This blog takes an interest in issues associated with Freedom of Information (FOI) and privacy legislation in Australia. Information contained on this site is general in nature and does not constitute legal advice. Follow Peter Timmins on Twitter: @foiguru Follow the open government cause through the Australian Open Government Partnership Network. www.opengovernment.org.au and @opengovau
Search This Blog
Friday, December 14, 2007
Victorian AG: FOI sets new bench marks
My guess is that this requires closer examination. The fine print usually provides further insights, but a week after the media release, the 2006/7 report is yet to be posted on the Department's website. The Age reports one in five internal review applications result in a change in decision and in half the matters that go to the Civil and Administrative Appeals Tribunal, result in a variation of the original decision.
Wednesday, December 12, 2007
Canadian turtles saved, public servant axed but rewarded
The Freedom of Information and Privacy Association and the Campaign for Open Government has given its 2007 Whistleblower Award to Gord McAdams, a former employee of the Ministry of Sustainable Resource Management, who on his last day before retirement after 34 years service, lodged documents in a court proceeding that exposed his then minister as having made an unauthorised exercise of statutory power. It turned the case against the government and
needless to say he was fired on the spot. He eventually reached an out of court settlement which appears to have saved his super.
He also saved a population of painted turtles that would have been wiped out if the minister's approved plan had gone ahead.
In Australia, Federal public servants commit a criminal offence if any fact or document acquired in the course of duty is disclosed without authorisation (Section 70(1) Crimes Act 1914). Allan Kessing, a former officer of the Australian Customs Service, in March 2007, was convicted of an offence for disclosing the contents of documents containing threat assessments and risk analyses of airport security in 2003. Kessing was sentenced to 9 months jail, suspended on entering a good behaviour bond, claims he did not disclose the documents, and intends to appeal.
The recent Independent Audit of Free Speech in Australia identified 335 pieces of legislation which contain secrecy provisions that prevent disclosure of government information. Go figure.
Federal Labor is committed to reform so here's hoping.......
Rudd urged to shake us out of complacency
Let's hope that in 12 months time we might see some better news in the UK press about Australia's human rights record, including Freedom of Information, than this dismal summary by Julian Burnside QC in today's Guardian. The comments by readers at the end of the article won't make any of us feel better either.And what a contrast with reflections on what UK Labour has managed in this respect from Justice Minister Jack Straw - a government proud of its FOI record (Straw doesn't mention a couple of unsuccessful government attempts to water things down), as well as other accomplishments.
Tuesday, December 11, 2007
Political influence in FOI decision making
My review in full is here.
Bissett made quite a point about the manual's comment that ministers may need to be consulted prior to the making of a Freedom of Information determination in some instances.
Bissett said: "The policy will surprise many applicants who believe their FOI requests will be dealt with at arms length of the political process"
I'm afraid FOI applicants who have been labouring under this apprehension haven't picked up on some of the clues that suggest some responses to FOI applications have a significant input from ministers and ministers staff. And it's not just an issue in NSW.
The report on the Independent Audit into the State of Free Speech in Australia included a section in the Freedom of Information chapter about political influence on decision making. It said that while there was nothing untoward in ministers being made aware of FOI applications being processed, the practice of informing them prior to the making of a decision raised the potential for political influence in a direct or indirect way. The Commonwealth Ombudsman in 2005-06 reported that "Complaints to his office concerning applications for access to non-personal documents typically raised concern about the involvement of ministers and their staff in dealing with a particular application". Regular reports on FOI applications are submitted by some agencies to ministers - the Audit had evidence of this happening in Treasury and Defence.
Guidelines on processing applications for Victorian Government agencies issued by the Department of Justice suggest that a brief on any FOI application should be provided to the minister's office 5 days before finalisation.
Quirks in the Federal and Victorian FOI Acts give the minister discretion to decide any FOI application received by a government department. While there is no evidence that this authority is exercised often, if at all, it may provide the justification for bringing FOI matters to the attention of the minister.
In NSW, where the Act gives authority for public servants to decide on access to agency documents, ministers' offices are kept regularly informed about FOI applications on hand and the Premier's Department requires a fortnightly report on FOI work in progress. A NSW Auditor General's Performance Audit report in 2003 expressed concern about possible perceptions of interference in decision making, citing examples in the Ministry of Transport where the then CEO sought to influence determinations, and in the Department of Education and Training where a draft determination was altered following comments from staff of the then minister. These are probably tips of icebergs.
