Search This Blog

Monday, May 17, 2010

Intelligence agencies remain out of FOI focus

The Greens Senator Ludlam in speaking in the Senate last Thursday to his unsuccessful motion for removal of the blanket  exemption of intelligence agencies from the Federal Freedom of Information Act, asked the Minister several times but failed to get a response:
What is it about Australian security agencies that should render them entirely immune to freedom of information that does not apply, for example, to the CIA, to United States intelligence agencies and to intelligence agencies like MI5 or MI6 in Britain which are subject to freedom of information laws?"
He could have added New Zealand there as well. Good questions that deserve a considered answer. As Senator Ludlam said there are plenty of exemptions that would always cover those aspects of intelligence agency operations that legitimately deserve protection, but the blanket exemptions remove scrutiny even of how many paper clips they buy-should you be interested. 

All Senator Ludlam managed was an acknowledgment from the Minister Senator Ludwig that exclusions from the act should be looked at in the proposed comprehensive review of the act two years after these changes commence.

Thanks to Open Australia for the link.

The 2010-2011 Budget for PM&C included money for an independent review of Australia's intelligence agencies. Will the terms of reference extend to issues of transparency and accountability? Tim Lester's report in the Sydney Morning Herald doesn't raise hopes.

NSW Information Commissioner set to lead the revolution

Ben Rushton SMH
Best wishes for an exciting journey. NSW Information Commissioner Deirdre O' Donnell, a week into the job, told Matthew Moore of the Sydney Morning Herald  she is ready for the challenge of leading from the front on implementation of the GIPA act, to commence on 1 July.
'The role of champion is really what most excites me. This is a revolution and it needs a champion, someone visibly proactive, engaged and engaging who will be out there to show this thing really matters and things will change....O'Donnell ...... concedes that, as part of the revolution she is planning, it is inevitable some people may get hurt as they are forced to change well-established patterns of behaviour. Her fundamental challenge, she says, is to change the culture of the public service, to make it far more open. To help do that she is drawn to the idea of varying the performance agreements of the heads of department to include compliance with the new laws as one of the measures by which they are judged. ''It focuses the mind wonderfully, you really internalise it, you really give it your attention,'' she says of the proposal."
Shades of former Premier Nathan Rees who pushed the legislation through and now watches from the backbench, who told Parliament  almost a year ago the new legislation would
"turn the freedom of information regime on its head. The bills establish a framework to actively promote the release of Government information and they offer the opportunity for a fresh start...These bills constitute a fundamental freedom of information revolution... New South Wales will gain the nation's best freedom of information laws. The public's right to know must come first. As well as comprehensively responding to the Ombudsman's report, they pick up reforms arising from the Solomon review in Queensland and recently proposed changes to Commonwealth legislation. The bills mark a paradigm shift. Our public sector must embrace openness and transparency and governments must forever relinquish their habitual instinct to control information. This is generational change and reform that is long overdue."
 All aboard...

How Federal FOI Reform bills became noncontroversial

The easy passage for the Federal Freedom of Information Amendment (Reform) Bill and the Australian Information Commissioner Bill through the Senate last Thursday - all done in 30 minutes flat, without a division -came from agreement behind the scenes that the legislation would go through as noncontroversial.

This resulted when the Government backed down on the onus of proof  issue in AAT review processes that had become the main issue of contention. The Opposition despite some earlier huffing and puffing and talk of amendments then didn't pursue other concerns raised in the dissenting report of the Senate Finance and Public Administration Committee by Coalition Senators Brandis and Ryan. With Opposition support, and The Greens also happy with this result, the bills as introduced ( with a new section 61 and some minor other Government amendments to the FOI bill  and IC bill agreed in the House on Wednesday) passed the Senate on the voices.

There was no support from the major parties for the only other amendment moved in the Senate -  by The Greens Senator Ludlam - to repeal the blanket exclusions from the FOI act for documents concerning intelligence agencies. Senator Ludlam the only senator to do so, at least gave voice to continuing interest in a couple of other aspects of the law that should be looked at closely - fees and charges, and the application of freedom of information to parliamentary departments- but can count, and didn't take these issues further.

