Today's papers reveal more about the MacDonald saga in NSW and "a Dubai connection" following his resignation as minister and member of parliament last week over travel expenses, with the Premier yesterday tabling a report (without attachments which the Premier said contain personal information about individuals) by the Director General of her department. The report has gone to the Independent Commission Against Corruption. Want to see it yourself? Sorry, it will take a trip to Macquarie St. in business hours. Papers tabled in Parliament don't go up on its website, the Premier's newsroom doesn't mention the matter, and the latest news on the Department of Premier and Cabinet is about the clasification of Research Scientist positions in the public service.
Come 1 July and the commencement of the GIPA act, "information about the agency contained in any document tabled in Parliament by or on behalf of the agency" will be open access information in NSW and is to be published on the internet. Would a report by the Director General about a minister's expenses contain "information about the agency" I wonder?
This blog takes an interest in issues associated with Freedom of Information (FOI) and privacy legislation in Australia. Information contained on this site is general in nature and does not constitute legal advice. Follow Peter Timmins on Twitter: @foiguru Follow the open government cause through the Australian Open Government Partnership Network. www.opengovernment.org.au and @opengovau
Search This Blog
Friday, June 11, 2010
Thursday, June 10, 2010
NSW Information Commissioner on target with $4 million
The performance information includes the Office estimate of about 1,000 contacts from the public this year, 100 investigations of complaints, depending on demand, and plans to undertake 10 agency audits. It will be working towards a range of intermediate outcomes some of which pose some interesting measurement challenges:
¨ rights to access information understood by the public
¨ increased access to information
¨ fewer complaints to OIC over conduct of government agencies in releasing information
¨ fewer formal applications for access to information
¨ fewer people seeking review of agency decisions
¨ improved information management by agencies and
¨ effective stakeholder relationships.
I'd be glad to tell you what's there for Privacy NSW, now co-located with the Office of Information Commissioner but still a separate business unit of the Attorney General's Department, if I could find any reference to it in the Budget Papers. Anyone?
Wednesday, June 09, 2010
Evidence from "Trance bought " no help in TCard public interest immunity claim
The only (unintended) light note in this judgment of Justice Einstein in the NSW Supreme Court on a public interest immunity claim by the State of New South Wales was the reference to one of the witnesses, Mr Nicholls, "currently acting as Deputy Director General of the Department of Trance bought and infrastructure" [at 38 and probably corrected by the time you get to read it.] Ah, the perils of proof reading in the age of Spellcheck... and yes I've had a few, so chin up to the Judge's Associate.Update-still there a week later so you wonder who read the judgment.
The rest was a setback for the heavyweight legal team of Mr P Hastings QC, Ms C Spruce, Mr R Bhalla, and Mr J Mitchell, instructed by the Crown Solicitor. They argued on behalf of the State that certain documents should be withheld from discovery by the defendants in this lawsuit initiated by the Government following its decision to terminate the ERG contract for an integrated smartcard-based ticketing and fare payment system for public transport in Sydney. The issue was a claim that the documents should not be discoverable by the defendants because they related to matters of state and the public interest in producing them was outweighed by the public interest in preserving secrecy or confidentiality (Section 130(1) of the Evidence Act.
Justice Einstein was unpersuaded by the evidence of the two public servants who under cross examination [34-36 and 39-41] were shown to have not turned their minds to a principled approach to the issue, and in effect signed affidavits that were put in front of them concerning the status of the documents:
45 In truth the materials put forward by the State’s witnesses fell far short of discharging the requirement that there be some form of transparency in relation to how there had been determined from amongst the many documents discovered those to be reviewed for public interest immunity.
46 It was important for the Court to have before it from the State, evidence upon which the court could rely in order to be in a position to understand what were the criteria by reference to which it came to be contended that particular documents were described as Cabinet minutes. To my mind it became clear from the above-described cross-examination that the proponents had insufficient knowledge of that process [and insufficient knowledge of the issues in the proceedings] to satisfy the court as to what the above-described criteria were.
Justice Einstein said the State bears the onus of seeking to have the Court exercise its discretion to prevent disclosure of documents:
49 ..... In that regard the State is the person seeking to prevent the production of material documents and must demonstrate that the material documents relate to matters of state and that the balancing test favours non-production. The onus is a heavy burden requiring a proponent of the immunity who is resisting production to "establish a 'real’ rather than merely 'some' or 'any detriment to the public interest from disclosure" of the documents: cf: Cadbury Schweppes Pty Ltd v Amcor Limited [2008] FCA 88 at [25]; Somerville v ASC (1995) 60 FCR 319 at 354.