A more significant problem everywhere is that in some agencies public service responsiveness to the government of the day results in a tendency to act in the government's interests by refusing access to potentially controversial or embarrassing documents.
We are still a long way from routine disclosure of information sought by applicants under freedom of information laws.
FOI Editor's investigative journalism rewarded
The series exposed exploitation of workers who were too afraid of being sacked or sent home to speak about abuses to which they were being subjected.
"The judges felt that the ....Award should go to this series because it exemplified the contribution the print media can make to better awareness and protection of human rights in Australia. In writing these articles the journalists contributed to government action and increase in public demand for, the introduction of reforms to the temporary visa system that would better protect the rights of al people coming to Australia".The full list of winners is here.
Monday, December 10, 2007
WA privacy and FOI bills "debated" and onto next stage
The standard of parliamentary debate on any subject varies enormously, but debate on these two bills was, to be polite, "ordinary". The speakers on the Information Privacy Bill (including on occasion the Attorney General who had introduced it) seemed to be scratching around for questions and answers. (The debate is in Legislative Assembly Hansard 27 November. Pages are not numbered. You can find it by reference to time.The debate commenced at 8.34pm and concluded at 10.22pm).
Throughout the almost two hours, no one mentioned the Australian Law Reform Commission inquiry into Australian privacy laws, and the many questions raised in the course of its work since early 2006 about the Federal and other state privacy laws that provide the model for WA. The WA bill will apply to the public and private sector in the handling of health information. The ALRC has pointed out that state laws of this kind overlap the Federal Privacy Act and are one of the causes of complexity and confusion that should be eliminated.
Having waited years for the WA Government to act on an election commitment to introduce privacy laws, it might have been sensible to hold off on this until the ALRC reports in March 2008.
The main point of debate about the Freedom of Information (Amendment) Bill was about the Government's proposal to remove the authority to decide whether a document is exempt from the Information Commissioner and give it to the state Administrative Tribunal. (The debate is in Legislative Assembly Hansard 28 November - in 2 tranches: 3.12pm to 4.03pm and 7.04pm to 7.48pm).
The Opposition took this issue up strongly, pointing out that it ran counter to the views of experts including Rick Snell of the University of Tasmania. The Attorney General said that Snell and others had been consulted about the proposal, but said the critics had wrongly assumed that the state Tribunal would be as legalistic as the Federal Administrative Appeals Tribunal.
I think time will prove the critics right. An Information Commissioner, properly resourced and with statutory clout, has every chance to provide speedy resolution of FOI matters, while the experience everywhere is that tribunals tend to be dominated by lawyers, and prove slow, costly and conservative in the interpretation and application of the law.
It's a stretch to label what transpired in the Assembly after the dinner break (in the 7.04pm - 7.48pm timeslot) as "debate". Those interested in whether WA is getting value for money from its politicians might read this and weep.
What's this - budget papers anyone could understand?
"....(I)f you read... the portfolio budget statements... it's very difficult to connect them with the wider budget papers, it's very difficult to connect them with annual reports, and there is all kinds of basic information that a lot of people in the media - the community whatever - are entitled to have, which is just not accessible"The Minister said he had asked retiring Democrat Senator Andrew Murray, who has a long standing interest in this issue, "to act as a bit of an auditor on these issues for us".
Senator Murray (whose credentials also include a detailed knowledge of Freedom of Information matters) will continue in the Senate until next July. In the course of a debate in the Senate in September, he expressed strong views about the need for greater disclosure of financial management issues, including removal of some discretionary authority of public service chiefs, and greater parliamentary oversight.
Friday, December 07, 2007
How things change, and it's not yet two weeks
Special Minister of State, John Faulkner, said the Government would look at getting rid of the Howard Government $10,000 threshold for anonymous political donations.
"It's all about transparency in the political process. If you have a massive increase to the threshold (from $1500 to $10,000 in legislation passed by Parliament last year), the public has no knowledge of those donations at all. They remain secret. Our party has consistently argued that we oppose those increases in the disclosure threshold".Of course the new Independent Senator Elect Xenophon was right to say that we need to do something more than this with regard to political donations. Xenophon says that political parties that take the available public funding should be subject to restrictions on private donations. And more immediate public disclosure of campaign donations is needed in this day and age. Information is only publicly available following annual returns lodged by political parties. Surely we should expect notification to the Electoral Commission and publication within weeks, particularly donations made during the course of the election campaign.