Given the fuss in the lead up, a feature of debate was that Government speakers managed a "don't mention the war" moment avoiding any mention of capitulation on the onus issue. The original proposal  would have required an FOI applicant to carry the onus in the AAT in seeking review of an Information Commissioner decision that a document was exempt. The Government's first compromise in March would have removed the concept of onus in line with a recommendation from the Senate Committee. The final version -urged by Australia's Right to Know, the Law Council, the Opposition and others - in effect retains the status quo.

Neither Parliamentary Secretary Byrne in introducing the new section and other minor amendments, or other speakers for that matter, referred to it during House debate on Tuesday or Wednesday.

Senator Sherry in introducing the legislation in the Senate on Thursday tabled three revised explanatory memoranda and incorporated the second reading speeches in Hansard. The speeches contain no reference to the change to Section 61. (Update and Correction: see this later post for the explanation about how the speech did refer to this but Hansard initially got it wrong.) The Minister responsible for the legislation Senator Ludwig spoke three times for a total of six minutes during the Second reading debate and the committee stage and managed to avoid any mention of section 61 or the change.

The only indication of what had happened (other than in the fine print in the tabled documents) came in remarks by Senator Brandis who relished recounting the history and took the long handle to the Government when observing that the original proposal- an
"extremely significant and deleterious change to section 61 of the act—was in fact included in a schedule presented to the Senate committee as a miscellaneous technical amendment. Just think about that. Dwell and reflect for a moment on the supreme irony that, in a bill which falsely claimed to be expanding and reforming the freedom of information regime, an amendment which would have set back the regime to make it practically unworkable was itself concealed from the Senate committee by being treated as a technical minor amendment. That is hardly freedom of information; a conspiracy to conceal highly material information from the Senate committee would be a better description."
So that was it. There had been plenty of suggestions over the last 14 months about how these bills, welcome as they are, could have been further improved but the onus issue dominated all else during parliament's consideration of the bills.  I thought the original proposal was a backward step but other issues also warranted consideration. Unfortunately it ended up dominating to the extent other aspects of the bills didn't get noticed at all.

The focus now shifts to when the new era is to commence, and how it all will work in practice.

Thanks to Open Australia for the Hansard links.

Friday, May 14, 2010

FOI onus in AAT-status quo preserved

On what became something of a controversial issue following tabling of the Freedom of Information Reform bills in Parliament last November the Government quietly backed off before final debate on the legislation on the proposal to change the onus of proof so that a party seeking review in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal would carry the burden of making its case. It also gave way on its second bite that would have removed the concept of onus but placed an evidentiary burden on the government agency. Tthe staus quo that the government agency carries the burden remains. Here is the relevant extract from the revised Explanatory Memorandum:

Civil liberties rate in UK Coalition accord

Thanks to Bob Burton for a reference to the UK Coalition Government agreement  which includes:

10. Civil liberties

The parties agree to implement a full programme of measures to reverse the substantial erosion of civil liberties under the Labour Government and roll back state intrusion.

This will include:

- A Freedom or Great Repeal Bill.

- The scrapping of ID card scheme, the National Identity register, the next generation of biometric passports and the Contact Point Database.

- Outlawing the finger-printing of children at school without parental permission.

- The extension of the scope of the Freedom of Information Act to provide greater transparency.

- Adopting the protections of the Scottish model for the DNA database.

- The protection of historic freedoms through the defence of trial by jury.

- The restoration of rights to non-violent protest.

- The review of libel laws to protect freedom of speech.

- Safeguards against the misuse of anti-terrorism legislation.

- Further regulation of CCTV.

- Ending of storage of internet and email records without good reason.

- A new mechanism to prevent the proliferation of unnecessary new criminal offences.

Mark Bollard comments about the FOI and privacy related issues, and Media Spy  has this to say about likely defamation law reform:
Both parties agree that Britain’s libel laws are in need of an overhaul, with concerns that corporations and wealthy individuals have disproportionate power to use the courts to sue publishers and media outlets on the grounds of defamation, placing an undue burden of proof on the defendants. The laws led to what has been termed “libel tourism”, where foreign individuals and companies took advantage of Britain’s pro-claimant laws to sue the media. The coalition agreement pledges to initiate a “review of libel laws to protect freedom of speech”. The Conservatives’ election manifesto declared that the party would “review and reform libel laws to protect freedom of speech, reduce costs and discourage libel tourism”, while the Liberal Democrats went further by proposing the implementation of the so-called “Reynolds defence“, giving journalists the ability to use the public interest to justify investigations even if they are unable to prove conclusively that their findings are true.
 