50 In any event even if a considerable number of the documents do relate to matters of State, subject to what is said below, the balancing exercise favours inspection. The defendants in these proceedings face a damages claim brought by the PTTC of $77 million for monies allegedly spent by the PTTC and the NSW Government between 2002 and 2008 supervising the Project in addition to a claim for compound interest. Many of the documents relate to briefings to the Minister or meetings referred to in the PTTC’s own evidence in support of its claim. I accept that as a matter of fairness and in the interests of the Court having all relevant evidence put before it, ITSL and ERG should be permitted to inspect the Claim Documents.
Justice Einstein was prepared to order only that " the allegedly confidential documents identified with the words ' Cabinet-In-Confidence' " be withheld but nothing else including briefings to the Minister.
Tuesday, June 08, 2010
1 November extra special this year
From PM&C :
"The Governor-General has proclaimed 1 November 2010 as the day the Australian Information Commissioner Act 2010 commences. The new Office of the Australian Information Commissioner will be established from that date and the majority of measures in the Freedom of Information Amendment (Reform) Act 2010 will also commence on 1 November 2010. Different commencement times apply for:
· the Information Publication Scheme (new Part II of the FOI Act) which will commence on 1 May 2011,
· a requirement for agencies to publish information where access has been given under Part III of the FOI Act (new section 11C FOI Act) which will commence on 1 May 2011;
· changes to bring forward the ‘open access period’ in the Archives Act 1983 for most records from 30 years to 20 years which will begin on 1 January 2011 (records created in 1980 or 1981) and will be phased in over a ten year period so that a record created in 2000 will be in the open access period on 1 January 2021; and
· changes to bring forward the ‘open access period’ in the Archives Act for Cabinet notebooks from 50 years to 30 years which will begin on 1 January 2011 and will be phased in over a ten year period so that a Cabinet notebook created in 1990 will be in the open access period on 1 January 2021.
Professor John McMillan AO, who is the Information Commissioner Designate, will start as the first Australian Information Commissioner on 1 November 2010."
"The Governor-General has proclaimed 1 November 2010 as the day the Australian Information Commissioner Act 2010 commences. The new Office of the Australian Information Commissioner will be established from that date and the majority of measures in the Freedom of Information Amendment (Reform) Act 2010 will also commence on 1 November 2010. Different commencement times apply for:
· the Information Publication Scheme (new Part II of the FOI Act) which will commence on 1 May 2011,
· a requirement for agencies to publish information where access has been given under Part III of the FOI Act (new section 11C FOI Act) which will commence on 1 May 2011;
· changes to bring forward the ‘open access period’ in the Archives Act 1983 for most records from 30 years to 20 years which will begin on 1 January 2011 (records created in 1980 or 1981) and will be phased in over a ten year period so that a record created in 2000 will be in the open access period on 1 January 2021; and
· changes to bring forward the ‘open access period’ in the Archives Act for Cabinet notebooks from 50 years to 30 years which will begin on 1 January 2011 and will be phased in over a ten year period so that a Cabinet notebook created in 1990 will be in the open access period on 1 January 2021.
Professor John McMillan AO, who is the Information Commissioner Designate, will start as the first Australian Information Commissioner on 1 November 2010."
That's a lot of lead up time for the proactive publication requirements to kick in- agencies have been on notice something like this was coming since March 2009, and commencement is still 11 months away. Not sure of the practical effect and he is sure to be persuasive in the lead up in any event, but Information Commissioner Designate, Professor McMillan will have no statutory powers until 1 November.(Update: The Minister's announcement has Professor McMillan happy with arrangements, and indicating "Cultural change is under way.")