In the Ministerial Code of Conduct released yesterday, the Prime Minister has set high standards for ministers. (The boffins are obviously struggling at the moment - the Department of Prime Minister and Cabinet website as at the time of posting, hasn't managed to list anything about the Code). However, back to ministerial standards:
"The Australian people are entitled to expect the highest standards of behaviour from their elected representatives in general and ministers in particular".The Code spells out requirements for disclosure of interests, and puts limits on post separation employment for ministers. It's still a bit hazy on a couple of issues such as ministerial advisers and whether they answer to parliament.
However the Government is to introduce an online public register listing lobbyists and who they represent, with an update every six months. Registration will be a prerequisite for contact with the Government. Again a query, why shouldn't we expect notification of new clients immediately? And who is a lobbyist for this purpose?
At least it's a start, although a long way short of best practice - here are a few thoughts from Marian Wilkinson earlier in the year.
As mentioned here previously, WA has a register, Victoria has talked about it, and surprise, surprise, NSW thinks it would be "too hard".
Thursday, December 06, 2007
Victorian Government loses battle over big dollar project reports
This report in The Age provides a summary of a Victorian Court of Appeal decision that progress reports on major projects, prepared by government agencies to provide the basis for a subsequent report to a Cabinet Committee, are not exempt from disclosure under the Freedom of Information Act. The decision comes two and a half years after the documents were sought by the Deputy Leader of the Opposition. In Secretary, Department of Infrastructure v Asher (2007) VSCA272, the Court dismissed the agency's appeal from a Civil and Administrative Tribunal decision that the documents did not qualify as Cabinet documents. The documents had not been prepared for submission to Cabinet, and would not disclose any deliberation or decision of Cabinet.
The Court found that even though the information contained in the departmental reports ended up in a submission to the Cabinet Expenditure Review Committee, and the evidence was that the matter was discussed by the Committee, the documents would not disclose any deliberation by ministers in the Cabinet room, or what was decided by them.
Importantly, the decision also gives weight to the objects of the Act and the description in Section 3 of exemptions as those "necessary for the protection of essential public interests".
Justice Buchanan (at 7) commented:
"I can readily understand that it is necessary for the protection of an essential public interest to prevent the disclosure of documents revealing views expressed by members of Cabinet as to a matter and the manner in which Cabinet treats and uses information placed before it. I am unable to see, however, that the disclosure of a document placed before Cabinet, without any indication that Cabinet even read the document, let alone how Cabinet dealt with the document, could jeopardise any public interest".
Today Reserve Bank, tomorrow who knows?
A Freedom of Information request in 2004 resulted in the issue of a conclusive certificate by the former Treasurer to exempt minutes on grounds that disclosure would be contrary to the public interest.
As the Australian Financial Review in an editorial today reminds us
"The changing of the guard in Canberra gives government and statutory agencies some breathing space for some overdue renovations".Where this might take us who knows?
However the release this week of the United States National Intelligence Estimate on Iran's nuclear intentions and capabilities, is another reminder of scope for a more mature view about the benefits of transparency. The Estimate, based on the views of the US Intelligence community is that Iran abandoned its nuclear program some years ago. Although it acknowledges that Iran may have plans for the future, these findings have put the President on the back foot given his statements about Iran and nuclear weapons over the last few years.
Why was the report released? Here is an extract from the statement issued by the Principal Deputy Director:
"The decision to release unclassified conclusions from any NIE is based upon weighing the importance of the information to open discussions about our national security against the necessity to protect classified information and the sources and methods used to collect intelligence......The decision to release (this Estimate) was made when it was determined that doing so was in the interest of our nation's security. The Intelligence Community is on the record with numerous statements based on our 2005 assessment of Iran. Since our understanding or Iran's capabilities has changed, we thought it was important to release this information to ensure an accurate presentation is available".Something our own Office of National Assessments (and other agencies) might aspire to.
Tuesday, December 04, 2007
FOI (and privacy) a responsibility of the Prime Minister
The detail of how this all works out with the Special Minister of State, Senator Faulkner, remains to be seen. What is clear is that it should ensure a new and different perspective is brought to bear.