Federal Information Commissioner cashed up

The Federal Government's Budget Papers for 2010-2011 (PM&C Portfolio Budget  Statement- Program1. 4) include an entry for the Office of Information Commissioner allocating $1.5 million in the revised budget for 2009-2010 (last year's papers included $2.961 million, obviously a little ambitious about the start date), $5.4 million for each of  the next two years  and $5.5 million in 2013-2014. Around $7 million is separately allocated to the Office of the Privacy Commissioner which will become part of the OIC, a separate statutory agency operating within the Prime Minister's portfolio, when the Office is established.

Thursday, May 13, 2010

Federal FOI reform: Australia's Right to Know loves it.

You know my "good, welcome, but.." reaction to the FOI reform bills and the "opportunity missed" list I've run up at various points since the Exposure Draft appeared in March last year. Then there's the "proof of the pudding" and all that.

Australia’s Right to Know thinks its excellent - not a gap or weakness in sight today.

Federal FOI reforms through Parliament in a flash in the end

I haven't checked what amendments were made in the end but Parliament has passed the FOI Reform legislation. The following message just in from PM&C. It's good and welcome change. Commencement is still some months down the track: 
The Government’s FOI reform legislation, the Australian Information Commissioner Bill 2010 and the Freedom of Information Amendment (Reform) Bill 2010, passed through the Parliament today.
 
The Government moved amendments to both Bills in the House of Representatives yesterday, which were agreed.  Details of those amendments and the final Bills as passed by both Houses are available from the Parliament of Australia ParlInfo website: see Australian Information Commissioner Bill 2010  and Freedom of Information Amendment (Reform) Bill 2010
 
Following Royal Assent of the Bills, the majority of the measures (including the establishment of the new Office of the Australian Information Commissioner) will commence on a day to be fixed by proclamation, or six months after Royal Assent.  The Government will make an announcement on this matter.
 
As you may be aware, the Government announced on 26 February this year the engagement of Professor John McMillan AO as the Information Commissioner Designate.  Preparations for the establishment of the Office of the Australian Information Commissioner are continuing. This includes work on new FOI guidelines so that they are ready in sufficient time for commencement of the changes to the FOI request regime.  The new Information Publication Scheme will commence six months later than the other reform measures.

The Media Release from Cabinet Secretary and Special Minister of State, Senator Joe Ludwig says:

“These bills constitute the biggest overhaul of the FOI Act since its inception and are directed to providing a stronger foundation for openness in government.” “I am proud to facilitate the passage of this legislation, which is a key component of the Government’s drive to restore trust and integrity in government” Senator Ludwig said.
 
The centrepiece of these reforms is the establishment of the Office of the Australian Information Commissioner and two new independent office holders, the Australian Information Commissioner and the FOI Commissioner. The Commissioners will have wide ranging FOI functions to promote openness and transparency as intended by the Government’s reforms.

 
Other changes include a new framework for agency-driven proactive publication of government information; a single public interest test for many exemptions, which favours disclosure; abolition of application fees and reduced charges; and reducing the open access period under the Archives Act from 30 years to 20 years for most records.
“The Rudd Government recognises we are responsible and accountable to the people we serve. That’s why in opposition we committed to overhauling FOI and today we have delivered on that promise in full” Senator Ludwig said.

E-health-more money, some confusion

The Budget announcement of a $466.7 million investment over the next two years in the national e-Health records system saw a lot of emphasis on benefits to come, secure access, and rigorous governance and oversight to maintain privacy, .PDF printable version of Personally Controlled Electronic Health Records for All Australians (PDF 24 KB)
Dr David More at the Australian Health Information Technonogy blog raises  questions about how the money is to be spent, and by whom.  Answers to follow?

Wednesday, May 12, 2010

The state of things in Queensland

In debate on the Federal Freedom of Information Reform bills in Canberra yesterday Opposition backbencher Peter Lindsay (from Queensland) likened the proposals to changes adopted in Queensland last year. He's right, in a fashion. But he went on to criticise developments there drawing on a media release by the state opposition leader last November headed ‘Accountability a joke under Bligh 'and stating 'Premier Bligh is living in a fool’s paradise if she thinks her government is setting the national agenda for accountability.' Mr Lindsay wasn't exactly using an objective source here. And his remarks don't square with the experience of one of Australia's most experienced journalists in the field.