Intelligence secrecy sacrosanct
The cone of silence that surrounds Australian intelligence organisations, in the name of national security, is in the news with a long term resident to be deported on ASIO's say so, but without being able to know and answer the allegations against him, and an academic taking on National Archives over refusal of access to assessments of the situation in East Timor 35 years ago that summarise intelligence reports during the Indonesian invasion and occupation. Ben Saul, a barrister involved in the case, writes about the deportation of Mansour Leghaei in Condemned by faceless accusers and secret evidence in the Sydney Morning Herald, complete with uncomfortable comparisons with Kafka's The Trial. Clinton Fernandes of the Australian Defence Force Academy at the University of NSW tells his story-yet to be played out in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal in what the Government submits should be a closed hearing - to Peter Mares on ABC Radio National The National Interest. In an apparent cock-up-and according to Mares, with no involvement at all of the intelligence agencies , part of the program dropped out when originally broadcast but this version is complete.
I notice a comment on the site from Jim Dunn, Australian Consul in East Timor way, way back, and long time activist for independence and justice there:
Re the release of classified material concerning event in E Timor 35 years ago. I cannot believe that in the changed political environment in Indonesian that our national interests will be damaged. In the case of Indonesia there is a growing interest in knowing the truth about the past. Re our security, DSD (Defence Signals Directorate) operations in the past are no longer a secret so the release should not pose a danger. There are also quite a few Parliamentary research service reports that could be released. What we still desperately need is a full account of what was known, and what actions were taken. As for Gough Whitlam's role, his positive achievements will always serve to balance his contribution to our political history. Finally if our nation is to learn the lessons of history, there is no alternative to a full exposure of the past, including highly classified material.
Protecting national security is an important high priority but some of the claims in its name, blanket exclusions from transparency laws, and alleged sensitivity about what we knew 35 years ago go way beyond what is necessary and justified.
Waterford on integrity
Jack Waterford, Editor-at-Large Canberra Times, wrote a scorching piece "Rudd's race to the bottom" (published 2 June but no link available), denied a wider audience for some unknown reason as neither the Times nor Fairfax National Times posted it online. Waterford lets go on the subject of integrity, without any amateur psychoanalysis of what drives the Prime Minister, although I'm reading David Marr's Quarterly Essay on that subject with interest. As the pioneer journalist Freedom of Information expert his ranking of the recent federal FOI reforms as "minor improvements" constitutes a lower grade than my "good and welcome but a long way short..." assessment, and a sharp contrast to effusive praise from the media coalition.
On where the Rudd Government stands after promising to govern differently, Waterford says
A longer extract follows.
On where the Rudd Government stands after promising to govern differently, Waterford says
It's been pretty much downhill since, particularly in matters readily placeable in a moral or idealistic calculus. The environment? Too hard, sorry. Refugees? Race you to the bottom. Aborigines? Just shut them up, please. Or shut them down. Democracy and debate in the party? No time. Probity and integrity with public money? Plllllease.
A longer extract follows.
Monday, June 07, 2010
Most parliaments fail modern standards on transparency of interests and entitlements
There is plenty of gory detail around about government in NSW with two more ministerial resignations on Friday, bringing to four the number of frontbenchers to resign in the last two weeks. The Premier herself is now caught up in the saga, and three inquiries are underway, including a referral to the ICAC. According to those who claim to be counting there have been169 or 215 ministerial changes since the 2007 election.
The resignation of Regional Development and Major Events Minister Ian MacDonald followed reports by Linton Besser of the Sydney Morning Herald about $30000 in flight upgrades that were not declared on the Pecuniary Interest Register, and the final straw, courtesy of documents released to the Opposition in response to a Freedom of Information application, that the taxpayer, not as MacDonald claimed, himself, who paid $2800 for an economy airfare to Dubai in 2008. That trip took place before ministers were instructed last year to publish details about their overseas travel, the subject of this recent reminder from Premier Keneally:
The resignation of Regional Development and Major Events Minister Ian MacDonald followed reports by Linton Besser of the Sydney Morning Herald about $30000 in flight upgrades that were not declared on the Pecuniary Interest Register, and the final straw, courtesy of documents released to the Opposition in response to a Freedom of Information application, that the taxpayer, not as MacDonald claimed, himself, who paid $2800 for an economy airfare to Dubai in 2008. That trip took place before ministers were instructed last year to publish details about their overseas travel, the subject of this recent reminder from Premier Keneally:Already, Ministers proactively release certain information on the Internet, including copies of all of their media releases (see M2008-18 (Availability of Ministers’ media release on NSW Government Agency Websites)) and (see M2009-10 (Release of Overseas Travel Information).
M 2009-10 to ministers was issued by former Premier Rees a year ago.