Both these functions have since inception been part of the Attorney General's portfolio. There is a chance at least that they will now be seen as matters of public management. FOI in particular has suffered in the Federal (and most state) jurisdictions because it has been primarily seen as a matter of administrative law. Lawyers have a role in all this but policy about how to make government more open and accountable and how to create and implement an FOI Act to achieve this purpose shouldn't be dominated by legal advice or lawyer considerations.
In NSW, this was recognised from the start, with Nick Greiner the then Premier, ensuring responsibility for FOI rested with him and his department. It gave FOI a good start, although legal perspectives almost inevitably soon emerged and assumed prime importance pretty quickly. There has also been a failure of leadership ever since to ensure that FOI acheives its objectives.
I'm sure Senator Faulkner recognises the opportunities and dangers in all this.
Privacy law reform - pushing uphill with a sharp stick
The Australian Law Reform Commission is examining Australia's privacy laws - long out of date and designed before the arrival of these social networking sites.
As everyone has been warned, what goes up on the net is hard to retrieve. Some bright young things, happy to disclose all to their 'friends' may live to regret what a Google search might show when they seek a position in the work force in 10 or 15 years time.
Friday, November 30, 2007
NSW Premier's faith in FOI improvement misplaced
A month ago, the Premier responded by saying that the head of his department would meet the Ombudsman to discuss concerns about the Act. He continued:
"The recent release of the new FOI Manual is a further step in helping to improve decision making in this area.... The manual ensures that all agencies are fully aware of their obligations and, particularly in relation to exemptions, that they apply the Act".I'm sure the Premier wouldn't consciously mislead the Parliament, but in making this claim he is way off the mark.
The manual, work on which commenced nine years ago, and which is the first guidance issued by the NSW Government on the interpretation and application of the Act in 13 years, will in many respects add to confusion and uncertainty. Rather than improve decision making, it is likely to have the opposite effect.
Even more disappointing than the lack of clear guidance particularly on key exemptions in the Act, is the Government's failure to provide leadership on the importance of FOI and open government principles. The Premier distributed the manual with a memorandum (M2007-11) to ministers asking them to pass it on to staff and agencies in their portfolios.
That was about it - not a word that positions FOI as an important issue in the broader context of accountability and transparency in the conduct of public functions. Public servants are good at reading between the lines. This will be interpreted as 'wink, wink', nothings changed. Saying nothing about these matters conveys an important message from the highest level of government.
The manual (all 376 pages - see FOI Manual 2007) and my comments (having spent close to 20 years working around these issues) are contained in this review .
If the Premier sees the manual as the only required step forward in NSW he is way out of line with the new Federal Government and Labor colleagues in Queensland, Victoria and Western Australia, where significant change is in the air.
Further information on Victorian FOI amendments
Let's hope the Attorney General in developing the standards is a bit more far sighted and pushes the envelope further than whoever dreamed up these unremarkable examples.
Another aspect of the amendments is that the FOI Act exemption relating to personal privacy will see the term 'information concerning personal affairs' replaced with 'personal information', the same term used in privacy legislation.
I'm all for consistency of this kind but one potential problem is that the definition of personal information is broad enough to cover any information about a public servant, minister or other public office holder. It should be made clear that information about the conduct of public functions isn't personal information for FOI purposes.
Victoria isn't following the example of Western Australia where the FOI Act (schedule 1 clause 3) exempts personal information subject to a number of exceptions including where disclosure would reveal information about an officer of an agency and things done in the course of performing official functions.
Another amendment (clause 20) would enable an agency or a minister to apply to the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal for an order declaring a person to be a vexatious applicant. The Attorney General's consent to the application is required. The Tribunal will have power to declare someone vexatious where satisfied that over a period of time the person has made repeated FOI requests or applications which abuse the rights of access. Where an order is issued conditions can be imposed on the making of further FOI applications.
Thanks to a Victorian reader for the links.
Thursday, November 29, 2007
Great new bold move on the FOI front
In suggesting yesterday that Kevin Rudd would need some input on culture change and FOI reform from some source uncluttered by past 'closed government' experience, I couldn't have thought of anyone better than Senator John Faulkner, the new Special Minister of State and Cabinet Secretary.At the Prime Minister-Elect's media conference today he announced that Senator Faulkner would have responsibility, among others, for the integrity functions within government, particularly freedom of information reforms.