It wasn't all the Budget in Canberra yesterday.

Those Federal Freedom of Information reform bills did get a run in the House of Representatives yesterday when the Second Reading debate resumed following introduction of the bills last November. The Government has the numbers in the House so the bills can sail through there at any time of its choosing, but the Senate is a different matter: Opposition support or the votes of all third party and independent senators will be needed to assure passage there. Shadow Minister for Justice Michael Keenan outlined the current situation:
I understand that discussions are underway between the opposition and the government regarding the onus of proof provision. Whilst the coalition supports these bills in principle, further amendments will be made in the Senate. I trust that the government and the opposition, with a bit of goodwill on both sides, will be able to find common ground on these two bills. As mentioned in the Bills Digest regarding the FOI Amendment (Reform) Bill 2009, there is an argument that in a number of areas the reforms do not go far enough. A common theme in submissions to the Senate inquiry was that, while the bill repeals a small number of exemptions, it retains an almost entirely untouched list of excluded agencies and documents held by certain agencies listed in schedule 2 of the FOI Act.
The debate (four speakers, then adjourned) generally was set piece stuff, with plenty of barbs back and forward about action (or inaction) on open government promises by the Howard and Rudd governments when they have had the chance. Mark Dreyfus, widely experienced in FOI in his previous life at the Bar, highlighted the positives, but in having a crack at the Opposition for ignoring the Australian Law Reform Commission's Open Government Report of 1995 failed to mention those ALRC recommendations that the Government has simply ignored without explanation, including that the parliamentary departments should be made subject to the FOI Act (31).These recommendations and weaknesses and gaps in the bills that quite a few of us see escaped other speakers as well. Next time maybe.

Thanks to Open Australia for the links.

Tuesday, May 11, 2010

NSW new era from 1 July; but as to Canberra...?

Deidre O'Donnell the inaugural NSW Information Commissioner took up her position yesterday and Government has announced the Government Information (Public Access) Act will commence on 1 July 2010, replacing the Freedom of Information Act from that date. Everyone will be pleased at that- Parliament passed the legislation last June. 

The Office of Information Commissioner has published some additional guidance material but leadership including selling the need for change to those at the top of the tree, and encouraging agency wide re-examination of information handling, publication and access policy and practices in line with the spirit, intent and provisions of the act have to be priorities. As does public awareness, which seems scant at present.

It's not just a job for the commissioner either. As The Greens Lee Rhiannon said in welcoming the new laws, "their strength will be largely determined by how well they are championed from on high."
"One of the strengths of this new legislation is its potential to change the culture of secrecy in state and local government agencies by requiring the proactive release of information. Premier Keneally must play a key role in driving this reform, or the public will suffer the same frustration as it did under NSW's shoddy old laws. A strong public awareness campaign is critical to educate people about how to use the new system... While former Premier Nathan Rees drove these changes to NSW's freedom of information regime, Kristina Keneally has been silent on the issue since taking office. Premier Keneally could garner a lot of good will in the eyes of the public by putting her energies into championing openness and accountability.
Meanwhile in Canberra, Federal Parliament resumes today for the Budget session with a long list of bills on the table and two uncertainties about the Freedom of Information Reform legislation - whether it gets a slot in what is now a crowded pre-election agenda, and the extent of support in the Senate for what the Government is prepared to accept in a final version of the bill.

Monday, May 10, 2010

FOI front and center at Press Freedom Day

The World Press Freedom Day Conference in Brisbane last week on the theme of Freedom of Information, the Right to Know, included a Masterclass involving (as Part 1) Queensland Information Commissioner Julie Kinross, Rick Snell of the University of Tasmania, Toby Mendell from Canada and Michael McKinnon of Seven Network. Snell spoke about the importance of a system wide approach to information access issues, rather than a focus on an act which may or may not deliver much. Mendell outlined the considerable progress around the world on FOI since 1990 with laws now in place in more than 70 countries.The Conference Brisbane Declaration may be a further prompt to action by the laggards on what is now an accepted part of the international law on rights.