The whole area of entitlements and use of taxpayers money by ministers and members of parliament is still unacceptably opaque here. When UK Treasury Chief Secretary David Laws resigned recently over a kerfuffle about allowance payments, anyone interested could check The Green Book, the House of Commons Guide to Members Allowances to see the rules and where Laws went astray. But when questions were raised in NSW about flight upgrades and whether they should be publicly declared, the Premier said it was a grey area, journalists were able to quote from the handbook and advice was sought. But good luck to anyone trying to find Parliament's guidance to members on entitlements on the internet- I can't find a sign of it on NSW Parliament's website. The Register of Members Pecuniary Interests isn't on the web either. Imre Saluzinsky in The Australian said the latest edition available for inspection is 2008-2009!
The whole area of entitlements and use of taxpayers money by ministers and members of parliament is still unacceptably opaque here. When UK Treasury Chief Secretary David Laws resigned recently over a kerfuffle about allowance payments, anyone interested could check The Green Book, the House of Commons Guide to Members Allowances to see the rules and where Laws went astray. But when questions were raised in NSW about flight upgrades and whether they should be publicly declared, the Premier said it was a grey area, journalists were able to quote from the handbook and advice was sought. But good luck to anyone trying to find Parliament's guidance to members on entitlements on the internet- I can't find a sign of it on NSW Parliament's website. The Register of Members Pecuniary Interests isn't on the web either. Imre Saluzinsky in The Australian said the latest edition available for inspection is 2008-2009!
Parliamentary handbooks about entitlements and the rules that apply to payments administered by parliament are hard to find in other jurisdictions as well- I couldn't find any on a quick look, but happy to be corrected.
The South Australian Parliament seems to be ahead in publishing online an annual report on members interests and an annual reports on travel by individual members, although not even close to real time. And of course Tasmania from 1 July will be the only Australian jurisdiction where the right to information (concerning matters of an administrative nature) will extend to parliament itself.
It's an area crying out for the application of high standards of transparency. And disclosure on the internet, not by horse and buggy means.
Thursday, June 03, 2010
Gov 2.0 a hive of activity in some places
Lots of buzz in parts of the Gov 2.0 world with the Expo in Washington last week, including a panel session on Australian developments featuring Nicholas Gruen and Senator Kate Lundy among others, which seems to have attracted a small but impressed crowd. The Senator told the audience the Federal Government will soon make a declaration of open government, a key recommendation of the Gruen Task Force.There was also the CeBit Conference in Sydney, the start up of AGIMO's blog and plenty of twittering on the subject. Its good and welcome, with recognition, for example in Senator Lundy's remarks of the link between what often seems techo interest and activity, and the role the Australian Information Commissioner is to play in moving forward on open government and FOI reform generally..
Hope the same is true at state level. Mark Elliott and Pat McCormick gave Victorian developments a good airing at the Washington Panel session .But hard to tell what is happening elsewhere around the country. News welcome!
After a flurry late last year the NSW Chief Information Officer's Information @ the center website hardly gives the impression of great activity and the announcement of a winner from the bright ideas generated by the Apps4NSW competition is still awaited..The NSW Office of Information Commissioner rollout for the commencement of the GIPA act on 1 July includes guidance on compliance with the proactive publication requirements in the legislation but hard to see anything that connects compliance with the broader Gov 2.0 issues. Culture change is at the heart of both.
After a flurry late last year the NSW Chief Information Officer's Information @ the center website hardly gives the impression of great activity and the announcement of a winner from the bright ideas generated by the Apps4NSW competition is still awaited..The NSW Office of Information Commissioner rollout for the commencement of the GIPA act on 1 July includes guidance on compliance with the proactive publication requirements in the legislation but hard to see anything that connects compliance with the broader Gov 2.0 issues. Culture change is at the heart of both.
Wednesday, June 02, 2010
Ministers' media plans off FOI limits
Cute as it might sound, this knock back reported in The Age today of a freedom of information application for Victorian government ministerial media plans is probably well based in law:
The Office of the Premier knocked back a freedom-of-information request from The Age for the media plans, ruling that the documents are exempt because they contain material unrelated to department business. ''All of the documents requested are exempt documents on the basis that they are official documents of a minister that contain material of a political nature which does not relate to the affairs of an agency or a department,'' the decision by the Office of the Premier stated.Whether it's a good look, in the light of developments there concerning a parliamentary inquiry into media management by one minister's office, or what should be, is another matter.
