMillan spoke at a forum in Beijing earlier this week entitled "Does Access to Information Really Make Governments More Transparent."  Hopefully the short answer was "yes" but I'm sure there is an interested audience beyond Beijing. Professor McMillan's speech or other details of the discussion are yet to appear on the OAIC website. 

     I'll be back in the middle of next week.

    Friday, March 30, 2012

    Out of touch-again

    While in Spain, France and Italy-no sympathy messages required-I'll be mostly resuming my out of touch position.