Kinross reaffirmed the Queensland Government's ambition to be the most open and accountable government in Australia- others prepared to take the challenge please step forward- with the Right to Information Act just one of a range of means designed to deliver on the promise. She made some interesting comments about measures designed to promote open government including a relevant provision, now included in the performance agreement of the chief executive of each government agency to advance the objects of the act, and oversight of performance in this respect by a committee including the head of the Premier's department and Treasury; the policy context established by the Government's Information Management Policy that forms part of a government wide Strategic Framework that probably has a 10 year time frame; standards for agency performance, and current collection of baseline data for future comparative purposes; report cards required by the Right to Information Act to be submitted to a parliamentary committee; and the offence provisions in the act and how they promote independence in decision making.
McKinnon while supportive of the "push" model said he thought he would be waiting a long time for government to proactively publish potentially embarrassing information, so the "pull" method would continue to be part of journalists' modus operandi. McKinnon said the media coalition Australia's Right to Know was about to seek to engage the to date uninterested South Australian Government on the topic of broad Freedom of Information reform.  That's a good thing- Victoria and Western Australia could do with pressure to act as well.


Thursday, May 06, 2010

MEAA report on press freedom

The Media Entertainment and Arts Alliance report on the state of press freedom in Australia released on 30 April is a comprehensive and useful survey of the field, and developments over the last 12 months including secrecy in government, Freedom of Information, whistleblower protection, shield laws, defamation and SLAPP, copyright, spin, anti terror restrictions-the lot. There is even a sane contribution  (rare in most media circles) on privacy by Media Watch's Jonathon Holmes suggesting (as ABC's Mark Scott did in March last year) that media organisations should be trying to negotiate a sensible statutory cause of action for gross unwarranted breaches rather than leave this to common law development by the courts. Other contributions include Michael McKinnon on FOI developments and me on how transparency issues featured differently in the recent Tasmanian and South Australian elections.


Chris Warren's overall assessment in the introduction properly stops short of a positive rating for the Rudd government on results to date, but is optimistic about changes still to come. There is plenty of room for debate about his comment about privacy and the profession: that "Australia's journalists-compared to some comparable markets- have a pretty good record of respecting this right to privacy and on occasions when we do step over the mark we are quick to recognise this as well." The rider about "comparable markets" gives this otherwise unqualified defence of standards a suitably vague and uncertain character.

Wednesday, May 05, 2010

Sunshine the best detergent

From the Sydney Morning Herald tonight under the headline MP admits deliberately misleading parliament over signing blank forms:
Penrith Labor MP Karyn Paluzzano (who resigned earlier in the week as a parliamentary secretary) admitted at a corruption inquiry today she misled parliament by signing either blank or partly completed staff payment forms....Asked at this afternoon's hearing whether she had knowingly signed false and misleading forms, Ms Paluzzano answered: "That is correct."....Asked if she had signed either partly filled-in, or blank, forms Ms Palazzano gave the same response, and when asked whether she had deliberately misled parliament, she answered: "I accept that."...During today's hearing, it was also alleged that she rorted her electoral mail account by sending out mail that had not been approved by the clerk of the Legislative Assembly as is required.
The ICAC hearing continues.


From a post  here on 19 June 2009:

When asked in the Legislative Council yesterday about why the NSW Parliament would not be subject to the Government Information (Public Access) Bill the Attorney General John Hazistergos said it was a silly question and that the President of the Legislative Council and the Speaker of the Legislative Assembly had explained the reasons for the decision. He said citing examples of where this had occurred elsewhere, like the UK, was inappropriate "cherry picking" because " how we do business in this Parliament, the checks and balances that exist in New South Wales are not replicated in every other jurisdiction" and "freedom of information legislation in this State and throughout Australia is about keeping the Executive accountable. There are other means for keeping the Parliament accountable."
Just what those means are is not apparent. And-if applying the law to the legislature poses a problem- why the Government has not asked Parliament itself to consider embracing higher standards of accountability and transparency has not been explained. The Attorney General has been a vociferous opponent of a Human Rights Bill or Charter for Australia on the basis that parliament, not unelected judges should strike the right balance in protecting rights. Yet when it comes to a system to ensure the right to know about the day to day operations of Parliament in spending the $123 million allocated in this week's state budget, it is not even a topic worth discussing.