As pointed out in this post in January, and its true of just about all our freedom of information laws, documents held by a minister are only subject to FOI where they relate to the affairs of an agency - with at least one possible change in prospect come 1 July 2010 with the commencement of the NSW Government Information (Public Access) Act. It remains to be seen how the act is interpreted and applied but it applies to information held by a minister or member of the minister's personal staff "in the course of the exercise of official functions in,or for any official purpose of, or for the use of, the office of Minister of the Crown" (Schedule 4 Clause 11). On my reading no reference to the need for the information to relate to an agency's affairs.
Any rumbles of discontent about the scope of your freedom of information act are best directed to the government concerned.
Tuesday, June 01, 2010
Oh dear...
There are plenty of potential targets on the transparency and accountability front at the moment but Alan Moir in the Sydney Morning Herald gives the puppet theme, the NSW Premier and excessive secrecy another run today. Come 1 July cartoonists will struggle with "GIPA" which just won't have the same ring...
Drug secrecy law trumps FOI
An Administrative Appeals Tribunal decision involving an application for documents concerning the listing of the drug Strattera on the Commonwealth Government Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme, while unremarkable in terms of the law and its interpretation and application, raises several important issues. For example the interplay between secrecy provisions in other acts and the Freedom of Information Act; how the ground can shift to exemption arguments in the AAT that haven't been raised in earlier processing of the application; and how information relevant to public health is protected from disclosure by laws that don't require showing harm from disclosure - "the law says" is enough although the Australian Law Reform Commission has recommended changes. Finally while the usual situation is for the applicant for documents who takes a matter to the AAT to end up with what he/she had before proceedings started, at least, and hopefully a little or a lot more, in this case the applicant ended up worse off-even documents the Department had agreed to release were found to be exempt.
Monday, May 31, 2010
Trust me with your details, I'm a politician
![]() |
| www.musiczoo.com |
I agree with many of the comments that much of this is or should be in the public domain, available to anyone interested in knowing about local happenings.
But politicians "trawling" the record raises a broader issue - and no one is holding breath expecting action on this before the Federal election later this year, or ever - concerning the large hole in privacy laws for political parties and those engaged in politics. The gap permits collection of personal information not just from the public domain but from wherever they can find it, subject to little scrutiny, with no citizen rights to know or correct what is held, or limitations on subsequent use and disclosure.
Legal privilege should not stand in Ombudsman's way
![]() |
| NSW Ombudsman Bruce Barbour |
The Ombudsman has a point about what is a unique NSW limitation on ombudsman powers (section 21 of the Ombudsman Act) and the lack of consistency in NSW where such a limitation does not apply to other investigatory bodies such as the Police Integrity Commission and the Independent Commission Against Corruption. However NSW is not the only jurisdiction with a consistency problem.This was a key element in an Australian Law Reform Commission 2008 Report on privilege and investigations. The report, which lends support to the NSW Ombudsman's argument, is yet to be acted upon by the Federal Government.
Wednesday, May 26, 2010
Note to PM: "FOI=administrative chaos"
16 May. Note for Prime Minister from Secretary of PM&C:
Freedom of Information legislation would result in administrative chaos.. departments keeping dual filing cabinets."
20 May. Handwritten note to Prime Minister from Secretary PM&C marked "not for file": "Were I not under threat of my advice being made public I would be questioning with you this whole legislation. It is a can of worms, political commitments notwithstanding."
The heads of Defence and Treasury are opposed to the legislation. Broader and in some cases blanket exemptions are necessary.
More delay, reconsideration and advice is needed.
"What we've got here would go further than any other country with a similar system of government and is an "experimental step of major dimensions.. Whatever the politics of the decision it is certainly a gamble in the administrative sense."
Something this week off the back of a truck? No, just some extracts from "Malcolm Fraser The Political Memoirs" by Malcolm Fraser and Margaret Simons (The Megunyah Press $60) pages 404-405 about events in 1977-the last paragraph 1980, after three more years delay- in the lead up to enactment and commencement of the Commonwealth Freedom of Information Act in 1982, ten years after the initial commitment. The notes to the Prime Minister were from then Secretary Geoff Yeend and the material is sourced to documents available in the National Archives- even the handwritten "not for file" note made it onto the files and survives.