Senator Faulkner has spent years on Senate Estimates committees listening to explanations about why even the Senate couldn't be given details about the performance of government functions. He knows the public service well, and the tricks of the trade.
This appointment will give some real meaning to the Government's commitment to change. Congratulations.
Wednesday, November 28, 2007
Era over with changing of the guard
Ross Gittins in "A vote for honesty and decency" in today's Sydney Morning Herald"
Alan Mitchell in "All eyes on public scrutiny" (no link available) in today's Australian Financial Review:I believe standards of honesty and decency fell under Howard. They were hardly very high under his Labor predecessors, but they declined further under a man who, to all outward appearance, radiated respectability. He was a tricky man, leaving you with a certain impression but then later protesting that you had failed to read his lawyerly words carefully enough.
How many times were we misled? There were the non-core promises, the children overboard, the Tampa (which, for all Howard's ministers knew, may have been carrying terrorists), the weapons of mass destruction and the probably illegal invasion of Iraq, the AWB scandal (which no minister had any knowledge of) and the promise to keep interest rates at record lows.
Howard was never told and so was never responsible. The buck always stopped elsewhere. As to decency, we had the brutal treatment of asylum seekers, the trampling of the legal rights of David Hicks and others, the shameful treatment of Dr Mohamed Haneef.
The Howard Government ruled by fear and behind-the-scenes bullying of bureaucrats, journalists, business economists and business people. It raised the abuse of incumbency to new heights, especially taxpayer-funded market research and political advertising.
..it is good to have washed away the stench of the AWB scandal, the Immigration Department's thuggish incompetence, and all the rest of the Howard government's tackiness. Kevin Rudd and his government brimming with enthusiasm for open, decent and accountable government.I would just add that in order to get there the new PM should be taking advice, not just from the secretaries of the Department of Prime Minister and Cabinet and the Treasury, and from those in the Attorney General's Department who have a tendency to see these issues through a legal prism. A broader perspective, uncluttered by involvement in the closed government Howard era, will be necessary if this sort of change agenda is to be achieved.
Labor is committed to implementing law reform commission's 1996 recommendations to strengthen the federal FOI law. It also promises to protect whistleblowers and "drive a culture shift across the bureaucracy to promote a pro-disclosure culture".
It is that last promise that will be the most difficult and most important. And it is Rudd who'll have to do the driving. Only when he has shown repeatedly his commitment to openness, despite the short-term political costs, will ministers and public servants start to change their behaviour in ways that increase the life exptency of his government.
It is difficult but surely not impossible".
Tuesday, November 27, 2007
Rudd serious about encouraging a culture of disclosure
This is starting to sound serious.KEVIN RUDD: ...I'm determined that we can actually do better with some decency in the standards of government.
I also know, it's very easy to say those things before an election, then you become a government and you think well it's all a bit difficult now. But let me just give you one core example. I'm determined to do something about freedom of information. This is notoriously seen as something that executive governments don't like because it causes information to go out which might be embarrassing. I'd like to, by contrast, encourage a culture of disclosure within government departments.
I'm determined that we can actually do better with some decency in the standards of government.
I also know, it's very easy to say those things before an election, then you become a government and you think well it's all a bit difficult now. But let me just give you one core example. I'm determined to do something about freedom of information. This is notoriously seen as something that executive governments don't like because it causes information to go out which might be embarrassing. I'd like to, by contrast, encourage a culture of disclosure within government departments.
KERRY O'BRIEN: That of course can turn around very quickly to bite you and others have made promises like that and then recanted when they've seen how much potential it has to hurt.
KEVIN RUDD: I understand that but a lot of the bite is in the shock value of a leaked document which every newspaper editor salivates for and not to mention people who present programs like yours.
KERRY O'BRIEN: We'll take what we can get but there's been pretty slim pickings in recent decades, not just years.
KEVIN RUDD: I'm not being unrealistic about this but if there is information in government departments which is not critical to the decision making process, then ..
KERRY O'BRIEN: Then it gets down to people's definitions of what's critical to the process.
KEVIN RUDD: That's true but that parameter has been written very narrowly in recent times and I just think there is a body of information in the political domain which can be put out there into the public.