So no more pesky questions please about the $100 million in the Budget for "Members' Support" or how much each member is paid in entitlements or how travel, electoral or other allowances are spent. Just look forward with anticipation to next year's annual report for a few high level details.
Trust us, we're the NSW Parliament.
Perhaps time for more questions and reconsideration, Attorney General, or can we be confident Ms Palazzano is a one off, and no repeats are likely?


Tasmania is the only Australian jurisdiction to properly address this issue extending the Right to Information Act to commence on 1 July to the parliament in respect of matters of an administrative nature. 

Google releases government requests data

Google's Government Requests Tool  launched on 20 April provides information about requests for user data or content removal received from government agencies or arising from court orders around the world. In the last six months o f last year Australian government agencies made 155 requests for information including 17 for remove all or some information:14 from You Tube, and 1 each from Blogger and Geo and a web search. Google complied fully or partially with 52%. No other details. Has anyone asked Canberra about the requests for user data? Australian numbers for removal are small in comparison to Brazil, Germany, India (many arising from defamation suits) and the US.

Google states the release is a first step in providing more transparency about efforts at web censorship, noting many requests are entirely legitimate for example for removal of child pxxxography.
We also regularly receive requests from law enforcement agencies to hand over private user data. Again, the vast majority of these requests are valid and the information needed is for legitimate criminal investigations. However, data about these activities historically has not been broadly available. We believe that greater transparency will lead to less censorship
On political speech Google adds:
In our experience over the years a very small percentage of content removal requests from governments have centered on political speech, but often those requests are the ones that spark the most vigorous debate within Google. We have complied with some of those requests if, for instance, the material violated our own content policies. But for others, we didn’t. For example, in Argentina, a federal prosecutor claimed that information about him and his wife (a federal judge) had been posted for analysis on two political blogs and asked that we remove them. We removed a portion of one of the blogs for revealing private information about the judge, but otherwise did not comply. We also received a demand in late 2009 from a Canadian politician for the removal of a blog criticizing his policies. Again, we declined to remove the blog, because it did not violate our policies.
There’s a question mark on the world map for content removal requests from China- Chinese officials consider censorship demands as state secrets, so Google (who terminated its joint venture there because of government intrusion) politely says it cannot disclose that information at this time.

On a China related topic, my morning read at the moment in Hong Kong, the South China Morning Post today reports China shut down all anonymous comments on major news and business websites last year, and plans a real name identification system to prevent anonymous communication on websites, discussion groups and mobile telephones. Wang Chen, chief of the State Council Information Office reportedly told the Standing Committee of the National People's Congress one of the aims was to "keep harmful overseas information" from appearing on domestic websites. Wang is also reported to have said China now has more than 400 million internet users, so the finger in the dyke faces challenging times.



Tuesday, May 04, 2010

Gov 2.0 inching forward

The Federal Government in an announcement yesterday accepted most recommendations made in the Gov 2.0 Task Force Report of last December, including to make a Declaration of Open Government, and to other initiatives generally to promote greater openness and transparency, including talking this issue up with the states.


The Department of Finance and Deregulation is to be the lead agency, with the Information Commissioner (if and when the FOI Reform legislation creating the position passes) to report on  a raft of matters within 12 months. While accepting the need for major changes in copyright policy concerning its own materials, the Government has rejected the recommendation that the Commissioner not Attorney General's Department should be responsible for policy in this area.


Much is made of how the Report's objectives will be advanced by the publication schemes required under the FOI reform bill and relevant guidelines to be issued by the Commissioner. However in case you have missed the point previously made here on many occasions, the legislation is thin on specific publication requirements, the Commissioner "may" (not shall) issue guidelines, and an agency must have regard to (not must act in accordance with) any guidelines issued. The Explanatory Memorandum states  that the lack of prescription or powers to mandate publication are because agencies are in the best position to judge what information they hold should be published. I beg to differ and would feel more confident if a broader range of information to be pro-actively published was specified or the Commissioner had stronger powers.


Notwithstanding this is generally good stuff, albeit part of a long and probably slow journey, in the right direction. While I know why he would say this Opposition Senator Ronaldson's comment , reported in The Australian that" too much of this response is just blah, bureaucracy and boffin-speak,"is well, just blah blah.