What public service players in these positions had to say to the PM or ministers about the 2008-2010 reform process might make an interesting FOI application- or become clear in 20 years (following a shift from 30 to 20 years in the FOI Reform legislation) when records come into open access.
Reports today are that Fraser resigned from the Liberal Party in December, concerned at its direction. He told Jack Waterford three years ago that FOI was his most important legacy.
Monday, May 24, 2010
Open government job no state secret
I have had a couple of exchanges with people who heard that the Federal Freedom of Information and Privacy commissioner jobs-part of the new system yet to commence with the Information Commissioner at the top- had been advertised recently but couldn't locate the ads. After a bit of searching and some help, it seems they were advertised in the Australian Financial Review on 14 May, but that appears to be it as far as media advertising goes.(Correction: also in the Weekend Australian 15 May page 5).The positions are also listed at Executive Intelligence Group #167(Privacy) and #168 (FOI). I haven't come across the Office of Information Commissioner website if it's up and running. No mention of the jobs on PM&C (Correction: see here) and Privacy Commissioner websites. (Update:also at Seek Online.) Don't know where this leaves incumbent Privacy Commissioner Karen Curtis. Leadership baton, and the rest in your kitbag? Applications close 8 June. The AFR ad was as follows:
Campbell and a cause of action for breach of privacy
I imagine racing off to court is the last thing on David Campbell's mind at the moment.The current uncertain state of the law wouldn't suggest any clear claim of action for breach of privacy. There's nothing defamatory about any allegations I've seen, and truth is a defence in any event. The proposals on the table, but so far not acted upon by government, for a statutory cause of action for breach of privacy ( broadly framed and not just aimed at the media) would if acted upon, raise additional questions in any subsequent legal proceedings than the one currently getting media attention: whether there is public interest that justifies publication of information about a person's personal or private affairs.
Premier Keneally gives the word on opening up
A good and strong message from NSW Premier Keneally to ministers, ministerial,staff and public servants about what's expected come 1 July with the commencement of the Government Information (Public Access) Act in this memorandum dated 14 May, and given wider circulation in Matthew Moore's article in today's Sydney Morning Herald.The Premier says::
Central to the new Act is the presumption that all Government–held information should be accessible to the public and that information should only be withheld if it is necessary to do so in the public interest...
The cultural shift that is necessary to realise the full promise of the new legislation will require leadership. Ministers and heads of agencies need to set the tone and cultural expectations which support the release of Government information. It is important that agency staff be given the confidence and support they need to make decisions that further the objects and intentions of the new Act...
There will, of course, continue to be certain types of information that it will be inappropriate to release. Information revealing Cabinet deliberations, sensitive personal or commercial-in-confidence information, and information that could jeopardise public safety, law enforcement or the fair trial of a person are examples. In all cases, however, public interest is the relevant touchstone. Political considerations must not come into play.
Leading by example will be crucial, and Ministers are asked to emphasise the need for all agencies (including Ministers’ own offices) to comply both with the letter and spirit of the new Act..
Ministers should also be aware that the new Act expressly provides that, in dealing with a particular access application, agencies are not subject to the direction and control of Ministers.
"Right to know" about Campbell has Channel 7 making news
Plenty of opinion and even some social analysis out there arising from the decision by Seven Network News to out now former NSW Transport Minister David Campbell and plenty more to follow, I'm sure. Politicians differ on the question, so too do senior journalists who have opined so far. Public sentiment is strongly against. Debate about the framework within which the media deals with matters that have a private dimension, and the way it works in practice is necessary and welcome. An issue for 7 is whether what happened here constitutes a breach of standards that underpin the licensing system. Another for any MEAA journalist member involved is how it sits with their code of ethics.
NSW Premier Keneally left the question of propriety in publishing hanging:
NSW Premier Keneally left the question of propriety in publishing hanging:
“I do think it’s a matter for debate whether or not a person’s sexuality is of relevance to their role as a minister or their role as a member of Parliament.”Deputy Federal Opposition Leader Julie Bishop on The Insiders surprisingly was prepared to accept virtually any media intrusion:
BARRIE CASSIDY: How do you feel about the way the media handled it?
JULIE BISHOP: Well that's a matter for the media to judge. I think that politicians know that they are fair game. We know that going into politics means that you don't have any private life and so the media is doing its job. But it's a sorry incident in Australian politics.