Wisdom from international conference in NZ
Some papers and abstracts are available on the program page (including a paper by Megan Carter, an Australian FOI consultant"FOI with Bite: Recipes for Openness see here). The Day three discussion 'Policy advice and politically sensitive requests', is of particular relevance given some of the recent controversy over this type of information in Australia. The Commonwealth Ombudsman ('Design of effective oversight bodies') and Deputy Victorian Ombudsman ('Investigations into systemic FOI problems') also spoke on Day three.
Professor Alasdair Roberts of Syracuse University, in the US is regarded as one of the leading authorities on the subject. On the eve of the conference Roberts commented that while 70 countries now have FOI laws, few if any, have their laws working successfully: "the adoption of a law is one thing but making it work is another, these laws are complicated devices and need a lot of care and attention to work properly". Roberts said that privatisation has moved many organisations that continue to conduct public functions, outside the scope of FOI law.
Roberts says that we need better research of how well FOI works in practice, who uses FOI, and what they do with the information when they get it. The full text of Roberts paper at the conference is available on the Day two program page.
Another event to coincide with the conference is the publication of a new book by Nicola White "Free and Frank" about FOI in New Zealand. NZ is often held up as an example of a system where FOI works much more effectively than in Australia. However in this article in the New Zealand Herald, White comments that a high degree of cynicism marks the relationship between those who make, and those who deal with, documents that may have political impact. "Those making requests felt it was being abused in terms of information that was not being released, for which there was no effective sanction. Those in government saw manipulation by the Opposition bogging them down with fishing expeditions". In a comment in last week's Australian news that the (then) federal government had won a legal battle to avoid disclosure of policy options regarding WorkChoices, White said such a legal fight would be unnecessary in New Zealand where Cabinet documents were available as a matter of course after decisions were made.
White suggests that steps should be taken to avoid a weekly contest about what should and shouldn't be released and the resulting cynicism. More explicit rules are needed about what must or may not be released.
There should be plenty of food for thought for Australian governments from these comments and other observations made during the rest of the week in Wellington.
Sunday, November 25, 2007
New PM needs to set 'tone at the top'
He should tell Dr. Shergold to stop pursuing fanciful arguments about the need for secrecy in government of the kind advanced by him in McKinnon and Secretary Department of Prime Minister and Cabinet (2007) AATA1969 . In that case a number of claims by Dr. Shergold that documents concerning government deliberations should not be disclosed on public interest grounds were rejected by the Deputy President of the Tribunal - that disclosure would reveal deliberations of senior public servants, would mean that proper records would not be created, and that frank and candid advice would not be offered.
He might also ensure that Dr. Ken Henry, Secretary of the Treasury, who is on the public record as saying that FOI is the cause of advice not being always committed to paper, is made aware of the views of the Deputy President of the Administrative Decisions Tribunal that public servants have a duty to record advice to ministers. Dr. Henry told the Canberra Times in January 2006, that FOI requests which he judged were "motivated by desire to either embarrass the Government and Treasurer or the Department" meant that communication on sensitive policy issues was likely to be verbal rather than committed to paper.
The next few weeks and months will be crucial to any new government attempt to get the public service sorted about the importance of openness and transparency.
Message for Howard: it's more than the economy stupid!
The Federal election yesterday in which the Labor Party has swept to power means that what John Howard had to say about anything has been rendered irrelevant with immediate effect.
So it doesn't matter that he failed to make any positive commitment during the campaign to greater transparency and accountability in government, or to freedom of information reform. Howard's party has not only lost government, but Howard himself almost certainly has lost his seat in Parliament.
It doesn't matter either that Peter Costello had 'form' as the minister prepared to argue that freedom of information laws were primarily designed to enable individuals to gain access to information about themselves. Or that he got that wrong, because FOI is essentially about public rights to access information about government's conduct of public functions.
Costello today has announced he won't be a candidate for leader of his party in opposition. He is now effectively a lame duck, as he has plans to pursue a career in commerce at the end of his three year term.
What does matter is that Kevin Rudd and the Labor Party have made commitments to improve Freedom of Information laws, introduce whistleblower protections that work, and ensure executive government is accountable to the Parliament and the public.
The PM elect has emphasised that he plans to govern for all of us. These commitments need to be acted upon promptly.