We greatly look forward, as the Government now says it's on, to public servants participating in public discussion of issues within their area of expertise- including here on open government.


Update: Stilgherrian in Crikey today under the headline Slow,slow little steps to Gov 2.0 picks up on the endorsement in principle only of the recommendation that all public sector information should be open by default, with the government having to make the case for why information should not be released, that information should be free, easy to discover, freely re-usable, and published in machine-readable formats using open standards.

Monday, May 03, 2010

Australian free speech report card

On World Press Freedom Day, News Ltd boss and Australia's Right to Know leader John Hartigan writing in The Australian provides a report card on progress on free speech issues, suggesting  on the surface little has changed in three three years since he accused the Howard administration of being "the most secretive government we've ever had, even in wartime."


However Hartigan says that underneath, the Rudd government has worked hard at change: "It cannot be accused of laziness or inertia on freedom of speech, and we should celebrate this."Hartigan goes on to give the Government a tick on Freedom of Information reform, although the Reform Bill is yet to pass, and as he says,everything depends on implementation. Overall he gives the Federal government a good report card for free speech so far: "The signs are good, but there's still a long way to go, not least because we were coming from so far behind in the first place." And a special gong for Queensland on FOI reform results with NSW poised to get a new regime underway on 1 July.


In my opinion this assessment of the Federal government is on the overly generous side on FOI and other reforms still in the legislative pipeline. On FOI, talked about for the first year or so as a high priority,  there is nothing concrete to show for two and a half years in office except the abolition of conclusive certificates  and the appointment of John McMillan as Information Commissioner Designate.

 The yet to pass Reform Bill is generally good and welcome but equally noteworthy for unexplained omissions, to mention just a few: the failure to extend the Act to the administration of Parliament, the absence of offence provisions for improperly seeking to influence decisions on access and leaving untouched a provision that empowers a minister to decide on access to an agency's documents, no change in time limits that remain as they were almost 30 years ago, proactive publication requirements that lack teeth and apart from disclosure logs and information about statutory appointments leave it to government agencies to decide what should be published "because they know best." I could go on....
I think on results it's a C rather than what sounds like a B from Hartigan mainly awarded on the basis of effort. 

Margaret Simons on The Content Makers raises another issue about report cards:

.. I could not help feeling, as I read Harto’s fine words, what a report card on the role of newspaper executives and editors would look like. What grade would we give News Limited, and other Right to Know Coalition partners, on issues such as invasion of privacy (thus sabotaging any attempt to forestall restrictive privacy legislation). Sadly, when it comes to media campaigns, the moral highground is awfully slippery.

Saturday, May 01, 2010

China blocks me!


I'm in Hong Kong this week after 15 days in China (fantastic and all that) where I found that access to Open and Shut is blocked.The thought of Chinese officials beavering away to find me in the blogosphere, making sense of my ramblings and then cutting  access seems a bit bizarre.

Subversive? Moi?

The explanation would have to be that key word blocks are in place for terms like freedom of information, open government, etc. so I'm not taking the ban personally as either a slight or compliment. But if anyone in China is reading, I'd be glad to hear your side of the story.

This blog will resume something close to normal transmission shortly.

Update: Shane McLeod of the ABC tells me there is a blanket block in China on blogs hosted on Blogspot and similar blog sites. This post by John Prandato refers to China's recent attempts to tighten the grip following the departure of Google (I could use Google in China but selective links were blocked):


Earlier this month, China quietly acknowledged the creation of a new “Internet news coordination bureau,” officially responsible for “guidance, coordination and other work related to the construction and management of Web culture.” And just this week, China’s legislature proposed an amendment to the Law on Guarding State Secrets that would require telecommunications companies to “detect, report and delete” leaks of “state secrets,” broadly defined by the government as “information concerning national security and interests that, if released, would harm the country’s security and interests.” These measures are just the latest pieces fastened to a massive regulatory system, much to the chagrin of the international human rights community and many of China’s 400 million Internet users.
Prandato (and McLeod) mention that net savvy locals get around the block problem through virtual private networks, but two weeks enjoying other things there meant I never came close to this solution.

Tuesday, April 13, 2010

China bound

I'm in China and Hong Kong for the next couple of weeks so attention to the blogoshere will be a bit more sporadic than usual.