It will be a sorry day for politicians and others if we have reached the point where "they don't have any private life" although this might have been one of those Tony Abbott "not considered, not on paper" comments.( Graham Richardson shares her view according to this report : 'There is no privacy. Politicians don't have a right to any sort of private life any more,'' he told Channel Nine. ''And I don't think they've had that right for 20 years; it's been eroded steadily over time but now anything goes.'')
77% of more than 50000 votes on a poll on the Herald website are critical of 7's decision. So is David Marr whose opinion piece appears on the same link, who categorically dismissed any "right to know" argument. Marr at the Sydney Writers' Festival responded to an assertion that any media organisation worth its salt would have published, by saying Herald journalists had known about Campbell for some time but had decided not to publish. Mark Day in The Australian says "by today's standards, an individual's sxxual preference is considered to be of no consequence." Day says news like this should have provoked a "so what" response and that Campbell could have chosen quite properly to hold his ground and dismiss a report about a private matter. However Day attaches weight to Campbell's statement in resigning and his admission of wrongdoing in some respects. On the question of whether politicians should be treated differently to the rest of us, Day says:
"Broadly, I'd say .. the answer is yes. When politicians stand for election they say, in effect, "Here I am; this is what I stand for; these are my values - vote for me." Therefore, if the truth is revealed to be something other than the intended projection, and if that truth is known to the highest echelons of those who govern us, but is kept secret from us, then the public is entitled to know it, too.
Dr Simon Longstaff of the St James Ethics Centre, taking the opposite view, said a key point was that Mr Campbell did not make his political career campaigning on moral issues.
"It doesn't seem to be true that it holds for David Campbell, who ... has done nothing more than be truthful about the fact that he has a family," he said. "I mean, you might think that using one's family to promote a political career has all sorts of problems. "But as far as I know, David Campbell is married, he does have a family and he has indicated that in his Christmas card because that is part of who he is. "I mean he is obviously a complex person. But to say that he has engaged in some kind of gross act of political hypocrisy is to make too great a statement in relation to this particular case."On the rules that apply, the Seven Network is a member of the industry body Free TV Australia. The 2010 Code of Practice forms part of a regulatory framework that operates under the Broadcasting Services Act and comes within the purview of the Australian Communications and Media Authority. The Code states:
In broadcasting news and current affairs programs, licensees:
4.3.5 must not use material relating to a person’s personal or private affairs, or which invades an individual’s privacy, other than where there is an identifiable public interest reason for the material to be broadcast.
As reported by Matthew Moore in the Sydney Morning Herald Channel Seven dropped the principal claim of the public interest justification, that Mr Campbell used a ''taxpayer-funded car'' to visit the club, conceding that driving a car provided as part of a salary package to and from the club was not an issue of impropriety. News Director Peter Meakin said there were two other justifications for running the story - Mr Campbell was leading a double life unknown to his family, and had campaigned for election as a family man. These and the fact that Mr Campbell had served as police minister for 18 months up until September 2008 tipped the balance in favour of publication.
''If it's someone's private life and it does not impact on his job or potentially impact on his job, it's a private life, but if it impacts on his portfolio or potentially on the execution of his duties, I think it's a matter of public interest.''
Apart from the industry code if those involved in running the story at Seven are members of the MEAA, its code of ethics requires a journalist to "respect..personal privacy," a provision suitably vague and deserving closer examination of what it means in practice.
John Hartigan of News Limited observed in March last year that " the current media privacy framework is effective and working well." I think incidents since raise serious questions about this,. The Australian Law Reform Commission has recommended significant changes to the current system that gives media organisations an exemption from privacy legislation in favour of self regulatory schemes. The Commission has drawn attention to gaps, inconsistencies and weak enforcement provisions in these arrangements.
I'll have something to say about the separate issue of the Campbell outing and the proposed cause of action for breach of privacy in another post.
FOI awareness and alphabet soup
Twenty eight years on since our first law arrived, and even among the 400 interested enough to show up on a wet Saturday in Sydney to a discussion on Press Freedom and the Public Right to Know, its still a puzzle.
Before the session started at the Sydney Writers' Festival on Saturday I was amused to hear two people sitting behind me puzzling over the meaning of the program description of Michael McKinnon as "FOI Editor, Seven Network." One suggested it was probably a misprint of Folio Editor, whatever that meant. Mike Carlton in introducing the panel cleared that mystery up. More lie ahead with new acronyms RTI, GIPA and who knows what might still come in jurisdictions beyond NSW and Queensland.
Before the session started at the Sydney Writers' Festival on Saturday I was amused to hear two people sitting behind me puzzling over the meaning of the program description of Michael McKinnon as "FOI Editor, Seven Network." One suggested it was probably a misprint of Folio Editor, whatever that meant. Mike Carlton in introducing the panel cleared that mystery up. More lie ahead with new acronyms RTI, GIPA and who knows what might still come in jurisdictions beyond NSW and Queensland.
Lively interest in right to know
At the session on Saturday on Press Freedom and the Public's Right to Know (packed, with over 400 people), excessive secrecy and government attitudes and barriers to disclosure came in for the inevitable serve. Mike Carlton suggested things are getting worse not better, citing suppression orders in the courts as a particular trend in the wrong direction. The point was hammered home by David Marr who cited a "barmy" court order (I haven't seen this mentioned anywhere else) that prevented publication of The Weekend Australian Magazine in Victoria on Saturday because it contained an article about the murder of a child in Western Australia that a judge decided may have influenced jurors in a completely unrelated trial in that state of a man charged over the death of his three children; orders that prevent the publication of the names of many involved in court proceedings including names of rxxpists serving life sentences for acts committed when they were underage; the difficulties of accessing court documents in NSW while proceedings are underway and a reform process that is "going nowhere"; and the $8 per page cost of transcripts that poses a "horrendous" obstacle to digging into what has happened in open court if you didn't happen to be there.
Anne Davies, recently returned from Washington, spoke of the "startling contrast" between her experiences there-even under the Bush administration, and things have improved since - in terms of access to government information and what she encounters here, using examples about the premier's appointments diary ( technical hoops here, versus 300,000 entries online at the White House website), and the release of political donation details (180 days after the end of the financial year here, versus something closer to real time there.)
Michael McKinnon claimed government secrecy is about protecting policy failures (it's a bit more nuanced than that); gave some examples that readers here will be familiar with of the need for constant vigilance as quiet steps backward often accompany big announcements of moves in a positive direction; and was particularly critical of delay tactics in the Freedom of Information arena that have the effect of turning important information concerning accountability into unusable stuff because of the lapse of time. It won't be news for public servants who deal with McKinnon's FOI applications to hear his stated modus operandi: proceed with obsessive bloodymindedness and demonstrate you will never give up.
This led to some questions about the media giving up on some topics, first from a small number of 9/11 conspiracy theorists, encouraged by the session title, who tried to put the panel on the spot about the media's complicity in an alleged cover up- no one was having that - and another about the truth behind the AWB Iraq scandal. Marr was critical of the Rudd Government's timidity in office on the issue given what was said when in opposition , and indicated the matter still has a way to run-watch this space.
"Privacy laws", said to be misused to protect important information that should be released, received a general caning- more about the media, privacy and the Campbell episode in another post.
Anne Davies, recently returned from Washington, spoke of the "startling contrast" between her experiences there-even under the Bush administration, and things have improved since - in terms of access to government information and what she encounters here, using examples about the premier's appointments diary ( technical hoops here, versus 300,000 entries online at the White House website), and the release of political donation details (180 days after the end of the financial year here, versus something closer to real time there.)
Michael McKinnon claimed government secrecy is about protecting policy failures (it's a bit more nuanced than that); gave some examples that readers here will be familiar with of the need for constant vigilance as quiet steps backward often accompany big announcements of moves in a positive direction; and was particularly critical of delay tactics in the Freedom of Information arena that have the effect of turning important information concerning accountability into unusable stuff because of the lapse of time. It won't be news for public servants who deal with McKinnon's FOI applications to hear his stated modus operandi: proceed with obsessive bloodymindedness and demonstrate you will never give up.
This led to some questions about the media giving up on some topics, first from a small number of 9/11 conspiracy theorists, encouraged by the session title, who tried to put the panel on the spot about the media's complicity in an alleged cover up- no one was having that - and another about the truth behind the AWB Iraq scandal. Marr was critical of the Rudd Government's timidity in office on the issue given what was said when in opposition , and indicated the matter still has a way to run-watch this space.
"Privacy laws", said to be misused to protect important information that should be released, received a general caning- more about the media, privacy and the Campbell episode in another post.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)








